Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Dancing with the Stars: Week 3

by Brett Love, posted Sep 27th 2006 7:24AM
Willa Ford(S03E05) Now that two teams have been cut, we're moving to a 90 minute show. It makes for a jam packed evening of dancing. Not much time left to dawdle. Of course, I'm sure there will be plenty of time to get the dawdling in on the results show. Anyway, this week we have the tango and the jive. I was under the impression that the male stars were doing the tango, and the females the jive. But that all went out the window at the end of the show and I'm still not quite sure why. Did I miss some announcement? Set me straight in the comments if I did. For now, on with the show.

Emmit and Cheryl - Coming off a second straight week with good scores, Emmit looks to be a contender, but his travel might be causing a problem for practice. I thought it showed. Emmit seems to struggle with the rigid requirements of something like the tango. He's much better when he is free to go with his natural style. The judges aren't impressed. Len is very disappointed and criticizes the lift, which isn't part of the traditional tango, and is a rule violation. The scores, 7 - 6 - 6. That is a shade lower than what I expected.

monique and LouisMonique and Louis - Monique's mother is coming to watch. Is it just me or does she look like Aretha Franklin? Wow, big start. That jump from the stage was crazy. Their jive seemed a little hectic at times, like Monique might not know exactly where she was, but pretty impressive overall. The judges love it with Len calling it Monique's best. Carrie Ann loved the big jump. The scores, 9 - 9 - 9. A little higher than me, but it was a good performance.

Harry and Ashly - I think the tango should actually work for Harry. A stiff dance for a stiff guy. I didn't really see all the passion Harry was talking about, but he seemed to hit his marks in the dance. Harry is something of the opposite of Emmit. While Harry lacks the natural grace and style, he does have a great work ethic. That lets him excel at the more rigid requirements of something like the tango. The judges disagree somewhat. Bruno criticize his footwork, but likes his performance. Carrie points out the mechanical nature of his dancing. And Len thinks it was great. The scores, 7 - 8 - 7. That works for me.

Willa and Maksim - I think Willa is fighting an uphill battle. She's danced well, but for whatever reason, she just is not getting the fan vote. She's going to really need to knock one out of the park to get out of the bottom three. Her diner girl outfit is really cute. They are really good together tonight. Really nice timing. The judges disagree again. Carrie calls Willa the best dancer in the group, but criticizes the lift. It's against the rules. Here is our theme for tonight. Len isn't impressed. Bruno loves it. The scores, 7 - 7 - 8. I thought that was low. It doesn't bode well for Willa's chances.

Jerry and Kym - And here is Willa's opposite. While Jerry has struggled with the dancing, the fan vote has been carrying him. I think the tango helps Jerry, but it is still pretty clear that he is the weakest dancer. Those fan chants of "Jerry, Jerry, Jerry" at the end do count for something though. Bruno thinks it's more Pink Panther than James Bond, but entertaining. Carrie agrees. Len also praises the entertainment value, and compliments Jerry's footwork. The scores, 7 - 7 - 7. I think that's high.

Sara and TonySara and Tony - After two weeks, I'm still not sure what to make of Sara. I expected more of her coming into the show, given her background. This was the performance Sara needed. Very fun and it showed off her personality. But man, I wasn't expecting that shirt. While that was shockingly low, she looks very cute in her hat and boots. The judges love it. Len calls her a diamond that is being polished. The scores, 8 - 9 - 8. That's the right ballpark.

Mario and Karina - Coming off of last weeks performance, I think we can count on a traditional tango here. Yeah, wrote that line before I watched it. Once again Mario and Karina decide to ignore the rules, breaking the hold in the middle of the dance. I don't get it. They are fantastic together. Mario shows again why he is the front runner in the competition. But wait... Len is pissed. He doesn't like that they are not following the rules for the dances. Bruno and Carrie agree with him. Carrie goes so far as to send the veiled threat that if they would respect the rules they might go further in the competition. The scores, 8 - 6 - 8. Carrie and Bruno both say it could have been a 10. And the audience boos. I think it should have been lower.

Vivica and Nick - And this is where I got confused. Not because I was wondering why they did Vivica's hair like that again. I was wondering why she was doing the tango. It was a really good tango, but I thought all of the girls were doing the jive. It's so confusing. The judges love it. All of them heap praise on Vivica comparing her to Dorothy Dandridge. The scores, 9 - 9 - 9. I think that was a little high.

Joey and EdytaJoey and Edyta - And now Joey is doing the jive. What the heck is going on? While that confuses me, I think it works for Joey and Edyta. They work really well together so the fast footwork makes them look good. I thought they fell apart a little bit at the end, but really good overall. But wait, except for that lift. The judges are having none of that. It's a rule! I'm surprised to see teams ignoring the rules when they have seen what happens to scores. The scores, 8 - 6 - 8. Len is a hardass. Fair enough considering the violation.

And so another week is in the books. All of the crazy rule shenanigans make it tough to handicap things this week. I suspect we'll see cleaner dances next week, but then again, I kind of thought that coming into this week. So who knows?

Best of the night - Sara and Tony. It could have been Mario and Karina or Joey and Edyta, if not for the violations.

Going home - Unfortunately, I think it is Willa's time to go. Too bad. I'd like to see more of her.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

9 Comments

Filter by:
Pev

To elaborate on what Erosia said (I'm going off last season's rules, but I don't think they've changed):

Each week, each couple is given two pieces of music, one tailored for each dance. The couple can pick which style they're going to dance, and they've got to use the song they're given. Theoretically, everyone could dance the same dance.

On one hand, I agree with you on the rules, because clearly everyone has to be judged on the same basis. On the other -- this entire show has its origins in the movie 'Strictly Ballroom'...which is about a ballroom dancing champion who breaks the outdated rules of ballroom dance in order to dance his own way. It's astoundingly ironic to me to watch a dancer get slammed for doing the same thing.

September 28 2006 at 6:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Brett Love

Thanks Erosia, I totally missed that.

September 27 2006 at 8:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
PastaQueen

Brett - The couples got to chose to do either the tango or the jive. They did the same thing last season. It just happened that most of the guys chose the tango and most of the girls chose the jive. I think it's so the stars can pick the dance style that best suits them since some people are better at the ballroom dances and some are better at the latin.

September 27 2006 at 5:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Amber

the whole competition is set up with the judges for drama...sara didnt do a jive either she did a line dance big difference and as a dancer i was appaled that the judges let that slide but penalized joey and mario.

September 27 2006 at 3:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Brent McKee

I thought that Emmitt's biggest problem was that he was pretty stiff throughout his whole body. The Tango is the sort of dance where for the male the upper body should be stiff and maintain aposture but the the movement of the lower body and legs should be active and fluid. Emmitt's legs seemed stiff to me and definitely not fluid. I'd like to see him continue though. (If you want to see the tango watch the one that Tia Carrerre did last season - her best dance but then it was done to the music that she danced to in "True Lies".)

Mario & Karina did a tremendously entertaining dance, but let's face it, what they did had a lot more to do with putting on a show and a lot less to do with ballroom dancing. As for Sarah & Tony, she looked an order of magnitude better doing the jive than she did last week doing a Mambo that looked like something your mom and dad would do at "the club" after a few too many. And I'm glad she let "the girls" come out to play.

September 27 2006 at 2:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Couch Potato Craig

I agree with your thougths on Sara and Tony. With her fanbase she should go a long way. As for her shirt, I thought (hoped?) she was going to pop out of it. After further review through my DVR, she stayed securely in her top.

September 27 2006 at 1:48 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
guy

I missed part of this show but does anyone know where I could download or see the dancing clips from last night???

September 27 2006 at 11:04 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Midalah

Willa was penalized for the lift she did, but I think the penalization for the other two on their lifts was more drastic cause there was more involved. Joey and Edyta actually had *two* lifts, with her back flipping the way she did over his arm, I bet that was considered a lift, then the one near the end. Mario's performance, while really good in reality, was smack with rule breaking between the hold break and the lift at least. And what was with the rolling around on the floor together?

September 27 2006 at 10:14 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Duane

I love pissed off Len! What's it he said to Mario, "You're off your head?" And cuts them down 4 points for a rule violation? Suddenly the game is interesting! It really shows how stupid Mario is, though, as even the backstage interviewer clearly said "Everybody was told that the rules are that you must stay in hold..." and Mario kept saying "but we only broke for just a teensy bit!" like it was ok, even though it clearly wasn't. I hope his professional partner smacks him around good for that.

But didn't Willa do a lift as well? She didn't get penalized for that. I'm all for being strict about the rules, but you've got to be consistent. You can't penalize Mario and Joey more just because they're in the lead. Unless we want to start up the rumor about it being fixed, again.

September 27 2006 at 9:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners