Powered by i.TV
February 9, 2012
 
CONNECT    

The Five: Things wrong with SNL

by Annie Wu, posted Nov 1st 2005 8:57AM
snlEveryone's favorite "good ol' days" topic for complaint nowadays has got to be Saturday Night Live. "It was so much better in the Gilda Radner days", "Ever since that damn Fallon pretty-boy...", "Bring back Dana Carvey!"... take your pick. I don't think I know anyone that can say that the present season (or any of the seasons in this new millennium) is the best or among the best. It's not that I really hate SNL... I just hate what's happened to it. I love this show and that's why I want to help it so badly, protectively cradling the TV in my arms whenever the show comes on. And before you flip out and say that there's no possible way to cram everything wrong with SNL into a list of five, remember it's the top five. Plenty of things are wrong with the show as of late... After all, the show was once synonymous with "comedy" and now is only synonymous with "beating a dead horse". What went wrong?

Well, here's what I think. In no particular order (because everything's equally horrible)...

Stupid theme songs:
Why does every returning character have a damn theme song now? Merv the Perv, Debbie Downer, The Couple That Should Be Divorced, and last Saturday's Carol ("I'm CAAAROL!") for example. A few years ago, these were reserved for fake talk show segments where theme songs actually made sense (like "Brian Fellows"), but now they're everywhere. I throw up a little in my mouth whenever I hear one because it's pretty much warning the audience that there's a one-joke character coming up. Merv the Perv does a bunch of really gross jokes, Debbie Downer has those trumpet noises and a joke about feline AIDS, the angry couple fights and then has crazy sex, blah blah blah. Throwing in lame theme songs just adds insult to injury.

Misuse of talent:
Okay, I really only have one complaint about this... Darrell Hammond seems like the old guy that just tags along now. He does some amazing impressions but rarely gets the chance to show it because he's always stuck with generic anchor/pundit roles. When he's not doing those impressions, he gets stuck doing tiny roles. It actually hurts me to see him in certain sketches when he pops up with maybe one or two lines and then walks off.

We get it! Now shut up!:
I'm sure Finesse Mitchell is a really funny guy, but in order for the viewers to see that, he needs to stop doing those "Haha, this white guy was about to call me Kenan 'cause we're both black" jokes. It was funny the first time but it kind of died after the fiftieth go. Fred Armisen is a pretty funny guy as well, but he has some truly horrible characters. His Fericito character was cute the first time when he popped up during Weekend Update a few years ago, but he definitely did not deserve a sketch of his own. Yeah yeah, you're just "keeding". You're always "keeding". We understand. Now get out. Although the show has always had formulaic character sketches, at least the Spartan cheerleaders had a new cheer every episode.

Terrible characters:
It started sometime before The Falconer and just snowballed from there. I can walk up to anyone in my school and ask, "If you were a hot dawg, would yeh eat yerself?" and we'd immediately break into fits of laughter. However, "Feline AIDS is the number one killer of domestic cats" doesn't bring anything but confused looks and "Man, Debbie Downer is lame" remarks. I think the only quotable recurring thing from the last five years is the "Barry Gibbs Talk Show" theme song ("Talkin' 'bout chest hair... Talkin' 'bout crazy cool medallions!"). Plus, it kind of feels like the writers have gotten stuck on characters that cannot develop any further. I guess they've forgotten the importance of occasionally having characters with depth (yes, even on a show like SNL).

Crappy Weekend Update:
I never really liked Colin. I didn't care much for Norm either. I really liked Jimmy Fallon, but that's just because I thought it was cute how he played with his messy hair whenever he got nervous (I was young. Forgive me). But I think the last great one was Kevin Nealon, because he had that dry delivery that I thought was fantastic. The segment has lost some of that false professionalism that once made it so funny. Sometimes Weekend Update just feels like a drag, time for me to take a potty break if I missed my chance during the last musical performance (admit it, you don't stay for most of the performances).

Alright, I've got my ranting out of my system. Now, it's your turn. What do you consider to be the five greatest flaws of SNL as of late?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

32 Comments

Filter by:
Goon

i'm actually going to dissent and say this current season is the best season they've had in YEARS. i like the current case, perhaps more because Maya Rudolph hasnt been around thanks to her baby... bringing the kids from 'the lonely island' on as writers has made the show a little weirder, new people like Bill Hader and Kristen Wiig are awesome, they're playing more to the strength's of some of the lesser talents like Seth Meyers... Horatio Sanz's 'carol' character is finally a good use of his overacting and giggling... most importantly they've done a whole lot less of the 'talk show' sketches that dominated the shows for the last few years. sure there is usually one or two per episode, but there was a stretch where that was pretty much it. the sketches have been a little shorter and have actually taken twists i wouldnt have expected from SNL. I was really on board the 'SNL sucks' campaign for years, but my roommate and I have actually been going out of our way to watch every new episode.

December 11 2005 at 2:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
kat

I still love the commercials! The Morgan Stanley guy is great and I love Woomba! I think the commercials have been consistently funny for 30 years. I also am tired of Debbie Downer, and the theme-songed sketches as well. I really am tired of the AG duo. Enough already with that. It's old. IN fact, I rarely enjoy the cartoon films. I have high hopes for Bill Heder(LOVED his Pacino and hope for more), and Andy Shamburg(looking forward to more). Tired of Noonie and Noonie too-not funny. Why can't Rachel and others still do the Southie sketches. They've got the accents right, and it could be done without Fallon.

November 27 2005 at 8:33 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Corey

I think that SNL is the best sketch comedy show out, considering it has been running since 1975. Things are bound to become repetitive over what?...30 YEARS! But who cares? For thirty years the people at SNL have been bringing laughter to everyone whether it be with "Cowbell" or "Debbie Downer". These people work hard and are a hell of a lot funnier then you bad-mouthing people. Sure the 70's had some of the best episodes, but the world changes and things from that time just aren't as funny now. Debbie Downer is one of my favourite sketches(the one with Lindsay Lohan is the best though) And although I will admit that political sketches are kind of getting annoying, they are occasionaly funny, and who doesn't like to make of Bush anyways? So for all those who are willing to say that the show sucks, show me something better.

November 22 2005 at 10:21 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
CHRISTIAN

I cringe whenever Horatio is on!!! He is so unproffessional, not funny and a bad actor to boot. Horrible comic timing. Poeler is great but overused. The new guy Sedeikis is VERY funny actually. My fave cast member has to be Will Forte, he cracks me up. I love the "OH NOOOOO" guy. They need to scrap the writers though, most of the cast is just fine, but the writers need to go. Adam Mckay was funny as hell, him and Ferrel were great together, just watch Anchorman for proof. The political stuff needs to go for a bit. And oh, the dancer party sketch with CZJ was Hil ARIOUS!!!!!

November 17 2005 at 4:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jeff

In the early days, there used to be a rule at SNL that anything under 2 minutes stayed in the show. Everyone knew that anyone can do 2 minutes and not put the audience to sleep. I like Tina Fey, but it's time to turn over the reins to someone else. Total revamp time. Keep Tina and Amy, but take 'em off the desk (and Tina off the head writer desk). Horatio? Time to go. Get some more original material/skits and quit falling back on the same old, tired jokes/characters/lines. Strangely enough, the musical guests have really improved this past year or so. The two new guys are great. And, please, get Darrel Hammond in there more. What's with the lack of skits for him? If it isn't Chris Matthews (which is old, thank you very much), what is it that he's doing...that's worthwhile? I keep hoping for just one or two shows that will pull this season out of the mud. Please, Lorne. Please.

November 15 2005 at 2:09 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Steve Dressler

I've been an avid viewer of SNL for 20+ years. The show is still one of the best shows on tv, bar none. I agree that serializing most characters is not always the best idea, but part of that is the relationship between writers/performers/Lorne. It is my understanding that the show enjoys creating notable characters that viewers can attach themselves to. Writers do it as favors to the actors. Actors do it to ensure air-time and keep themselves in the show (besides the end credits.) As for the cast... Lets not forget that everyone was unliked at the beginning. Yes, even Will Ferrell. It was only after he had a serialized character (Craig in the Spartan Cheerleaders) that his talents were noticed and skits were written to revolve around his talents. The cast now has just as much talent as any other cast in the past. Amy Poehler is certainly seems to be the headliner of this crew, but Seth Myers, Fred Armisen, Rachel Dratch and Horatio are far more talented than any of you realize. Go see ASSSSCAT and know for yourself. The rest are as talented also, just spotlighting a few who need recognition. This job requires appeasing a great number of people including sponsors, censors, the greater majority appeal and of course Lorne. After jumping through that many hoops, one begins to appreciate what they still manage to put on the air. I have no doubt that this show is on the upswing. The cast is diverse, has the funniest bunch of women on tv, and the new additions are great performers as well. Jason Sedaikis, Andy Samberg, and Bill Heder are very talented and will surely match up with the already funny female cast. There are clearer skies ahead. Don't fret, little ones.

November 14 2005 at 5:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mary o'sullivan

I remember the "good old days" of SNL when every year there would be a mostly new cast and I would say "Oh, it's not good this year," but.........after one or two shows of each season and getting used to the new cast, it WAS really good (and it was!). I've stopped watching or recording it years ago but every once in a while I turn it on hoping, hoping..... It's so stupid now. Not funny at all. Boring. Why is still show still hanging on? It's time to throw in the towel. Even my 80-year old father when he catches a glimpse of it occasionaly is perplexed. He says it's not funny any more and what ever happened to it? I find the cast is talented but the writing is not.

November 13 2005 at 12:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jordan

I believe that they should not really focused on ONE cast member, because everytime that person leaves, the next season is full of holes. Ferrell, Fallon, Meadows, Morgan, Sandler.....all were the basis of many returning sketches that could no longer be used. Now, don't get me wrong, I'm a total Fallon-Aid (names for Jimmy Fallon fans), so nights when he was in, like, every sketch(or as it seemed) was awesome! However, now that he left, they found themselves a little short on material(What the hell was with "Bear City"). But, whatever the season may be, golden or not, I'll still be religously watching.

November 08 2005 at 3:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
reverse mortgage

cowbell...bring back the cowbell

November 08 2005 at 12:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Helene Unjian

I quit SNL soon after Jimmy Fallon left the show. He was SNL. Never liked it before Jimmy arrived either. Will Farral was ok as Dubya but for the most part he was to reidiculous. Tina Fey was good at up-date with Jimmy as co-anchor but lacks luster with out him. Amy is the star of SNL. Her impressions are priceless. Her talent is wasted on up-date. The best reacurring sketch ever was The Boston Teens. SNL needs to find another Jommy Fallon to stay alive. Helene

November 02 2005 at 10:47 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners