Powered by i.TV
May 23, 2013

Grey's Anatomy: Losing My Mind

by Jonathan Toomey, posted May 16th 2008 12:50AM

Katherine Heigl and Justin Chambers
(S04E15) "Tell her... tell her the train is leaving the station and she better get on it... yeah." - Webber

I don't know what to think anymore. You know, at the end of Grey's Anatomy when you see the title card for Shonda Rhimes' production company? Have you noticed what it is? Shondaland? It's a roller coaster. How appropriate. I mean, don't get me wrong. Even though I feel like everything on TV is still getting sort of a free pass to some extent due to post writer's strike "hey, at least it's new" syndrome, this was actually a great episode... for the most part. Which I suppose could be interpreted as getting a free pass due to "hey, at least there was a lesbian kiss" syndrome.

Alright, lots to talk about but I feel like getting Meredith and Derek out of the way first. They had another tumor patient for their clinical trial and much like all the others, the brain mass is causing her to act abnormally. In her case? Imaginary boyfriend (not really). Random question regarding these tumor patients though... is there something in the water in Seattle? Is it just me thinking this or are there are lot of brain tumor patients, not to mention severe ones, in upstate Washington? Ones that are so bad that they qualify for Mer and Der's study? I'm just saying, these poor people are coming in by the truckload it seems.

Anyway, the issue was this. After mixing the injectable virus solution, there's only a short window to use it before the solution is dead and useless. The patient was convinced her boyfriend (no pictures, no phone calls, no one has ever seen him - soooooo fake) was coming to see her before the surgery. Derek was willing to give her a few more hours of happy thoughts (since the virus solution wasn't dead yet) and Meredith just wanted to get on with it. She was cold to put it bluntly. It seems like the one thing that's truly bothering Derek is that yeah, he's still in love with Meredith. What's troubling to him is that he can't stand how negative, pessimistic, depressing, and anti-love she is. That's why, when he patched things up with Rose at the end of the episode, he asked if things could be happy and (taking a cue from Sloan) easy.

That being said, Meredith realizes this. She told Wyatt to fix her. Is she broken? To me, that's an odd word to use with a person, but she definitely has issues. With her mother, Ellis. With her sister, Lexie. With Derek. With Cristina. The list goes on. Her mental repair job has been a work in progress all season and it looks like she'll have a better outlook on life by next week's two hour finale. I liked some of the ways that Wyatt was using to describe Meredith. She never called her suicidal - only Meredith used that word. But she did say that Meredith was "careless with her life." Also, she called her a quitter. All very appropriate. I think Meredith saw it as a challenge though, a reason to prove her psychiatrist wrong. Derek too.

The rest of Seattle Grace had its collective panties in a bunch over the arrival of Dr. Walter Tapley, Webber's mentor. The guy is the godfather of cardiothoracic surgery. A real heart transplant rock star. Well guess what? He's old, overweight, has a laundry list of complications, and he needs a few serious valve transplant thing-a-ma-jigs. No one wants to operate on him because there's a very good chance he'll die on the table. So he came to Webber (who was once a young African-American doctor with no real career prospects until he met Dr. Tapley) to guilt him into doing the surgery. Hahn reluctantly agreed and Tapley made it out alive. Beyond that, there wasn't much point to him being there. He was a one-shot character that I didn't really care about and it felt like a lot a filler. You could make the argument that his sole purpose was to bolster George's confidence by the end of the episode, but Webber gave George a pat on the back anyway. Tapley just seemed a little pointless to me.

Now speaking of George, he's still the Chief's intern. Why? For lack of a better term, he's become the Chief's bitch. Running around like a chicken with its head cut off, holding charts, taking calls, e-mailing Adele. Here's what I don't get. George's ultimate concern is advancing his career. Well... he said he's missing out on tons of valuable OR time by doing all this busy work for the Chief. Sure, all the ass-kissing could lead to a promotion but is that really worth the experience he's giving up to get it? I don't see George as that type of person. He needs more than just an atta-boy.

Moving on to Cristina. She has just completely given up. She cleaned the apartment, then went to work and proceeded to do nothing but fill out charts all day. She cares about nothing and doesn't seem to have any desire to get in on a surgery. She even passed on assisting Hahn with Tapley. It seems like Hahn's constant disdain for Yang and the re-emergence of Burke (via that newspaper clipping) has finally taken its toll. I know I often view Yang in a negative light, but that's just how I see her. The whole Burke thing got me wondering though. He was more than just a potential husband for Cristina. Marrying him was a guarantee that she had a mentor and teacher to help further her career. His departure took that away and I think it's finally sinking in for her that Hahn will never teach her in the same way that Preston did. So she's shut down. It's about time she took some of the advice she gave to Lexie and started looking out for herself. She needs to be fierce and get what she wants. It's kind of hypocritical for her to say that stuff to someone while she just sits around and fills out forms.

The one person who was being proactive this episode was Izzie. She finally spilled the beans and told Alex that Rebecca isn't pregnant. This has gotten ridiculous though. I really just can't believe she's still in the picture. The latest development? After asking Sloan for a boob job, he and Izzie swapped stories and figured out that Rebecca must have acute stress disorder. According to Sloan (who's doing his best to no longer be a whore) severe trauma patients can develop it after plastic surgery because they look in a mirror and truly don't know who they are anymore. So Rebecca wants boobs, makes up a pregnancy in her mind, and forgets she already has a kid. She needs a psych eval and Alex looks the other way. I don't get it. He's king of the insensitive a-holes and now he chooses to pity her and ignore the obvious? What's he trying to prove? That he's a man who can handle things? I'm going back to my original prediction - Rebecca is gonna flip out and attack him. I hope anyway. That would make sense to me anyway. And now she's nuts, so it's believable.

Some more thoughts...

  • Andre (brain tumor lady's boyfriend) was real. I know it was predictable right from the beginning, but that's just it - it was too predictable. I seriously can't believe they went through with that. I mean, the writers went out of their way to establish him as symptom of the brain tumor. When he showed up, I laughed.
  • I also laughed at that scene when Meredith and Lexie had it out in the bathroom and Dr. Wyatt was in a stall listening to the whole thing.
  • Bailey and Tucker arguing is boring to me. It's the same thing every time. The one positive thing to come out of it is seeing George interact with Tucker Jr. O'Malley is gonna make a good father some day.

And then there was that kiss. Honestly, it was anti-climactic. Ever since Addison made the comment to Callie, you knew it was going to happen. Sure, all the threesome jokes were funny but it was still kind of like, "oh look - it's finally happening." Makes you wonder what Hahn was discussing with Wyatt when Meredith walked in on her session. It's worth noting that it was Hahn who initiated the smooch, although Callie (and Sloan) both seemed to enjoy it. I'm sure some people will argue that it's clichéd since it's the two moderately overweight, sort of attractive, kind of butch, female characters who locked lips, but whatever. It'll get people talking and Grey's Anatomy needs that bad. Besides, didn't you read my first paragraph? "Hey, at least there was a lesbian kiss" syndrome = free pass.

Most ridculous part of this episode?
Rebecca. Period.390 (58.3%)
Andre is real!94 (14.1%)
Webber's "get on the love train" text message.131 (19.6%)
Sloan turning over a new leaf - yeah right.54 (8.1%)

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

23 Comments

Filter by:
Nathania

People wouldn't have to live in the state of washington to go to Seattle Grace for a clinical trial. People travel all over the United States for clinical trials - especially when it's their only hope.

May 24 2008 at 8:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
AT

My link failed. I intended to link to this reference to the L.A. Law kiss: http://www.afterellen.com/archive/ellen/column/2005/3/backintheday.html
YouTube video here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7xpeY_4I_U

May 21 2008 at 5:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
AT

I found the kiss anticlimactic because it was closed mouth, on the lips, and because there was no chemistry. If it was supposed to simply be a show for Sloan, it worked. If it was supposed to indicate Hahn's interest, it failed. Callie appeared to have enjoyed it, but then, maybe it was the flattery she enjoyed. The kiss didn't look like an enjoyable one.
The recent kiss between the two Sixes on Battlestar Galactica was hotter, and not because it was Tricia Helfer "kissing" herself.

I've got news for Georgia and possibly others:
The first girl-girl kiss on primetime happened in 1991 on NBC's L.A. Law (I remembered the kiss, Googled it for exact year because I recalled that it was either the late 80s or early 90s). That was 17 years ago. This isn't new. It was a huge deal back then. Currently it seems that two women kissing on TV is done either for shock value or as a political statement, both often unsuccessfully, IMO. Occasionally it's an integral part of the plot and done well because it's not meant to be a big deal, just two people kissing.

I do agree that it's possible that the show is trying to prove that it's not anti-gay. It could be that they're still doing damage control over the T.R. Knight/ Isaiah Washington debacle. I don't want to call anyone "closed minded" here. Sometimes things are just out of peoples' comfort zones because it's not what they're used to or what they're familiar with.

The episode was mediocre but I did like the Ava/Rebecca plot. I didn't like Rose and Derek going off together. It felt like she gave in too easily. It didn't feel real.

Oh, and Jonathan: George is always someone's bitch.

May 21 2008 at 5:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
amy

Excuse you Jenny, but a size 0 or 2 may not be typical because of the supersize trend and America's growing problem of obesity, but it certainly is a normal size.

I'm a 0 or 2 depending on the store or brand. I am not anorexic, I eat what I want and get a normal amount of exercise. Who the hell are you to say what size is normal?

I am so sick of people bashing on thinner folk because heavier people feel sorry for themselves.

Women come in all shapes and sizes, and Grey's Anatomy does a great job of showcasing that. Torres, Hahn, and Bailey happen to be representing the larger girls and there's nothing wrong with that.

May 20 2008 at 2:03 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to amy's comment
andy513

amy size 0 and size 2 is not the average, as much as the mags and movies and you know those people who know what we should look like. you dont have to be anorexic to be a size 2 or 0. callie and hahn are not overweight. personally i think callie is the hottest girl there, izzie i would love to take to mama. everyone there is beautiful, (though mer and sandra oh always look like death rolled over. i know they are meant to be depressed and such, but some bright coloured make up please)

ok mr reviewer you are dire!!!! how can you not love that story, as predictible as it was when everyone else convinced her it was an illusion she broke down so hard. that there was strong enough acting to make you know that feeling. andre being real was a message to meridith. and she listened.

i personally can not stand mer and der. they are not meant to be. but everyone else does so i guess we are going to have it

anyways we are back to good old grey's we've loved from the first episode. on to the finale

May 20 2008 at 4:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Laura

Michelle; I have to disagree. If Georgia has the right to find the show offensive, then we have the right to find her comments offensive.
I'm not gay, or a man, and I still found the kiss kinda hot. Probably because Mark was watching. But it fit the plot and didn't seem to be just for the shock value.
I thought the Andre plot was stupid and contrived, though. She made the comment that his phone was off because he was on the plane. OK, she has a phone number. Call the phone number, let sis and the doctors hear his message. While it doesn't prove that Andre is her boyfriend, it does prove that Andre exists. For Pete's sake, in this day and age, why didn't anybody google him? Why didn't anyone check the cruise ship records? Stupid, stupid, stupid. The story line actually would have been much more touching if he really had been fake. But maybe they couldn't think of anything else to send Meredith back to therapy. I groaned out loud when Andre showed up because I was so disappointed that they would do something so predictable.
So, bets are on for a season finale that has the cancer therapy finally working, Mer and Derek sharing the champagne and of course sleeping with each other again.

Although predictable, that wouldn't disappoint me. I do not like Rose. She sleeps with him because of something somebody else says, finally looks like she is getting a spine when she tells him off, and then just goes "oh, OK" in response to his happy/easy speech. She deserves the heartache she is so obviously going to get.

May 18 2008 at 5:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Paisley

I actually liked this week's epi, reminded me finally of some of the epis from previous seasons. Especially with Meredith confronting her psychiatrist in the bathroom while she's peeing so she can get her chart back! Of course there has to be proof of her brokeness by having Lexi come in show the psychiatrist exactly why they are so disfunctional and broken.

The kiss between Hahn and callie didn't bother me, I just figured it was perhaps some foreshadowing since it's been said since the beginning that Hahn's character was maybe supposed to be gay....and it seems that even tho Hahn is all flirty with Sloan, mentioning threesomes that perhaps there is some jealousy there, because she told callie she doesn't make friends easily and she was mad that callie didn't tell her about sloan in the first place.

And I seriously am offended that you called Callie and Hahn moderately overweight! Dude seriously that is just wrong! Not everyone lives on salad and is a size zero! Did you see Callie dancing in her underwear?? She's a curvy girl, but I did not see rolls of fat! Sheesh.

I don't think they've ever said where the patients for the tumor trial are from. I also assumed that they were from all over the country as the trial would be their last chance to do something about a condition that there is no hope for.

yeah Andre showing up was predictable but I think it was still heartbreaking that she thought at the end that he wasn't real, and died thinking that.

I too am sick of Bailey and her hubby arguing. He's on a date with someone else, and she's still arguing about who made sacrifices etc.

I thought Alex was so mad at Izzie about the Rebecca pregnancy thing because he finally had a hope for some kind of family. The writers have never really mentioned much about his past..so I think he'd be quite willing to believe the fake baby bit. I hope Rececca does go crazy soon because I am sick of this storyline. Enough already!

May 18 2008 at 12:32 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Paisley's comment
Jenny

Yes, Sara Ramirez, who plays Callie is reported to be a Size 12, which is SMALLER than the average American woman. How does that make her "moderately overweight"??????

When compared with the other unhealthily thin actresses (a size 0 or 2 is NOT a normal or typical weight), she appears large, but if you met her on the street, I bet she'd look thin to you.

May 18 2008 at 10:11 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
nattyff

Sorry, with MICHELLE!!! :)

May 17 2008 at 3:38 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
nattyff

I'm with michelle on these one.

May 17 2008 at 3:36 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Borat

I don't care what anybody else thinks, but Callie is REALLY HOT.Not everyone likes a skinny girl.

May 16 2008 at 6:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
MICHELLE

Hey Nick,

ummm.
sensitive much... Georgia was simply expressing her feelings in a very non-offensive way. I mean this is America right? Free speech and all. Personally I don't see how her comments were offensive or unintelligent. Lighten up dude.

May 16 2008 at 4:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners