Powered by i.TV
May 21, 2012

E-Ring: Escape and Evade

by Adam Finley, posted Oct 6th 2005 9:25AM

E-RingIt's a sin for any screenwriter to bring in a deus ex machina, but to bring one in no less than thirty-eight times in a single episode is incredibly brave. Last night's episode of E-Ring placed JT (Benjamin Bratt) near the Iran/Iraq border to investigate a Special Forces team who were allegedly, and illegally, crossing the border into Iran.


JT is soon captured by Iranians, but manages to escape by grabbing a knife from a man's pocket, cutting the ropes around his own wrists, knocking the man over, stabbing the man, grabbing the man's machine gun, and shooting down three more men, all in about ten seconds. I've never been a marine, but apparently studying magician David Copperfield is a major part of the training. I expected JT to then stand up, throw a gauntlet onto the ground and disappear in a cloud of smoke, or maybe scale down a cliff wall using an ever-extending wad of handkerchiefs from his lapel pocket.

JT miraculously runs into a young Iranian goat herder who speaks fluent English. They hide from Iranians by laying behind a water trough, which is a good lesson if you ever find yourself lost in that region and you want to avoid capture. Simply hide behind something, because apparently Iranians won't actually leave their vehicles to look behind things. In the end JT is rescued, which we all know he would be because he's the main character.

The promotions for E-Ring seemed to imply that it would be a realistic look at how the Pentagon operates, but it's really an hour-long melodrama where complex issues are all resolved by the show's end. I don't think that makes for the best television, but if that's the way the creators want the show to run, then that's their prerogavtive. The question is whether or not setting this military fantasy in the present day while conflict still rages on overseas is simply a form of escapist entertainment, or an insult to the profound complexities our troops find themselves mired in day after day.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

8 Comments

Filter by:
Bruce Wayne-Johnson

I havent seen this new one but the first 2 I saw I liked...I think its entertaining like a Jerry Bruckheimer show should be but kind of funny that if true - that it takes this many people to green light missions - that why do American's make fun of George Bush - I didn't see the president in it so far; its all the Pentagon people making these decisions to enter other countries and cause problems if they fail. Anyways - strong as always Dennis Hopper and Ben Bratt...feels like Michael Bay, Tom Clancy and a tounge firmly in cheek - but you know that's what I expect in a 45-minute show. I hope it continues!

October 07 2005 at 6:59 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Joan

I thought your critique of the show was witty and I think it takes the show too seriously to call it an insult to current serving soldiers!

October 06 2005 at 10:40 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Michael

E-Ring wasn't on my cable last night in CA. Instead, Martha Sterwart was on. Anybody else notice this?

October 06 2005 at 2:13 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Edgar

Wow, can you want to hate this show anymore?

October 06 2005 at 1:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners