Powered by i.TV
February 9, 2012
 
CONNECT    

ER: Parenthood

by Richard Keller, posted Oct 13th 2006 8:25AM

Doctor Greg Pratt(S13E04) Could we have finally turned the corner here? After so many mediocre seasons of ER with rotating doctors, uncompleted storylines, and the constant moping of Abby and Sam, is the series back on track? Well, after watching this week's episode, which I thought was the best of this season so far, I would say yes.

Okay, NBC says yes as well, because they decided not to interrupt the show's run for three months in order to air The Black Donnellys. Sure, you can contribute the show's resurgence to weaker competition (Shark on CBS and Six Degrees on ABC), but I also think it's due to the gelling of the cast after last season's adjustment period. Oh, and of course the addition of John Stamos as the new Dr. Ross probably didn't hurt either. I just hope they stay on track this season and not veer too far off into personal stories. The name of the show is ER and it should take place in the ER.

Okay, my rant is done. Let's get going with this week's review.

I've got to say that I haven't seen a 'doctor all alone' story on ER for quite some time. I remember Dr. Lewis had one way back in the first season, and Dr. Greene had one in the second. Carter may have had a few during his years on the show, but I can't remember any. For the uninitiated, these are the stories where a doctor is left alone in the ER as the cases pile up. All right, technically they're not left alone; they're just left with the interns and medical students.

It was Greg Pratt's turn to be left alone this time around. I like Pratt, he's tough like Benton was, but he also knows all of his stuff like Greene and Carter did. However, after five years at County General he still can't teach himself out of a paper bag. He just doesn't have the inherent patience like Doctors Greene and Carter did. And this is a problem because, as we see in this episode, he can't keep rein on his interns and residents. Because he can't control and rely on them, he ends up handling multiple traumas by himself. Luckily, as the episode ends, we see Pratt realize that he needs to really begin to teach in order to get some of these interns up to speed.

There were two subplots this week. One involving Abby's attempt at finding a connection with other mothers at a 'Baby and Me' class and some nannies at the park, and the other involving Archie Morris and his son (By sperm donation. Apologies, I didn't see the episode when all of that was introduced). I could have done without the Morris subplot. Rather than using him as some kind of comic foil I wish the producers of ER would start showing him being an actual doctor. As I mentioned last week, we saw some of that in the season premiere when he was working to save Jerry. But, since then, he's been portrayed as somewhat of a buffoon. As for Abby's plotline, well, needless to say I won't be hiring a nanny anytime soon (and apologies to nannies, because I know many of you are not like what was portrayed this episode).

One final thought this week, and it involves John Stamos' role as Doctor Tony Gates. The character is beginning to grow on me. As I said at the beginning of the review, he's the new Doctor Ross: a rule-breaker who takes matters into his own hands, damn the consequences. What I'd like to know is his relationship with the mother and daughter he is currently living with. Is he married, or a boyfriend? I'm not too sure. Anyhoo, one of the final scenes of this week's episode was a conversation between Gates and the daughter. I swear, for just a moment I thought I was watching Uncle Jesse talking to Michelle Tanner. When he kissed her good-night I thought he would say 'Good night, Munchkin.' That would have been very funny if he did.

Right. Next week Forrest Whitaker takes a break from The Shield to visit the emergency room, and it looks like Abby returns.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

6 Comments

Filter by:
gina

this will sound crazy but i stopped watching a awhile ago after they killed dr.greene but i started a new job a while back and found myself watching rerun on tnt back to back 7 to 8 am monday to friday. I was raelly loving the show again because of my job 10pm is too late for me.I was watching the one when sams ex comes in and the whole shoot out thing luka is tryed down and abby real pregnant falls blood which looks like may be coming from between her legs. I could not wait until the next day and that night i was telling my husband all about it turn on the tv the next morning and bam it's the pilot and i thought i had died and gone to he** I know this sounds crazy but what happen that next show please someone take mercy on me and respond

December 30 2006 at 9:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
hadley

really happy that it's focused more on doctors and patients-some personal stuff is fine, but the core of the show is the fast pace in which life is gained and lost in the ER and it's great to have finally returned to that concept. John stamos has quite an interesting character and it will be intriguing to see where it leads-adds some humor. Pratt and Neela are back! So glad to see them get out from under that dark cloud they have been under...The writers are doing a great job this season. Keep it up!

October 16 2006 at 6:44 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Brent

It's clear to me that Stamos's character can not read.

October 14 2006 at 12:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Chris

SPOILER ALERT:






John Stamos' character-
I am pretty sure the woman and girl he lives with are the widow/daughter of a friend he served with in the Gulf War..I think Stamos mentioned that in interviews

October 13 2006 at 3:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jimmy

What the writers and producers of ER seem to have re-discovered, and tonight's episode was a good example, is the frantic pace of the first few years it was on the air. I like to see the characters fleshed out, but for several years now the series has focused less on the ER and more on all the personal crap. I love when Sally Field comes to visit as Abby's mom, but I would hate it if she stayed around; Neela is more entertaining now that she's concentrating on being a surgeon and less on her now-dead husband; and Pratt is just great this season. In fact, Mekhi Phifer and Parminder Nagra get my award for the most improved actors and characters this season -- so far. Last night's episode reminded me why I started watching this show in the first place.

October 13 2006 at 2:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
tracey21

What a phenomenal episode! It had my heart pounding and had me on the edge of my seat. It also had its funny and cute moments too. Great hour of tv, well done!

October 13 2006 at 10:32 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners