Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Boston Legal: Fine Young Cannibal

by Richard Keller, posted Oct 11th 2006 8:54AM

The Cast of Boston Legal(S03E04) What? Haven't you ever seen a smoking dwarf before?

Gosh, its been awhile since we've seen Alan Shore in the courtroom. Oh, we had a brief appearance of him during the first episode of the season, but he's been pretty quiet since, making room for some of the new people as well as a number of prominent guest stars. So, it was good to see him, along with his 'dreamgirl' Shirley, take on the case of a homeless man charged with cannabilism.

You would think this would be played out for laughs. Oh, there was some humor to it, but it was actually one of the more serious cases in this episode. And Alan took to it with gusto. We even got to see one of his patened closing arguments (his niche, as Shirley would say). In the end, the client wasn't treated as some crazed man, but someone with more dignity than the District Attorney who was prosecuting him.

Oh, that would be District Attorney 'Second Line on the Ballot Come This November' Ginsburg, according to Alan.

And so, another episode of Boston Legal is upon us, and what a very good episode it was. There are very few shows that can do both humor and drama at the same time and be good at it. Scrubs is one example, The Office is another, and Legal is definitely one. I don't think there's been an episode this season where I haven't laughed out loud sever al times in the hour. This week's episode was no exception.

Particularly when it comes to any scene involving Shirley Schmidt, Alan Shore, and/or Denny Crane (in the real world, Candice Bergen, James Spader and William Shatner). I wonder how many times they have to run through their scenes during filming, because it would seem to me that these three probably crack each other up on the set constantly. Especially when there in the same room together. Take for instance this week's scene where Alan and Denny are trying to defend the virtues of battle for the hand of maiden Shirley. There all in the room together: Alan's pontificating and Denny is just giving one of his patented looks. Shirley? Well, Bergen can barely keep the smile off her face.

There's also a very unique sweetness to some of their scenes as well. Take the one where Alan is asking Shirley to give him a try as a sexual partner. First, you don't see many types of 'mature' relationships on television today, which is refreshing in its own right. Second, the honesty that these two characters show during a conversation about, basically, having sex, is just nice. And sweet as well, as you see Alan's genuine affection for his law partner.

Okay, enough talk about those icky relationships. Let's get to the geek moment of the week. It was the scene between the characters played by Armin Shimmerman and Rene Auberjonois. As you all know, these two actors played the roles of Quark and Odo, respectively, on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. In this week's episode, you could almost picture them having the same converdation at Quark's bar on the Promenade. Shimmerman, who plays a jude whose wife was murdered, was confrontational to Auberjonois' character, who plays a law partner to Denny Crane. In fact, just watching Auberjonois' mannerisms, and listening to his accusational talk, reminded me of all the times that Odo confronted Quark about something seedy going on. It was a nice addition to the episode.

One more item to talk about before I get to my complaint about this week's show (Yes, I actually have one). Bethany Horowitz should be made a semi-regular. Other than Shirley, Denny has really never had another female foil to play off of. Bethany, also known as 'The Badger' is that foil. She doesn't take Denny's crap for a second and is willing to confront him face-to, er, waistline, to tell him how it is. She's a tough 'little person' and she would make a great addition to the law firm.

All right, here is my complaint. The whole 'Judge Hooper Murder' plotline is taking way too long. It had some serious prominence during the second episode of the season (really, the unofficial start of the third season), and then kind of peter out. We're now into the fact finding of the case, but it needs to be speeded up a bit. It seems like the trial will start in next week's episode. So, at least we'll be coming to some sort of conclusion. I hope.

Finally, I leave you on this note. Do you know what Denny Crane would do if he ever met God? He'd take him fishing. See you next week.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

12 Comments

Filter by:
A. Rose

Realizm, smealizm. it is real, CSI, Law & Order,Without a Trace,ER, Grays Anatomy, etc, so what? My boyfriend down talks all them shows, how phoney they are...so what. They take us to another place, be it good,bad or whatever.Better than Numbers, nine or how about Kidnaped? What the heck is with these dramatic series. Can't get into them at all.

October 26 2006 at 2:54 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
S. Everett

Does anyone know the name of the man that played the Cannibal?

October 19 2006 at 3:03 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
7G

With characters like Denny Crane and Alan Shore? I dont think so.

October 18 2006 at 3:13 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob Walley

Is there a better show on TV right now than Boston Legal?

October 12 2006 at 10:54 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

Does anyone know where I can find transcripts or video of Alan's closing arguments? Not just THIS episode... ALL of his closers. They're a gold mine of twistedly ironic genius.

October 12 2006 at 8:56 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
treegoat

Glad you pointed that out, Harish! I thought I'd heard that joke before.

The wrestling match was too funny - then Denny saying he did the same thing to Shirley the first time they got together. Hilarious! I hope the Badger comes back - I liked her.

October 11 2006 at 10:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Harish

Did anyone notice the repeat joke of God being Denny Crane at the Pearly Gates? That joke was told in an earlier season, either 1 or 2. Anyone have any idea which episode though? By the way - Boston Legal is one of the best shows on tv. I want to see interactions between Geoffrey Cohoe and Alan Shore though - considering they're basically the same person in different time periods, it should be fun.

October 11 2006 at 7:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

The show isn't even a drama, it's a comedy that makes fun of itself all the time. You want "real" go to a courtroom. Boston Legal talks about itself on air all the time. "I hope we stay on the same night next season". Yeah that's SOOOOOOOOO real. ER, Desperate Housewives, Lost, Battlestar Galatica are all so very real.

October 11 2006 at 6:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
James

Love this show! Denny would take God fishing, which is exactly what he did when he met Alan.

October 11 2006 at 1:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
aphoward

And I hate to break it to you, but you should read up on some of the research done for the show. There are in fact real life attorneys who this is based off of, and as someone who has worked with many attorneys over time, I can tell that you clearly have a very limited exposure to the world of high priced/high publicity corporate law and criminal defense. It all depends on where you are, who you are, and who the judge is as to how your behavior is tolerated.

I really have to wonder about the many people who say stuff like "I'm not watching this anymore because of the lack of realism". It's a freaking TV show, as in fiction, as in staged, as in it's NOT REAL. If you wanted true to life courtroom drama, you might stick to Law & Order or even CourtTV.

October 11 2006 at 12:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners