Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Saturday Night Live: Dane Cook and The Killers (season premiere)

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Oct 1st 2006 12:32PM

Dane Cook and The Killers' new album 'Sam's Town'

(S32E01) "And we're baaaaaaack!" Anyone? Anyone? No? OK, well it's SNL season premiere time (that came fast) and Dane Cook is already hosting again. I can't remember the last time someone hosted two episodes so close together. He was just there last December. Well, it's understandable I suppose. I can't think of anyone else that's bigger on the comedy circuit right now and his name automatically attracts attention. He's all over the place, from touring to HBO specials. Anyway, the show was pretty decent I thought, but not because Cook was the host. He was barely in it.

First off I wanted to talk about the cast. Without Fey, Dratch, Mitchell, Parnell, Sanz, or any featured players, the cast is much smaller and I'm excited about that. Everyone will get more air-time and I think it'll make for a better show. Faces will become more recognizable and I think the cast as a whole will work better together. So yeah, I'm one of the few who has high hopes for this season.

Moving on, we had Dane's monologue which was just some of his stand-up. It was all new material (I think...) and for the most part it was very funny. The bit about everything being on YouTube was dead-on. But as I said, he wasn't in the show that much following the monologue.

As one would expect, Seth Myers and the rest of the writing team were all over current events and really had fun with them. The sketches about the TSA and Hugo Chavez were the two best in the episode I think. They were timely and made some really good points, especially the TSA sketch when the debate about liquids on airplanes came up ("What if I could produce a liquid on the plane... or a gel?"). As much as I liked the Hugo Chavez political round-up sketch, my only gripe was that Fred Armisen is the same character whenever he plays someone who's Latin or Spanish. Bug eyes, flailing arms. It's always the same guy. Cook's portrayal as Saddam was flat and didn't really contribute to the sketch either.

The digital short "Cubicle Fight" was priceless. Much better than most of the digital shorts from last season. "Two men enter, one man leaves." I loved the part when Dane blew the paper-punch holes into Jason's face. Funny stuff.

Most of the impersonations fell flat for me. I feel like the last time we saw Bill Hader do Al Pacino (that Anderson Cooper 360° sketch from last season), it was so much better. I wasn't amazed by Clinton and Condoleeza during Weekend Update either. I love Darrell Hammond but I was surprised he returned this season.

Speaking of Weekend Update, it went on too long. But for the most part it was very good. I think Seth and Amy play off each other very well (they used to do that British news show sketch... right?), and the intro with Brian Williams being rejected from the anchor job was hilarious.

The Poland Spring delivery guys? It was odd but I liked the end and the way they poked fun at SNL, Studio 60, and 30 Rock. When done right, self-reflexive humor can be subtle (and funny). They pulled it off here. After this sketch, the show kind of dragged along. The Farrah Fawcett thing was lost on me and the sketch with the bouncers was predictable. I did like the Geico commercial though. Maya, as Whitney Houston, singing about doing coke off a hot waffle iron? It's funny because it's probably true.

The Killers didn't really impress me. They changed their visual style right? Didn't they used to wear suits and look all flashy? For their first song off their new album Sam's Town, they were dressed all scrubby in jeans and flannel shirts. Of the two songs they performed, neither sounded as catchy as anything off their first album. But who knows. This was live and the album versions most likely sound far better.

Overall, as I said, a decent episode. Lot of high points and plenty of lows. But I am excited about this season. I really believe that it's going to get better every week.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

39 Comments

Filter by:
Vickers, C.

ugh, I just watched the third show with My Chemical Romance. I think I'll just sleep in next Saturday night.

October 22 2006 at 1:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Vickers, C.

Ugh. Just saw the second show with My Chemical Romance.
Well, actually it's still one, I just got tired of watching it. Hardly a skit that was really funny on the show. Is this where they're headed for the rest of the season?

October 22 2006 at 12:53 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kelee Heiffus

The show was absolutely terrible. Dane Cook was self-conscious and not funny.
In fact everyone looked self-conscious--like they knew they were in the middle of a stinker and that the stink would be permanent.

October 15 2006 at 3:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
celeste

this season premeririejfkei was really ggood, i love dane cook, i love dane cook woo woo

October 15 2006 at 3:26 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bobby

Absolutely horrible. I just watched it here in Alaska, and I think this season is off to a horrible start, from bad impressions to really bad sound guys. The microphones kept cutting out time after time. Seems like an amateur crew running the show now.

October 15 2006 at 3:40 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jim

So ... no review this week (Oct. 7)?

October 09 2006 at 11:42 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Santiago Leon

Great show. Andy Samberg will be the star!

October 05 2006 at 9:56 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
dk

sorry SNL I think it's over - Jamie P is great so I'm hopeful fro next week but Weekend Update is done - Daily Show is so much better at the joke ont the day the story breaks - I may have a 6 year olds sense of humor but I loved the Al P bit and caught him on the actors studio wearing the exact same get up the next day. TSA was funny - I really don't like dane cook - the bar skit was one of the worst in recent memory - they should fire everyone and try and do an all-star year (bring all the best back for one season) then end it

October 03 2006 at 4:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bdure

I've been hearing "it's over" since 1980. Doesn't happen. Shouldn't happen. It's just the refrain of people trying to prove they're hip by saying SNL (or R.E.M., or The Simpsons, or U2) peaked 10-15 years ago.

Now I WILL say that Dane Cook is in a slump. Watch his Comedy Central appearances from a few years ago, and you'll bust your gut. He was good in some sketches the first time he hosted and decent in this one, but the expectations are high for his monologues, and he hasn't delivered.

What I've noticed about SNL these days is that you can no longer assume that the good sketches will run pre-Update and the lame ones will run post-Update. In this case, the funniest bits were either side of Update. The TSA sketch was absolutely spot-on, as was the Geico ad. Add Cubicle Fight, and you have three good ones. Plus the Brian Williams intro on an otherwise so-so Update.

No, it wasn't a classic SNL from start to finish (as if any SNL ever is). My problem with it was that I was aware that I was watching a transition in progress from Fey to Meyers. He seems intent on trying some new things, such as breaking the fourth wall. That could work. But it may take some time to get it right. And if you know anything about SNL's history, you know that such experimentation is vital to keeping the show moving.

Meyers needs an editor -- some of the gags went on too long. But there are no fatal flaws and a few good highlights. Enjoy the highlights and give it time on the rest.

What would you replace it with, anyway?

October 02 2006 at 11:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
griff

the worst SNL I have ever seen - And I don't even understand the point of their Studio 60 / 30 Rock reference.

October 02 2006 at 8:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners