Powered by i.TV
February 10, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Why Christians should love Studio 60

by Chris Thilk, posted Sep 28th 2006 11:28AM
First off, let me just state that I'm with Bob Sassone: I absolutely love Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip. The acting, the writing, the production value...I could go on but suffice it to say that I agree with Bob on just about everything.

Let me also state that I am a practicing Christian (Lutheran, specifically) and have been all my life. I mention this because I want you all to know from what position I'm speaking as you read this post.

One of the major plot points of the first two episodes of the show has been a skit, cut by network executives just before airtime, called "Crazy Christians." We've never been shown the skit but, as many characters stated in the pilot episode, it "killed at dress" and was actually written four years previous by the Matt Albie character just before he was fired from the show. You could guess what the skit was about since it used a very tired tactic of using "Crazy" to telegraph the joke was going to be.

The skit was cut because of concerns it would outrage religious people in America which makes th fact that cast member Harriet Hayes, a devout Christian, was proud of the skit and was willing to fight for it more than a little ironic.


It's the Harriet character that I want to focus on here. Christians on television are often portrayed as zealots, wingnuts and generally crazy people. There are a few positive examples but I feel Harriet Hayes trumps them all. That's because she's an actual adult who is able to hold fast to her faith and, at the same time, poke fun at it a little bit. This is a character trait that Christians on TV, movies and other forms of pop culture often lack. If you're a Christian, we're often shown, you must be deadly serious at all times whenever someone discusses your beliefs and righteously smack-down those who would speak even mildly against it.

But Harriet knows that to truly love something, as she obviously truly loves her faith, you have to be willing to acknowledge its faults. Christianity does have its faults (it was created by humans and everything we create is, by definition, imperfect) but very few people can admit that and even fewer people who can do so are on TV. Even if the skit "Crazy Christians" might have satirized her religion she was willing to go along with it because humor is 1) sometimes needed to keep things in perspective and 2) a gift God gave to her that she would be irresponsible to waste. So when she saw something funny she made a judgment call as to whether to participate in the skit or not and decided to do so. She's a human being, a Christian that reaffirms her faith whenever and wherever she can but also one that is approachable and not intimidating, as cultural portrayals of Christians often are.

So Christians should embrace Studio 60 as being one of the few shows to portray a devoutly religious person in a positive light. She shows all the best traits of Christianity while not bleeding over into being, as the title suggests, a "Crazy Christian." I'm not offended by anything her character has done (of course it's only been two shows) and hope the Chrisitan community embraces her as a positive representation of their faith.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

28 Comments

Filter by:
roger c delaney

The bit about the character's "gift" is so far out of whack it's, dare I say it, comical. Yes, humor is a gift; so is the ability to write or sing or act (or breathe, for that matter). No one should waste their God-given gifts, but it's HOW we use those gifts that matters. Adolf Hitler had a gift for leading large groups of people - would you say he used it in the way God intended? Ozzy Osbourne has a musical gift - would you say God is pleased with how he's chosen to use it? Of course not. What the show seems to want to portray is a hypocrite - one who says she believes one thing and then, by her actions, shows she's not all that committed to those beliefs after all. Yes, Christians often do exactly that - but it's not something we as Christians should celebrate as some kind of cultural breakthrough. It's just sin, and it's something we should grieve about, not commend. If that seems judgmental, so be it.

November 10 2006 at 2:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
MEC

I do not care for the Harriet character myself. Like many have said here, I don't find her funny. I want to like her because I like what the show is trying to accomplish with her character -- a Christian who has a sense of humor. Her character, though proclaimed a Christian, is (in my opinion) a "watered-down" Christian. She hasn't made all of her beliefs known, so as to not offend viewers. Viewers are excited about having a Christian character on prime-time and not realizing that this Christian may have totally diverent ideals than they do.

Even more disappointing to me than the Harriet character, are some of the posts here. Not all Christians think alike, and they shouldn't. Not all Christians believe in the Trinity. There are many who regard the father, the son and the holy ghost as three separate entities.

That's why there are so many different religions in the world -- because not everyone thinks the same. If you find other Christians who believe as you do -- Christianity is man-created or God-created -- you start to think there is safety in numbers. As if your point of view is validated because others think the same. You start to feel a little superior, kind of like "What other people think is not worthwhile -- they are going to hell." *and this is just my opinion here* HOW CHRISTIAN IS THAT? (I do not mean to offend non-Christians with that remark, just turning the tables on some of the posters)

I feel it's time for some folks to realize there may be more than one mindset that is valid. Don't put down the original poster because she said man made Christianity. If that's her belief, she should be allowed to have it and post it here without worrying someone is going to tell her she's not a true Christian.

What I would like to see is a Crazy Christians skit where we have, say, Pentecostals, African Methodist Episcopal, Unitarian Universalists and Catholics competing on a game show about who God is. Now THAT would be must-see TV.

November 02 2006 at 5:48 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kim White

I am a "devout" Christian and have seen nothing that makes Harriet stick out as "devout". It's still sterotype lines and bits coming out of her mouth.
I love SNL and humor, and laugh at the wrong parts the church, but Harriet falls flat. Nothing is sticking.

November 02 2006 at 10:15 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
tbar

Chris Thilk, the author of the blog, is terribly wrong about the origins of Christianity. I am not familiar with Luthern teachings, but it does not sound Christian at all.
Christianity was not created by humans, but its very name come from the worship of the Son Jesus Christ as God, and who, along with the Father and Spirit, makes up the Holy Trinity. And Jesus the Christ, was God in the flesh, who came to take our sins upon in himself that we might be reconciled to God through his willinging and loving sacrfice.
So Christianity was not created by humans, but is the worship of the creator of humans. Though we humans are imperfect, Jesus Christ and his word are perfect truth.
As far as the show goes, I stopped watching it because I was not fooled by the shows desire to bash Christians by using a Christian character who doesn't mind being the target of ridicule.
I thought the show was pretty bad regardless.

October 17 2006 at 11:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tony Figueroa

As a resident of Hollywood, I know Christians like Harriet who have a sense of humor and can laugh at themselves. I think Harriet presents a more positive portrayal of Christians than Ned Flanders (The Simpsons), Bree Van De Kamp (Desperate Housewives) or Angela Martins (The Office). I do have a hunch that sometime soon (maybe November Sweeps), there will be a backlash to Crazy Christians story line.

October 14 2006 at 11:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Zachary

From the article:

If you're a Christian, we're often shown, you must be deadly serious at all times whenever someone discusses your beliefs and righteously smack-down those who would speak even mildly against it.

I think the reason why they're always shown like this is because those kinds of Christians in Real Life are the ones who are doing the loud bitching and complaining, therefore the shows and movies portray Christians as serious and thin-skinned.

October 01 2006 at 12:54 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Karen Hall



If you believe that Christianity is "man made" I'm afraid your Christianity is worthless. Christianity is God reaching out to man unlike all other religions who's aim it to try somehow to reach or please God. I pray you discover this Truth for yourself.

September 30 2006 at 4:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Barbara

RE: Post 18, by RAB....
I love what was said here, although I have to say it made me a little sad that the most sensible and Christian-like response was from an atheist. Sigh...I've been a Christian my whole life and fear we have more to learn now, than ever before, about how to truly live and represent our faith. "Feed my sheep, feed my sheep, feed my sheep." Funny, I see nothing there about judging others and not being able to laugh at ourselves. I repeat, "sigh".

September 30 2006 at 12:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rufus Firefly

My problem with the character is that I don't find an evangelical Christian on an SNL-type show plausible. Victoria Jackson might be or might have been a Christian, but I don't remember her spirituality getting much press. And I doubt she was evangelical. SNL is the kind of show that the fundamentalists love to criticize. It's full of lewd jokes and profanity--not something Christians should be watching. I can't imagine an evangelical Christian cast member of SNL appearing on the 700 Club (as Harriet did--mentioned in episode one). The Christian community wouldn't accept it. When Amy Grant released her first "secular" album, which was squeaky clean but made no reference to God, Christians everywhere rejected her as a traitor. So the idea that Harriet could be a Christian who's accepted by, and identifies with, the larger Christian community in the US just doesn't make sense.

September 29 2006 at 4:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jonny Rice

In a shameless bit of self-promotion, some like-minded friends of mine have a blog where we try talking about religious/Christian issues without taking ourselves too seriously.

http://www.midwestmindset.com/

I don't know if we're exactly a "positive representation of our faith," but we do like taking each other down a notch when we need it.

September 29 2006 at 3:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners