Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Kate Loves Jack, not Sawyer

by Michael Canfield, posted Nov 9th 2006 12:03PM
Jack and SawyerLast night on Lost Sawyer and Kate got busy in broad daylight right under the Others' surveillance cameras. Sawyer loves Kate, we know. I'm guessing he is pretty sure now that Kate loves him too.

I hate to break it to Sawyer, but I see things completely differently. If I'm right, which is far from certain, of course, Kate doesn't love Sawyer, although she is attracted to him. She may or may not have admitted it to herself yet, but Kate loves Jack. Here's why I think so ...

First, I think that Kate slept with Sawyer because, as she keeps saying to him, she didn't want him to give up and die, and she certainly knows that Sawyer loves her. That, along with the tension of imprisonment, and fearing for their lives gets them together, but it doesn't mean she's in love with him.

Furthermore, we saw in the flashback that she ran away from her husband, Nathan Fillion's character. Kate doesn't think she deserves anything or anyone good.

Jack is good, at least in Kate's mind. So there's more of a reason she would go toward Sawyer, when she really loves Jack. You still might argue that she prefers a bad-boy like Sawyer, but she gives herself away when she tells Jack over the walkie-talkie that she won't leave without him. She does not say we won't leave without him. She's only thinking about Jack at that point. She'd rather die than leave without Jack, just as Sawyer would rather die than leave Kate behind.

Any thoughts?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

108 Comments

Filter by:
Jessi

I think Kate loves Sawyer with all of her heart. Even though something happened to her loves, she did love them. Kate doesn't seem like the kind of person to tell someone she loves them without knowing for sure that she does. In my opinion, Jack has changed through the second season, and the third season. He's not the person that had chemistry with her at the beginning. Plus, Kate ans Sawyer have te whole hate/love thing that is so romantic.

January 08 2007 at 5:58 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kelsey

Dude, what kind of world are you living in? If I recall correctly--the writers SAID that Kate loved Sawyer. Wouldnt that mean that Kate loves Sawyer?

January 08 2007 at 2:19 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kelsey

I dont get how you idiot Jaters can possibly believe that Jack & Kate are in love when practically EVERYTHING in I do pointed to the fact that Sawyer and Kate were. It is sad that Lost has such moronic fans. Go watch the OC or something..

January 07 2007 at 4:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kelsey

Youre completely wrong--why would any woman love hairy chested fugly Jack?

January 07 2007 at 3:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
KELSEY

I THINK YUO ARE ALL WRONG I KNOW KATE LUVS SAWYETR AND SAWYER LUVS KATE SOOOOO.... BOOOO YAAA!!!!

December 27 2006 at 8:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
jenny

Well, i kind of get your point but over the walkie-talkie i think she was talking about sawyer that she wont leave with out him i realy wont to find out how this love thing ends i hope sawyer gets her because he truley loves her and his given his fight to get out twice or three times to save kate xxxjennyxxx

December 20 2006 at 9:03 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ripping jealousy

WARNING reading the following will spoil the end of lost.

hmm some vry intresting points from above. but noone is close to the real ansr yet. isn't it ovious?

here lies the truth:

ok basicaly jack and sawyer will be pushed into a big red bussy thingy and it will create a mixture of the two yeah. with sawyers fucking hot looks and and bad boy style with a caring and intelagent hint. oh and of course Jacks beautiful eyes.


but there is one thing i just dont understand. uno when kate and sawyer got it on and he lifted up her top ya well her armpits were resanatly shaved! she had no hair at all! even if u havn't shaved in 2 days there is somthing there!


oh and as for the big red bussy thingy, well they should put johnny depps ass in the mixture aswel just to make him perfect!

why dont ppl like kate? she killed the man who maried her mum. he beat up her mum every night. then when he was finished he would try and fuck kate. im fucking glad she killed him! he was a syco bastred.




goths rule!

December 18 2006 at 5:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lors-x

Beautiful, I totally agree! And for those who say Kate was taking to Sawyer when she say "I can't leave with out you"-- that is stupid, if she wasnt talking to Jack, she wouldnt have pressed the walkie talkie button so as he could hear her.. DUH!

December 18 2006 at 12:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ripping jealousy

hmm some vry intresting points from above. but noone is close to the real ansr yet. isn't it ovo? ok basicaly jack and sawyer will be pushed into a big red bussy thingy and it will create a mixture of the two ya. with sawyers fucking hot looks and and bad boy style with a caring and intelagent hint. oh and of course Jacks beautiful eyes.


but there is one thing i just dont understand. uno when kate and sawyer got it on and he lifted up her top ya well her armpits were resanatly shaved! she had no hair at all! even if u havn't shaved in 2 days there is somthing there!


oh and as for the big red bussy thingy, well they should put johnny depps ass in the mixture aswel just to make him perfect!

why dont ppl like kate? she killed the man who maried her mum then beat her mum every night. then when he was finished he would grope kate. im fucking glad she killed him!he was a syco bastred.




goths rule!

December 17 2006 at 9:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tami

I think it's pretty sad that Michael, as well as the Jaters are getting ridiculed and called names just because they take a different viewpoint then the Skaters. The Skaters posting here in particular are looking very immature and are not representing their ship well at all. A couple of things I want to clear up for those that didn't listen to the podcast. Damon and Carlton never said that Kate loved Sawyer and no amount of the fans saying they did are going to make that so. They said she made a choice and right now that choice is Sawyer. They never said her choice was the right one or that it was permanent. Using the argument Kate slept with Sawyer therefore she loves him, doesn't make it fact. I dare anybody who has commented here to openly admit that every person they slept with they loved. It's not going to happen. Kate is no different. I happen to agree with Michael that Kate is in love with Jack and no amount of rude comments presented here is going to persuade me otherwise, especially when said comments are nothing but attacks on fictional characters lol and personal attacks against Michael and the Jaters. I think the Skaters are in for a rude awakening when they get the rug pulled from underneath them and it's revealed that Kate in fact doesn't love Sawyer. After that happens, I am going to come back to this site and smile at those that were intelligent enough to keep an open mind.

December 16 2006 at 6:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners