Powered by i.TV
February 8, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Numb3rs: Bones of Contention

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Dec 10th 2005 3:53PM

Skull18 million Native Americans, 1492. 350,000 Native Americans, 1900. 206 human bones. Two truths. Now based on those four facts which flash by as the episodes starts, you'd expect this to be a politically charged story and it was. Who knew that archeology could impact so many things... well, hopefully everyone does at this point. A skull is found at the construction site for a new high school and the truth behind this antiquity has the potential to destroy the history of an entire nation. Or at least shut down a casino.

The skull in question has already gotten a woman killed. A young female museum research tech was examining the skull late at night, when an unknown assailant killed her and stole the artifact. Because the museum is on federal lease, Don and his team were called in. But where was Colby? I know he's not a full member of the cast, but he's still been a pretty big part of every episode up until now. Anyway, a notebook of calculations is found on the body. Using what he knows about carbon dating, Charlie was able to finish what the woman was working on and determines that the stolen skull was somewhere around 10,000 years old. Sounds ridiculous right? Well, if that's true, then it poses some huge problems to the Native American groups in the area - one of which runs a very profitable casino. This developed into a really interesting debate about history, who has to claim to what, and how that claim is determined.

So if the Native American nation is laying claim to a parcel of land, asserting they were the first ones there, a skull older than their recorded history would suggest otherwise. You'd expect them to want this skull. In charge of the local nation is Chief Clearwater and apparently he got in touch with a security guard at the museum. Why you ask? The nation annually removes people from their list of eligible members (meaning those who get a cut from the casino profits) based on the percentage to which they are still Native American. The security guard was one of those disenrolled people. In return for letting Clearwater into the museum so he could take care of the problem, the security guard would be put back on the list. Sounds kind of sleazy, but that's how far they were willing to go in order to maintain their claim.

Beyond the main story line, some more back story on Alan was let out. He's still having trouble dealing with the loss of his wife. Months ago, he and Don packed all her stuff up, but Alan never got rid of it. Another odd omission - there was no mention of the apparent date that Megan and Larry went on. They brought it up at the end of a previous episode, but haven't discussed it since. That really needs to go somewhere. When those two interact, it's good stuff. Overall, this was probably the best episode of the season, save for the one that guest-starred Lou Diamond Phillips.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

3 Comments

Filter by:
Wade Wofford

This is a sad case of propaganda and media hype making it's way into American popculture. Yes, the "10,000 year old skull" IS loosely based on a real find (the 9,200 yr old Kennewick Man skeleton)... but the premise follows deliberate propaganda by racist hate groups & by politically motivated scientists more than it does reality. No "anomalous" skull would change laws one iota, let alone inspire a coverup by "feaful tribes". Kennewick Man was "claimed" (by a deputy coroner who bumbled the case from day one) to "look White", once he was found to be over 9,000 yrs old this unsupported claim was seized on by white supremicist groups wanting to claim that America was "really a White homeland" & that ancient White firstcomers had been exterminated by Mongoloid invaders (hoping to make the "Conquest of the Americas" seem a tit-fot-tat retaking of White territory rather than the genocide it really is) AND by certain archaeologists trying to fan discontent with a piece of federal legislation called the Native American Graves Repatriation Act (which gave federally recognized Native American tribes.... rather than the archies.... control over "some" Native American skeletons & artifacts found in "part" of the U.S.). SCIENTIFIC STUDY of Kennewick Man proved he was not even vaguely White, that he was NEITHER Caucasian nor even "Caucasoid". He most closely matched Native American, coastal Asian, & Pacific populations. A motley assortment of White racists, neo-pagans, & scientists (politics making odd bedfellows) all pushed the inane conspiracy theory that ancient remains like Kennewick's somehow suggested that Native Americans WEREN'T the first inhabitants of the Americas but that the tribes were covering it up due to fear of losing "special priviledges" & that the govt was going along because the tribes were "somehow" able to coerce them (old myth of an ant raping an elephant?). In reality, ALL evidence (DNA, dental, craniometric, linguistic, etc) says that modern Native Americans ARE descendants of the FIRST arrivals in the Americas. It's unknown... but IRRELEVANT... whether these first arrivals were one people or several peoples who blended together to make Native Americas. So called Native American "priviledge" is just normal U.S. citizens' rights PLUS in some cases "Treaty Rights" extended "some but not all" enrolled members of some U.S. tribes.... Treaty Rights are legal rights the tribes got guaranteed in exchange for giving land to the U.S. SOME (Federally recognized, "Sovereign Nation") Native American tribal GOVTS have "special" rights (re taxation, self rule, etc), but these are merely comparable to what govts of States & U.S. Trust territories like Puerto Rico enjoy. "Indians" don't fear any truth behind ancient skeletons, at most they fear White racism & the effects of a hyped up media frenzy.

December 12 2005 at 1:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Brent McKee

The 10,000 year old skull is based on a real incident - Google "Kennewick Man" for an extremely intriguing story, although it doesn't have the added feature of someone like Chief Clearwater. Clearwater is played by one of my favourite Canadian actors, Graham Greene, who is one of a number of extremely talented Native Canadians in the business today.

December 11 2005 at 11:35 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Evadne

Wasn't really paying attention to the episode, but I was annoyed at everyone's "concern" that Alan had kept his wife's clothes. They were married for decades--why is it wrong for him to want to keep some of her things? Surely Charlie ought to understand a little better than he seemed to, having hidden in a garage for months before and after she died. I missed how this all played out, but something tells me it ended with Alan getting rid of the clothes.

December 11 2005 at 12:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners