Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Battlestar Galactica: Torn

by Keith McDuffee, posted Nov 3rd 2006 11:51PM
battlestar galactica
(S03E06)
Well, here I am watching the episodes live with the rest of you. And you know what? It feels good! Now I look forward to every week where there will be a new episode instead of lumping a bunch into one season. There's something to be said about pacing oneself.

Dear lord (lords?), what an opening. Does anyone get tired of seeing Number Six scantily clad, let along on a beach? Though it's about time that Baltar questions the vision of Number Six that plagues his thoughts, both in dreams and seemingly in reality.

I love that Baltar starts things out by doing exactly what Gaeta says he's good at: finding a way to self preserve. "Earth? What Earth?" "You're going to die." "Oh THAT Earth! Why didn't you say so?"

DAMN it was good to see (a thin!) Apollo and Starbuck back to old tricks, wasn't it? Chief and Callie back in the pit. A newly populated Galactica. By gods the writers for this show pulled off what many thought was a hell of a risky move at the conclusion of last season.

Is Baltar a Cylon because he can "project" himself into a different reality in his mind? Here's my theory -- somehow he's directly related to the one responsible for creating the skinjob Cylons, and that person molded the whole "projection" notion onto his own creation. I'm sure I have no idea what I'm talking about, but that's how it's feeling to me up to this point.

Another fantastic conversation in this episode was Baltar's questioning about the final five Cylon model's we've yet to see. Number Six says they "don't talk about them," so does this possibly mean they're rogue Cylons, ones who've gone about on their own and who are against the beliefs of those we already know?

I could definitely see Tigh being relieved of duty in the near future because he's got some big nasty ax to grind. Finally Adama does put him in his place, but will he listen?

Definitely an interesting look into how the other side lives ... and relives. Everything is so closely connected, including the Cylons with perhaps their own base stars. Everyone and everything is aware of everything else.

So, was the disease-causing device found on the Cylon base star an old satellite sent from old Earth? Voyage or Voyager II perhaps? And now we know that possibly Earth carries diseases that would mean the downfall of Cylons? If so, this is definitely an interesting development.

I'm sorry, but I liked Starbuck with the long hair. I mean, it's great to see yet another moment from the past make it into this season (like Saul's going back on the sauce, for instance), but I liked that change.

From what it looks like for next week, the humans board that derelict base star. What will they find from that strange artifact brought on board?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

56 Comments

Filter by:
Patrick DeVaughn

7 known + 5 unknown = 12 , 12 tribes, 12 dicsiples?.
Torn is 2nd episode back to being worthy.
Why leave beacon? please!
Dying and transporting virus back, please again! Virus Act of god or cylon 5?

Dave #24 AMEN Brother.

November 11 2006 at 5:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tim McCleese

cress-d: Just a footnote. The example I used with Sharon's child (Hera) is bolstered in the scene when Six, Baltar, and the Lucy Lawless model (what # is she?) found Hera among the dead in the end of the Exodus part 2 episode. Notice how they immediately knew who she was? I cannot recall how else they would know her. The cylons just know.

By the way Dorv, I see what you mean about the reference to Sharon's name. I really like 'Athena' but I am just not used to it yet. I prefer Sharon as in Hera's mother and Boomer to be the original. Oh why couldn't they capture me!

Akbar: Just having a little fun!

November 08 2006 at 9:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tim McCleese

cress-d: I also noticed Sharon's reaction when she saw the basestars. Of course cress-d, when it comes to Sharon/Boomer, I notice EVERYTHING about her. But to the point, like you, I wondered if anyone else picked up on it enough to make it an issue. It worries me a little. I agree with your assessment of this scene. I believe the cylons have a built-in sensory network much like our own human sixth sense. I think they can sense things among their own, for example, any of the humanlike (I hate the term skinjobs) models can immediately pick out, say...Hera....in a crowd without ever having seen her. If we are right about this theory, I do not think she is affected. I certainly hope she isn't.

November 08 2006 at 8:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Akbar Fazil

I did notice that Cress D.

Was Athena infected? My initial thought was she was hit but since she is special she was not infected thus her reaction.

Or, it could just be a reaction to seeing the pulsars.

Or since she is so versed in the scriptures maybe this was another prophecy that just plopped into place.

November 08 2006 at 2:18 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chris w

When Athena/Kat(I think it was Kat) jump to the coordinates, did anyone else notice the weird facial expression(closed her eyes, shook her head) displayed by Athena BEFORE BEFORE she saw the BaseStars/Raiders in disarray? It seemed like she knew something was up immediately when they arrived at those coordinates.

"When Gods anger awakens, even the mighty shall fall..."
Boomer/Athena is well-versed in the religious scrolls(HOME as an example). She states to Adama that she has no hidden protocols and makes her own decisions, and is not a sleeper. But I just thought her initial reaction was odd here. Maybe she automatically sensed something was strange when they arrived at the coordinates, BEFORE they saw the infected BaseStars/Raiders. Anyone else notice this..and your thoughts?

November 07 2006 at 8:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chris w

"Mists of dreams drip along the nascent echo, and love no more. End of line."
More Hybrid dialogue...

November 07 2006 at 8:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chris w

David--24. "You talk to much. When your post is 4 times as long as the blog no one will listen. David."

That is a lame observation.

David..sorry you can't read more than a couple of sentences in a post. I would rather read a long post w/ deep analysis than a two-sentence blurb from someone who doesn't feel like typing too much! Are you a member of "Short Attention Span Theatre"?

November 07 2006 at 7:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chris w

"The agony exquisite, the colors run the path of ashes."

Just one of the lines spouted out by the Hybrid. Nothing special to point out, just thought it was a beautiful, strange statement.

November 07 2006 at 7:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob

Dorv,
I'm here to answer your 10pt question about the "Flares".
I could be wrong, but my guess is ST:Voyager (in the intro).

Oh yeah,.. I liked the episode as well, except I felt it had more of an "artsy" feel to it. Not my favorite episode, but still great.

November 07 2006 at 1:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dorv

David: So a scene that is written and not shot, is that canon? (Are we really arguing over this?)

November 06 2006 at 2:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners