Powered by i.TV
May 25, 2012

Letterman is better than Leno in every way (except ratings)

by Bob Sassone, posted Jun 16th 2006 5:22PM
Leno and LettermanIt's no secret that Alessandra Stanley of The New York Times is one of the very worst TV critcs in the biz. Her mistakes and bizarre observations are becoming legendary in the media world and blogosphere. And she has another beauty today, as she says that Jay Leno is a better talk show host than David Letterman.

She uses two examples to prove her point. One is the ratiings. Leno has been on top for years while Letterman is always in second place. I don't really want to dignify her analysis by answering it, pointing out that using ratings as an example of something being "better" has never been an accurate portrayal of what is good on television (or in film or in music or in books). Oh, I just did answer. Oh well.
Second, she says that Leno is a better host, even though he's a "terrible interviewer." Um, OK, but isn't interviewing guests kinda of a major part of being a talk show host? You can't just sweep that aside as unimportant. And it points out something I've always said about the Letterman vs. Leno debate: Leno starts off really, really strong (his monologue is better than Letterman's), but gets worse and worse as the hour goes on. Letterman is just the opposite. His show gets better and better as it goes along. And Letterman is a better interviewer than Leno too. Leno goes for the middle America safety zone. Letterman sort of has a "f**k you" attitude, but one that is mainstream at the same time.

This is where Stanley goes off the rails, arguing that Letterman isn't as good because he's resigned to his second place status, he's more cynical than Leno, and guests often want to go on Leno's show instead of Letterman's because they know they'll get more softballs.

Funny, I think those are reasons to watch Letterman. Plus the fact that Leno is completely unfunny, a terrible interviewer, has horrible second bananas (Stuttering John, the people from his "Jaywalking" segments, etc), and everything else.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

31 Comments

Filter by:
Donna Fox

Dave is the Best because he is real. Leno is so phony. I think Dave proves he is the best all the time, but especially with his shows after 911, after his heart surgery, and after his son, Harry was born. I can't imagine Leno having any real emotions about anything! He is a wishy-washy robot.

Donna Fox

June 24 2006 at 2:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jason Anderson

Conan
Letterman
Everything else ever made and put on TV aside from American Idol
Leno
American Idol

In that order.

Letterman is WAAAY better than Leno. Leno sucks more than anything can ever suck. All because of his writers. Plus Kevin is just a useless piece of set furniture. He's no Max or Paul. No way is he even close to Ellen's old and new DJ/sidekick. God, Leno and Kevin just suck. The announcer ain't a shining gem either. Letterman and Conan have great hosts, band leaders and announcers that participate way better than anything on Leno.

June 18 2006 at 2:08 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
John Hewitt

I spent the eighties and early nineties watching Letterman every single night. He was the funniest man on television and his talk show was the only one that seemed to break out of the Carson formula of folksy humor and personable interviews (Which was fine for Carson but terrible for every other show). Leno was a terrible host ever since his first days as a Carson guest host. I could never stand to watch him interview, even though I enjoyed his old stand-up routines.

A lot of time has passed since then, and I have to admit that I now find Leno and Letterman to be equals. Leno is slightly funnier than he used to be and Letterman has fallen a long way from his creative heights. Both of them conduct the most scripted and dull interviews you can think of. I now watch The Daily Show and The Colbert Report for my nightly fix of topical humor and talk. Their interviews aren't scripted (or don''t feel scripted) and the guests seem much more likely to say something interesting because many of their guests actually have something to say.

June 18 2006 at 12:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ildee

Love Letterman!!!

While his monologue is not as good as Leno's...everything else about Dave is top-notch!

Funny, sarcastic,intelligent and entertaining!

June 17 2006 at 11:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Sam

Letterman's a MUCH better interviewer. Anyone who saw him verbally joust with Vince Vaughn and Jennifer Aniston in the span of one week back when they were denying their relationship can easily see the difference between the two. Leno would have just talked about the movie they were plugging; Letterman dared to dig deeper and make the guests a little bit uncomfortable, let their personalities out a little bit, make it different than the same damn scripted interview we see everywhere else.

The only one who approaches him in interviewing skill is Craig Ferguson. But between Leno and Letterman? It's no contest.

June 17 2006 at 2:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Seth

Leno BLOWS.

Although I must say Letterman gets more and more inconsistant as the years go on. Some of his monologue jokes are just terrible.

One of these days, I would like to see a boxed set of old 'Late Night with David Letterman' shows - with a few of the ancient MORNING shows as a bonus. WAY overdue.


June 17 2006 at 12:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Walt

Johnny Carson wasn't even funny the last five years of his show, and David Letterman is channeling those last five years. I do like what Letterman has done with the "Jack Hannah Brings Animals That Surprise And Attack Dave And Dave Is On The Lookout For It". It's the only new schtick in years. Why I'll watch Dave: Top Ten Things. Why Dave is dumb: Will It Float/Is This Anything?/Monologue.

I'll often flip back and forth, and one night about two months ago, they both did the same joke within a minute of each other in the monologue. Dave's audience laughed and laughed and Leno's didn't laugh hard at all. Nearly the same delivery. I didn't think the joke was that funny, and that's why I turned it just when Leno made the same joke.

Also: I have predicted before and I'll do it again, Conan will flame out horribly when he gets his late night promotion. Funny guy, bad talk show host.

Finally, Craig is funny. The funniest monologue, and it almost makes up for the lame stuff that comes after. Interesting how Craig is the only one without supporting on-air talent where it makes you focus on the monologue and later takes away from the rest of the show.

June 17 2006 at 12:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Anne Cristello

I am an ex New Yorker/Jersey resident now living in
Amsterdam in The Netherlands. I can get Jay Leno &
Conan O'Brien via satellite; but, my favorite late
night host is David Letterman. Is there any way for
me to view the show that I'm not aware of? I do view
CBS News via Sky News because Murdoch is kind to US
expatriats so I know it can be done.
Thankyou---Anne Cristello

June 17 2006 at 10:51 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
gkz

When has Leno ever said anything funny when its not written for him on a card? He is not spontaneous and relies completely on prepared material. On the other hand, the best moments of any given Letterman show are when Dave makes random offhand comments. There's a big difference between someone who is good at telling jokes and someone who is funny and original.
It's little wonder why at the Emmy's Jon Stewart said that comedians of his generation look up to Dave the same way Dave looked up to Johnny Carson. Everybody knows that Dave is the original.
Also, Craig Ferguson makes up his entire monologue as he goes, while Conan just reads jokes and jumps around like a monkey when he wants a cheap laugh. Seems to me that it takes a lot more talent to wing 15 minutes of comedy.

June 17 2006 at 10:48 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
glenn

Not that Dave needs me to defend him, but I've been going to bat for him for years now. Leno's audience skews to the dumbed-down demographic. Can you imagine Jay having a segment on "Great Moments in Presidential Speeches"? Would Jay do a spot calling the Vice President "Just a Big Bowl of Bad"? Therein lies the difference.

June 17 2006 at 10:07 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners