Powered by i.TV
May 22, 2012

Project Runway 2: The Lingerie Competition

by Lacy Hall, posted Dec 22nd 2005 11:34AM
project runway leiderhosenHave you ever watched your mom cook in the kitchen? You get to find out all her little tricks, like how she puts ketchup inthe baked beans, or how the secret ingredient in her trademark casserole is actually Cheez Whiz. Sometimes seeing how things are made takes the appeal out of them. Lingerie is the same way. It's sexy when you skip to the end-product, but not so much when you witness all the emotional breakdowns that occur while making a garter belt.

 

For this week's competition, the designers were given 30 minutes to draft a concept for a new line of lingerie. They then had to present their ideas to Heidi, who would choose 4 designers to develop the best ideas. The designers would then pick teams from the remaining contestants to help design their lingerie lines.

Heidi chose Daniel V. who had a "Revenge" concept, which actually sounded pretty cool. It was basically lingerie that was supposed to look like a jilted girlfriend had raided her ex-boyfriend's closet and cut up his old dress shirts and ties, turning them into bras and panties. Santino was the second pick who concepted a "Heidi's Homeland" idea that basically supposed to be sexy leiderhosen. But more on that later. Diana (who knew she ever thought about sex) concepted a "Goddess" design which was basically S&M meets green billowy fabric. (Side note- Every time I say "billowy fabric" I think of Deb in Napoleon Dynamite.) And finally, Daniel Franco squeaked in with his "Lovemaking" idea. Daniel absolutely seduced Heidi with this concept. It was one of the weirdest moments in reality television history. Here is this gorgeous supermodelwho is 18 months pregnant, and this little designer man is sitting next to her explaining that there is a difference between humping and making love, and that he wants to make lingerie to represent lovemaking. The whole time he's explaining this to her, he's staring deeply into her eyes and shooting indecent thoughts into her brain with his evil laser tractor beams. I think the last thing he said was, "Heidi, I would love to show you something beautiful." Heidi was speechless. She just turned to the camera and smiled.

Right away there was trouble with Santino's team. Santino almost lost his designs at the fabric store, and he started to fight with his teammate Emmett from the get-go. He didn't think that Emmett was very good at sewing, while Emmett doubted Santino's concept. Santino does not design things that are simple and he has a tendency to over-embelish and that is never good when designing lingerie. As Tim writes on his blog, he final designs lacked sex appeal and looked like "marzipan costumes for a BlackForest production of The Nutcracker."

Daniel Franco's team was also riddled with problems, namely Franco's obsessive sewing techniques. He kept putting things together and then taking them apart and then putting them back together. He pushed his teammates, Chloe and Klara, to have about 13 different breakdowns. He just kept telling them to trust his design and leadership and if anything went wrong, he would take the blame.

Daniel V.'s team worked together pretty effortlessly. Although, there were several homo-erotic moments between Daniel and Andrae. But I was happy that this week marked the first episode where Andrae didn't have an emotional breakdown on the runway. Perhaps he was too busy staring deeply into Daniel V.'s hipster bangs to let his emotions get out of control. Diana's team (Team SuperNerd) also worked well together on her S&M designs. The only real speed bump came when the models showed up and one of the models (Cara) had to be coached into wearing her assigned garment. She didn't like it because the bottom was a thong, and she thought the top barely covered her tiny boobies. (But it totally did cover her little micro-boobs.) Apparently, this model has been a problem before, and has complained about not liking when her hair is piled on top of her head. Diana's attitude was sorta, "If you don't like to do these things then maybe you need another job." I loved it! Who knew that the SuperNerd had such a big set of balls on her.

At the runway show, Daniel V.'s "Revenge" was the winner, but I think he won by default. I thought his concept didn't really materialize itself well. I thought it just looked like black bras and panties worn with a necktie. Tim thought it looked like a Playboy bunny rip-off and I have to agree. Santino almost got the ax this week with his carnival designs, and I really think that it should have been him that got "outed." During elimination, he almost got into a screaming match with the judges and he blamed everything on Emmett. Daniel Franco, on the other hand, took full responsibility for his lackluster designs (judges thought they looked too Joan Collins and too repetitive). In the end, Daniel Franco got sent home, but he went out with his head held high. He graciously thanked the judges for the(second) opportunity and was greeted backstage by tears from his fellow designers. Even Tim (who came out of nowhere) commended him for his integrity. It really should have been Santino who got sent home. His designs were atrocious and his behavior during elimination was bad, but let's face it...he makes for good TV. Daniel Franco was just too zen for his own good.  

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

10 Comments

Filter by:
Emily

On the concept drawings, I thought Santino's had a possibility. Maybe he was drawing on childhood memories of the bad guy's girlfriend in Chitty-Chitty-Bang-Bang. Anybody remember her? Anyway - as soon as fabric was chosen I knew it would be a disaster. Look at the pic above - lose the middle section and the cap sleeves, make the fabric sheer black with silver trim and maybe it is salvagable. Ok it sucks.

Anyway - judging simply on behavior, Santino should have gone, especially if you add his arrogance and pouting from previous shows. Daniel F is someone who would definitely be easier to work with than Santino. Santino does seem to have more design talent, tho. Won't really know since we won't be seeing anymore of Daniel F.

Why the two week break? The show was in the can before Heidi popped. Didn't she have that baby in May? I googled it real quick and only read the headlines, but I found it curious that InStyle said she had a boy and NYFashion said she had a girl. Which was it?

January 04 2006 at 11:29 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Malcontent

I posted some video highlights here:

http://malcontent.typepad.com/malcontent/2005/12/kneel_before_sa.html

Does anyone else think Santino looked like General Zod last night, or was it just me?

December 22 2005 at 4:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Evadne

Haha, no, it's true Daniel F.'s presentation was very cheesy, but he's just so damn sincere, I didn't mind. I found Santino's more embarrassing to watch because of the blatant brown-nosing. I don't know why everyone (especially Tim and Heidi) gave him so much credit for the concept. And he IS good, so why not come up with, like, a real idea he'd be willing to stand behind?

December 22 2005 at 4:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jamie

I really liked Daniel F. and I must admit that he had me mesmerized with his "lovemaking" premise like Heidi. I think most people watching the episode noticed she had a *moment* when Daniel F. was explaining his idea (how awesome did Heidi look pregnant!) . I was glad he took responsibilty because we all know what a tough spot team leaders were placed in.

Diana's designs were creative but not practical. IMHO it did not seem very easy to get on (or off) especially with the fabric tucked/interwoven in the piece. It was kinda weird.

Daniel V., as someone mentioned before, pretty much won by default. His designs were good but I agreed with Tim that were were "Playboy Bunny".

And Santino. I really have not liked any of his deisgns. His lingerie designs had to be the worst designs ever. I laughed sooo hard when his models came out. I am sure Heidi wanted no part of those designs in any way being associated with her or her homeland. Santino seems very smug and I could not believe how he behaved with the judges. He complained about Emmett, yet when Emmett asked for guidance about how he wanted the design, Santino kept saying do whatever. Why was he surprised when his vision turned out crappy. His team really was let off easy and he should have went.

By the way, did anyone else notice how Santino was dressed like one of the three villains in the Superman movie, the one with the beard?

December 22 2005 at 4:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
doc

For what it's worth Dave, your thoughts echo those of the judges. I think Nina actually said "It's not aesthetically pleasing." about that very outfit. It is not a good representation of what the designers regularly come up with. There is the occasional what were they thinking trainwreck, but there are also some very nice designs. It's an interesting show, produced very well.

I have two theories on why Santino skated by last night. One, his previous weeks work was really good, and overall he is probably ahead of Dan. Or two, there was a producer in the judges ear saying that he is so insane that they have to keep him around for a few more weeks, just to see what happens. That's what makes good tv.

December 22 2005 at 3:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dave Caolo

I've never seen this show, but is the outfit pictured in this post representative of what the contestants regularly come up with? She looks like she murdered and then wore an Ewok. That's supposed to be sexy lingerie? I'd hate to find the person who finds that appealing.

December 22 2005 at 2:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jordan Running

The woman in the photo looks like a Cardassian.

December 22 2005 at 1:49 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Annie W.

Oh maaaan. I almost fell out of my chair when Franco was explaining his idea to Heidi. He's so much cheese. I mean, I love his dedication and passion but he's too much for me. Poor guy. No wonder he got picked on.

Santino's such a jerk. He's good but not BRILLIANT (as proven by this competition), so he should stop pretending he is.

I've taken a liking to Daniel V. I'm not sure why though.

December 22 2005 at 1:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
orimental

It was definitely Santino's time to go this week. While Daniel F's was repetitive, there was still a bit of sex appeal to them. Santino's sexy leiderhosen was just too gimmicky for me. I think what really did Daniel F in was that he took FULL responsibility (like a true leader would do) and basically stated that he was the weakest member (kind of like how Vanessa of London from Texas did last season during the rock star makeover challenge). Also, I think they wanted to make sure that it would be someone brand new to win this season, so it was kind of a perfect opportunity to eliminate him. I'm glad that he was able to leave feeling accomplished. We did get to see what kind of talent and passion he has inside. I just can't imagine what sort of tantrum Santino would unleash if he were eliminated last night. And of course, I will be waiting for it to happen.

December 22 2005 at 1:26 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Evadne

I hope Daniel F. was sincere, because he just about broke my heart, and it would be lame if I was sucked in by a reality show stunt. I love how he interrupted Kara and Chloe just as they were about to sell him out. His pieces really weren't very good this time, either, although he has done some stuff I've really liked; his attention to detail and perfectionism (who would have guessed that a guy who acts like the kindergarten teacher from Half Baked would be a perfectionist?) are pretty endearing, too. In the real world, who wants a shoddily-crafted piece of clothing?

The designs were awful. Santino blatantly pandered to Heidi and it worked--you have to wonder if the producers thought he'd fall on his face if he had to actually turn his suck-up ideas into actual garments. He fell all right, and the pieces were wretched. I liked Diana's--actually, I've liked everything Diana has done, although I can't imagine that she'll win--and the first of the other Daniel's pieces. I'd have voted off Emmett this week, though, because they say he can't sew very well, and the woman who can't sew has a better story.

December 22 2005 at 12:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners