Powered by i.TV
February 11, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Steve Irwin criticized by former producer

by Julia Ward, posted Nov 2nd 2006 2:29PM
Steve IrwinAs if Crocodile Hunter Steve Irwin's death hasn't raised enough ire thanks to the "too soon to joke" camp versus Bill Maher and South Park, Irwin's former BBC boss has added more fuel to the fire.

Executive producer of BBC's Planet Earth Alastair Fothergill must have had it with the Irwin-as-saint treatment when he stated to the press that he didn't have much sympathy for Irwin because he believed Irwin was more interested in his own stardom than animals.

"He introduced a lot of people to natural history but his basic stock in trade was - Aren't I brave, and aren't animals dangerous?" Fothergill went on to say that animals attack only when they feel threatened. "The first rule of natural history filmmaking is to film animals' natural behavior. Attacking humans isn't natural."

Steve Irwin's death is sad, but isn't there some truth to what Fothergill is saying? If you play with fire or crocodiles, you may get burned.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

11 Comments

Filter by:
Patricia in Phoenix, AZ, USA

I agree wholeheartedly with Tex Kamakawiwo'ole. The green eyed monster, jealousy, has certainly brought out the worst in these negative posters. Baby Bob was indeed safe in his devoted, loving, and experienced father's hands. The average father would not do this but Steve was NOT average and that is as it should be. You posters of negativity need to get a life.

November 09 2006 at 7:56 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tex Kamakawiwo\'ole

Steve Irwin was doing what he LOVED, What about personal freedom ??? All you guys with your negativity comments are always telling everyone else how to live, Irwin was making MONEY and built a GREAT zoo,, What are you doing beside tripping up a DEAD man ??? The way he died was a freak thing, an accindent, We ALL take wrisk when we get in our cars, EVERYDAY.. Nobody get off this planet alive, We ALL have made mistakes, Baby Bob was SAFE, I would not have done it with my son, but it was Steve Irwins pesonal freedom. Most of your comments are on the mistakes he made, He was eccentric and lived HIS life to the fullest, He was not egocentric like your folks who have nothing but negative things to say about the man..If he rubbed your wrong, he must of made YOU feel less of a person..The root of your negative comments is JEALOUSY, nothing new under the Sun..

November 03 2006 at 10:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tex Kamakawiwo\'ole

Steve Irwin was doing what he LOVED, What about personal freedom ??? All you guys with your negativity comments are always telling everyone else how to live, Irwin was making MONEY and built a GREAT zoo,, What are you doing beside tripping up a DEAD man ??? The way he died was a freak thing, an accindent, We ALL take wrisk when we get in our cars, EVERYDAY.. Nobody get off this planet alive, We ALL have made mistakes, Baby Bob was SAFE, I would not have done it with my son, but it was Steve Irwins pesonal freedom. Most of your comments are on the mistakes he made, He was eccentric and lived HIS life to the fullest, He was not egocentric like your folks who have nothing but negative things to say about the man..If he rubbed your wrong, he must of made YOU feel less of a person..The root of your negative comments is JEALOUSY, nothing new under the Sun..

November 03 2006 at 10:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
treegoat

Ahh...sounds like he's not an untouchable anymore. He repeatedly injected himself into their natural habitat - at some point he was going to tackle an animal that wasn't going to take it. I also was out of the fan club when the baby/alligator thing happened.

November 03 2006 at 8:53 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Linda

Had he died from wounds inflicted by one of those dangerous animals one could say that he died because of violent behavior one should expect of a wild, dangerous animal. Ironically, he died as a result of a wound inflicted by a normally peaceful animal.

November 03 2006 at 4:36 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
CJ

Thank you! His death was regrettable, but I he always rubbed me the wrong way. He always seemed to be almost taunting the animals.... going right up to them, letting them snarl and then grabbing them in some way. It was pure showmanship, we know these are dangerous animals, didnt really see the need to taunt them into displaying that fact. I don't think he was too much better than the "Wild Boys".

November 02 2006 at 6:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Whoosh

someone needs to tell the sharks and bears that "attacking humans isnt natural"

November 02 2006 at 4:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Sam

I think in general, we as a society tend to deify people like Irwin much more so that he deserves to. I never thought he was all that special, though you could tell he was a nice guy and overall a good family man.

You're right, Julia: anyone who thought of his death as some sort of out-of-the-blue, entirely unexpected event clearly did not understand what Irwin was doing. He repeatedly put himself in harms' way, in no small part for the platitudes and notoriety it got him from the public, and it cost him his life.

November 02 2006 at 4:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Marco Garbelini

Thank you, thank you, thank you. I thought I was alone on this one. Irwin lost me forever with the Baby X Alligator thing, what a f***ing idiot. I go even further and say that by being the ironic bastard that I am I couldn't hold a very wide smile when I read the first Stingray X Irwin news. It made me chuckle. I remember thinking "I love your sense of humor God, I just hope people can learn something from this."

Apparently they can't.

November 02 2006 at 3:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Julia Ward

Correction made. My misreading of the source piece. Thanks. If you find additional errors in any TV Squad post, feel free to use the "corrections" link to the right.

November 02 2006 at 2:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners