Katharine Vs. Taylor
Let's get it on...
In his favor: This is one unique cat. Taylor definitely has talent-- he can sing and write. He's already a character who's been parodied on SNL. He has a great, positive attitude. He's the real deal.
Against him: He may just be a little too weird, ya know? The dude is quirky and fun and prematurely grey, but is he really an American Idol? He may be a novelty who is finally starting to wear thin.
In her favor: The girl is cute and has mass market appeal. She's not afraid to show of her gazongas or her legs. She has a terrific voice and a sweet disposition.
Against her: In Taylor's shadow, she is simply uninteresting. She would disappear in the crowd of other twenty-something pop stars already polluting the airwaves.
Who deserves to win?