Powered by i.TV
February 9, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Stargate SG-1: The Fourth Horseman, Part 2

by C.K. Sample, III, posted Jan 7th 2006 4:30PM
The second-half of the season premiere of SG-1 aired last night, and I, for one, am dissatisfied with both this episode and the Stargate Atlantis episode that I will comment on in a post following this one. The Stargate series, to me, has always been a good episodic Sci-Fi series, in that they had a consistent big bad guy and each episode is a nicely contained unit that I can watch at any given point in syndication and not feel left out if I hadn't seen the previous or later episodes. Now, what bothers me about this season, is that they've eliminated all their previous big bads in one fell swoop before this season began, so that we are left with a brand new big bad in the form of the Ori, the evil twin siblings of the Ancients.

 

For some reason now, there is too much bleeding into other episodes, and this second half of the season premiere felt like it should have gone on for another episode or two rather than abruptly end as it did. Too many subplots and too many loose ends being tied up much too quickly for my tastes. And the conclusion didn't feel like it was worth the wait of the season-split.

If you'll remember, we left off with an Ori plague stretching its evil grip much too quickly across the globe, Gerak has become a Prior for the Ori and returned to convert the Jaffa to the path of Origin, and the Ancient Orlin, who once made sweet sweet Ancient-love to Samantha Carter, has returned as a little boy (played by Cameron Bright) to help stop the plague, but his human brain is failing under the weight of trying to retain his Ancient knowledge. Notice the odd affectionate love story between Orlin and Samantha. Something about that seems very familiar... Movie rip-off and using the *same* actor to boot.

Anyway, I just thought it a good idea to be upfront with why my review may read a little more negative than normal...

So, here's the story lines:

Carter and Orlin are working to cure the plague, except they really did everything they could last episode, so this story line is really more about Orlin losing his mind. He does help in a conversation with a Prior (played by The Smoking Man) later on, but it's not very convincing for a variety of reasons. They are trying to convince a Prior they have captured that he has served false gods all these years and they have Orlin come and tell the Prior about his past to help convince the Prior that Orlin is an Ancient and that the Ori are evil. This doesn't work, although the Prior reveals that the Ori are coming to take the Ancients down. So, Orlin doesn't really do anything that leads to any results, but he is the emotional show-capper of the episode, as he's lost all his memories, is sitting working on a puzzle as Samantha Carter comes to visit him in what looks to be some sort of home for the senile (as he's the only kid surrounded by really old people) and he doesn't know who she is but asks her to help him with his puzzle (just as he helped SG-1 with their puzzle; oooooh!).

Daniel and Mitchel visit the Sodan warriors for help in capturing a Prior. The beginning of this story line read very oddly, as they glossed over the whole bit where Mitchel had supposedly died and the Sodan were going to worship the Ori and join Origen with very minimal explanation. This is what happens when you cram too much into one episode. In any case, this story line which overlaps with the previous one, contains probably one of the best bits from the episode, when Daniel and Mitchel are taunting the powerless Prior who has been captured. Lots of Farscape-esque quick witty jabs at the adversary. Of course, ultimately, they learn very little from the Prior, he manages to become enraged by Orlin's delving into his past and focuses enough to use his powers to bring the General into his grasp and infect him with the plague, and then Mitchel shoots the Prior dead in the back.

The family spin story line was perhaps the shortest, but the one that linked most nicely from previous episodes. After the Prior infects General Landry with the plague, his daughter, Dr. Lam reveals that she saw her mother recently and felt conflicted because she couldn't tell her mom about what she did, and this was the same thing that angered her about her father in her youth. General Landry had also tried to ply the Prior's heartstrings with a tale of what he gave up to be who he was now, revealing that he regretted missing out on his daughter's childhood, and asking the Prior what he missed from his years of devotion to the Ori.

In the end, the salvation of humanity wasn't earned through the blood sample they grabbed from the Prior or through any of Orlin's work, but instead, Teal'c convinces Gerak that the Ori are false gods and slavemasters, and Gerak comes to earth and proclaims "I die free!" as he slams down his Prior staff, releasing a white light that cures everyone from the plague moments before being engulfed in flames and disappearing.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

8 Comments

Filter by:
Mack Swift

I got a kick out of this episode as well. I like the Ori, we have an enemy with evolved powers; unlike the Goa'uld who used tech to make it look like they had magical god-like powers. SG-1, Earth, and the Milky Way have one hell of an enemy to defeat.

The Goa'uld are still around and are a threat. They're just changing tactics. They run the Trust now and Bhaal's got a few versions of himself running around. I've been privy to Atlantis via Canadian satellite; the Goa'uld are still around and causing problems.

All in all, a good episode and a lot of fun.

January 10 2006 at 12:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Scott

The only thing that really bothered me was the speed at which they were able to mass produce and distribute the cure.

January 10 2006 at 9:17 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bec

Stargate SG-1 has most definetely NOT "jumped the shark". With the departure of Richard Dean Anderson, season 9 was meant to be starting fresh, with new characters, new enemies and new adventures. The Goa'uld were more or less defeated in the season 8 two-parter finale, so really the Goa'uld have no bearing on what goes on in season 9. Baal is still hiding out on Earth and is building up a sizeable army of clones and is preparing to return to his previous "glory".

The Ori are a powerful nemesis who started out much like the Goa'uld, who, in the first season (excluding the Stargate movie) we were introduced to. They had been in power for many thousands of years and when we meet them we are just stepping into their realm. Now, with the Ori, they have been in power in another galaxy for who knows how long, and now have dicovered a new galaxy to which they can convert followers into following their religion of Origin. It is a new, fresh slate to which the writers can work on, and they have done a marvelous job at it.

This episode, The Fourth Horseman, Part 2, was a very well done piece of television, and especially with the task of having so many characters as to which either introduce, carry on their storylines or start them onto new storylines - they did a supurb job. I totally agree when you say that Stargate SG-1 "has always been a good episodic Sci-Fi series, in that they had a consistent big bad guy and each episode is a nicely contained unit that I can watch at any given point in syndication and not feel left out if I hadn't seen the previous or later episodes." You're right - and not much has changed. Stargate is still a phenomenon in the sci-fi world, and it is fair enough to allow them to create new storylines. The Goa'uld had to be defeated eventually, and now theyhave done it in supurb fashion.

As for this "Now, what bothers me about this season, is that they've eliminated all their previous big bads in one fell swoop before this season began, so that we are left with a brand new big bad in the form of the Ori, the evil twin siblings of the Ancients." Is that really a bad thing? Like I said, the Goa'uld had be defeated sooner or later, that was the whole point, basically, of the series, their fight against the Goa'uld. Anyone who wathes television will tell you that for a television show to be sucsessful you cannot just have one storyline, you need many more storylines intertwined to make it a good show. Stargate is exactly that and more. Season 9 is a groundbreaking season filled with suspense and fantastic new characters as well as much-loved old ones. It has not "jumped the shark", it has merely had a revamp and it has worked damn well.

All-in-all, a great season AND a great episode!!

January 08 2006 at 5:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
eva

With the exception of some witty Daniel/Mitchell scenes, this show put me to sleep. I kept looking at the clock, and not in a good way. I didn't think the kid who played Orlen was very good but I thought AT did a great job in her scenes.

And Lou Gossett Jr? All that "Captain Kirk" delivery really had me confused. What was up with that?

I can't believe how they can pretty much talk through this whole show and not say a whole lot. By contrast, Battlestar Galactica, which after the intro was was relatively dialogue laden, still had me on the edge of my seat.

January 08 2006 at 11:26 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kel

Damn it, for some reason I thought it was the Part 1 so I deleted it from my TiVo's To Do list, but luckily it's being re-aired.

Anyone else think SG1 has "clearly" jumped the shark with the Ori.

January 08 2006 at 10:59 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
John B

"Now, what bothers me about this season, is that they've eliminated all their previous big bads in one fell swoop before this season began"

Not Really. Baal is still somewhere on Earth with a bunch of clones of himself.

There are members of The Trust who are unaccounted for.

I was completely satisfied with this episode.

January 07 2006 at 8:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
LC

"In the end, the salvation of humanity wasn't earned through the blood sample they grabbed from the Prior or through any of Orlin's work, but instead, Teal'c convinces Gerak that the Ori are false gods and slavemasters, and Gerak comes to earth and proclaims "I die free!" as he slams down his Prior staff, releasing a white light that cures everyone from the plague moments before being engulfed in flames and disappearing."

Actually it was stated in the episode by the doctor that Geraks sacrafice was what cured everyone in the base. Using Orlins research and I believe the blood sample, as well as studying the way Geraks cure healed, was what allowed them to save the rest of the world, so the cure could not be found without each teams contribution.

January 07 2006 at 5:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jimmy

I completely agree with you: this episode was disappointing on so many levels. It was also a terrible use of a great actor like Louis Gossett, Jr. Stargate has really lost its way this season. First, the Ori are a terrible enemy. They have none of the fun and terror of the Goa'uld -- all the sermonizing just gets on my nerves. Second, while Ben Browder is a great actor he has not meshed at all with the cast. Too often, he's just giving us his Farscape character transplanted to Stargate. In fact, the entire cast just seems to calling in their performances, especially Amanda Tapping; but then, her character has been vastly underused this season (even considering Tapping was out due to pregnancy). The only real bright spot has been Claudia Black as Vala. Black was able to create a fun and exciting character wholly different from what she played on Farscape. It's good she'll be back in Season 10, because otherwise this show seems to have run its course. Better to bow out gracefully than continue past its prime.

January 07 2006 at 5:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners