Powered by i.TV
February 9, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Firefly: Serenity (Parts 1 and 2)

by Keith McDuffee, posted Jun 2nd 2006 11:22AM
firefly serenity
Do not adjust your web browser. You are now entering the Retro Squad, where we are reviewing past episodes of your favorite shows, in order, every week.

(S01E11/S01E12) When I decided to go the route of reviewing the 'Serenity' episodes before 'The Train Job', I wasn't quite sure what Firefly purists would think. Most fans of the series know that Joss Whedon had originally pitched this two-parter to FOX as what would kick off the series, but the execs disagreed. They thought it wasn't the right kind of thing that would draw viewers in for following weeks, so 'The Train Job' was aired first, shuffling off the 'Serenity' episodes well into the season, right before it got canceled.

So, why am I not starting with 'The Train Job'? Because, my friends, this is how the series should have started. This is what makes sense. This is what Joss envisioned as what would start his beloved series, and I can see why. I mean, who introduces characters at the end of the series?

Rather than thrown into the thick of things, meeting characters we know nothing at all about nor how they were brought together, these episodes show how it all began. To those of you who had seen the movie before ever catching the series, first of all, shame on you. Secondly, you shouldn't go into these episodes thinking the movie was a continuation of what happened in the series. Off the top of my head, there are notable changes, such as Simon and River being introduced borught about differently in the movie, while Book is on some other planet, having already known Mal for a long time.

The differences between the movie and the series aren't at all something to complain about. Joss did the right thing in making a movie that both fans of the series and newcomers would enjoy, and he obviously succeeded. But enough about the movie.

What we learn in the opening sequence helps us understand Mal's discontent with the Alliance, something that in other episodes will be touched upon every so often though little (if ever) depicted like this.

Obviously what we come to learn is that everyone on the ship has a reason to hate the Alliance. They're brought together with different purposes in mind, but in the end they all hate and/or fear the Alliance and their hulking ships that threaten each of them in different ways. It's this hatred and fear that Simon and River have for the Alliance that helps Mal in deciding to keep them on board for the long term, even if they might mean more trouble for him.

What really struck me about this show was some of the details put into it to make sci-fi geeks squeal in delight. There is no sound in space, and that's just what you get on Firefly. Being a "companion" is something not commonly looked down upon. It also makes sense that people on these terraformed planets and moons are left with the bare essentials, left to live the lives of those from the late 1800's; the Alliance is evil and the universe isn't rich enough to make everyone live the life of kings.

I also liked how the Reavers were brought into the story in these episodes. We're left with a lot of mystery as to who or what these creatures are, only knowing they are definitely more frightening to everyone than the Alliance. And the escape sequence toward the end of the episodes? Just plain "wow."

Next week, we'll pick up where the show really started out, and we can see how strange it would be now knowing what we know from these two episodes. Then you can tell me if you thought the networks were right in airing that episode first.

Jayne-ism of the episode:
"The only fluid I see here is a puddle of piss refusing to pay our wage!"

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

16 Comments

Filter by:
Dorv

At the end of the day, the man made a conscious choice to make the change.

I can enjoy my DVDs of the TV Show, and I can enjoy my DVD of the Movie. I can enjoy them both as one set of canon if I ignore some continuity screw ups.

Show me one TV Show or Film Continuation of a TV Show thats not without Continuity issues, and I'll be quiet (Instantly, ST:TOS and the associated movies come to my mind as something that was pretty dern good, so I'll be quieter now :)

June 06 2006 at 1:11 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
doc

Horovits, I think you and I have differing definitions of what a Firefly purist is. To me, a Firefly purist is someone who is a fan of the TV show Firefly, period. The purist doesn't give a crap about Joss Whedon, the boards, or any of the ancillary junk that comes along with the community aspect of fandom. I would categorize you as a 'browncoat'. In my mind, there is a big difference. Feel free to disagree.

As to the Lucasian revisionist history people want to tap into in order to avoid pointing out that the almighty Joss just might have dropped the ball, I'm still not buying it. The idea that Simon wasn't telling them the truth about the breakout because he was scared and didn't trust them could theoretically plug the gaping continuity hole, but if you go back to the series, it really doesn't hold up. If he was really so scared and not trusting of these people, why would he tell them his real name, River's real name, that he's a doctor from Osiris, that she's a scary genius he just busted out of the Alliance klink, etc.? That is all more than enough information for them to sell him out with, if they were going to. Knowing whether or not he actually pulled the job off himself is of no matter.

So, if you really want to go on thinking that he was just telling a fib about that business, go ahead, but make sure you add in, 'and by the way, it was the most ham-handed attempt at subterfuge of ever'.

June 05 2006 at 10:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Horovits

Two points:
1) Firefly purists are just fine with "Serenity" (the TV episode) being shown before "The Train Job", in fact we prefer it that way. The order of the episodes as originally aired was chosen so the series would make some sense even though "Serenity" had not aired; when the original pilot is available, watch the show in the order on the DVD. IIRC, when SciFi Channel showed Firefly, they used the DVD order.

2. (This one to Akbar) Joss did a pretty good job of eliminating contradictions between what we *see* in the series and in the film. There's nothing to say Simon was telling the truth in the series, though...

June 03 2006 at 11:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
wakey

imho I'm not completly sure that the movie does lack continuity.

For starters the movies 6 months after the end of the series. Inara has left the ship and Mal is bitter about that and he seems alot more guarded. He certainly seems to be a little harsher with most of the crew than he was in the series. This isnt however a continuity problem, people change over time due to circumstances

As for Simon rescuing River. Yes Simon said he paid someone and in the movie its clear he has help so just because he was involved more than he said he was doesnt mean that the continuity is wrong. In the Series he doesnt trust the crew epecially early on and its certainly in his favour to downplay his role. We do however see in Ariel that hes picked up some skills which more than suggest hes capable of pulling it off. I think if the series had gone on we would have found out he was moe involved than he originally said.

As for being told whats wrong with River, again he doesnt trust the Serenity Crew and the concept is a scary one. Just because he hasnt told them he knows and just because he want to find out medically whats been done rather than just going on what he was told doesnt mean continuity has bee broken

June 03 2006 at 4:45 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dorv

Yeah...

So, at this point, the length of this conversation is way out of proportion with my interest in it.

June 02 2006 at 7:53 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Akbar Fazil

awww, did I go and hurt your feelings?

Buffy? Not my kind of show so I can't say that I ever watched it faithfully. I appreciated its presence and enjoyed a few random episodes my friends had me watch.

Are you trying to state that you are not a sheep since you feel the first season of a untried concept in US tv was not good and had to find its footing?

June 02 2006 at 7:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dorv

Akbar...

Fair enough.

But, I think us "sheep" are sick of being attacked for liking what we like.

Furthermore, I'm no sheep. Did you see the first season of Buffy?

June 02 2006 at 6:33 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Akbar Fazil

Hey Dorv, I dont know how you can possibly think you can read Simon sneaking into the facility, rescuing river himself, knowing a password to stop her from being a berzerker and being told what they did to her against the series saying (paraphrased)
-"I paid people to get her out"
-"I know nothing of what they did to her so lets sneak her into a hospital so I can scan her"
-"My sister an assassin? No way."
-and the many other things in the series that blatently contradict the movie.

again, you people are sheep for thinking Joss can do no wrong.

June 02 2006 at 5:01 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dorv

Come on!!! First, the only major continuity change in the from the TV show to the movie were the details of River's escape. And, after having seen the backstory created in the Movie, you could read the story in 'Serenity 1 & 2' to fit that storyline.

As far as everything else, time as passed. The Sheppard has moved on. Inara moved off of the ship (Which, BTW, was always the event that I attributed Mal's slight change of attitude).

I was one of the DVD converts. I'd been a casual Buffy fan, found Angel in syndication (Never liked the charater on Buffy, didn't think I'd like him on his own show... However, after I started watching it on TNT, I ended up picking up all of the Angel DVDs in the course of about eight weeks). Loved the Series, love the Movie.

But on to actually commenting about "this week's" episode:

Instantly, Kaylee became my favorite character on the show (Anyone want to guess my favorite Buffy/Angel characters? Would it be... Willow and Fred? Yerp (though not as much Willow as Anya and Tara in the end). I was so pissed, as I feel for the practical joke on Simon as well.

My favorite Jayne line? "10 percent of nothing is...let me do the math. Nothing into nothing, carry the nothing..."

Never 'loved' Zoe and Wash until 'War Stories' but Wash's scene with the dinosaurs was great.

Cancelling this show was a greek tragedy, IMHO. I want to know Book's backstory, and I sure as hell want to know what was in Inara's vial of black liquid.

June 02 2006 at 3:01 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dorv

Come on!!! First, the only major continuity change in the from the TV show to the movie were the details of River's escape. And, after having seen the backstory created in the Movie, you could read the story in 'Serenity 1 & 2' to fit that storyline.

As far as everything else, time as passed. The Sheppard has moved on. Inara moved off of the ship (Which, BTW, was always the event that I attributed Mal's slight change of attitude).

I was one of the DVD converts. I'd been a casual Buffy fan, found Angel in syndication (Never liked the charater on Buffy, didn't think I'd like him on his own show... However, after I started watching it on TNT, I ended up picking up all of the Angel DVDs in the course of about eight weeks). Loved the Series, love the Movie.

But on to actually commenting about "this week's" episode:

Instantly, Kaylee became my favorite character on the show (Anyone want to guess my favorite Buffy/Angel characters? Would it be... Willow and Fred? Yerp (though not as much Willow as Anya and Tara in the end). I was so pissed, as I feel for the practical joke on Simon as well.

My favorite Jayne line? "10 percent of nothing is...let me do the math. Nothing into nothing, carry the nothing..."

Never 'loved' Zoe and Wash until 'War Stories' but Wash's scene with the dinosaurs was great.

Cancelling this show was a greek tragedy, IMHO. I want to know Book's backstory, and I sure as hell want to know what was in Inara's vial of black liquid.

June 02 2006 at 2:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners