Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Criminal Minds: Profiler, Profiled

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Dec 14th 2006 12:11PM

Criminal Minds(S02E12) This show is really hitting its stride. What a great episode. Despite some negativity in response to CBS choosing Criminal Minds as the show airing after this year's Super Bowl, I'm excited about it. Criminal Minds isn't just another crime procedural. It's incredibly unique and, in my opinion, blows the Law and Orders and CSIs of the world out of the water. This show is legit folks and last night's episode was proof of that. You've got to feel good about this show though. It went from being a hardly watched freshman drama last year to a sophomore powerhouse that has been challenging the almighty Lost in Wednesday night ratings.

Here we had something that this show has lacked in recent episodes and hopefully what we got here becomes a trend. What am I talking about? Backstory. Up until now we hadn't gotten too much. We knew about Gideon's blunder that got some team members killed before he joined the BAU and we've gotten some info on Hotch's home-life, his wife, and his child. We even got info on Elle (via her unconscious flashbacks) in the season premiere this year. She's not even on the show anymore and the backstory has run a little dry since then.

Here we had an extremely compelling look in Morgan's past. Where he grew up, his family, and the childhood events that changed his life forever. Kudos to Shemar Moore for the way he's handling the role of Derek Morgan. His performance in this episode was excellent.

This type of story is the kind that I want more of though. At this point, we know what these people are capable of (except Prentiss) and I'm definitely interested to see what makes these characters tick. Hopefully they're all not as disturbing as Morgan's past (being sexually abused as a child and then being framed for murder may have been slightly too much), but I still want to know what's going on in their heads. How did Garcia become the computer genius that she is? What was Reid's childhood like growing up with his schizophrenic mother? What drew JJ, who appears to be the most timid member of the team, to a unit that deals with some of the most horrific killers in the country? All of these are great questions that I'd love answers to.

Other points about this episode:

  • The local detective Gordinsky? Could he have been more incompetent? This episode would have been slightly better if he had been more convincing and we were left with the teeniest potential that maybe Morgan did it. Instead, there was never doubt of Morgan's innocence because this guy was a blithering idiot.
  • I found it interesting how this case placed Gideon and Hotch on different sides. From the beginning, Gideon was never willing to consider Morgan a suspect and never treated him as such. Hotch did. He profiled Morgan while Gideon profiled what mattered -- the case. It'll be interesting to see how Morgan reacts to that treatment in the future because Hotch certainly showed his true colors.

Overall, very good though. I'm looking forward to the Super Bowl episode now. I wonder if the show will be airing in its intended order or if a more suspenseful episode will be shifted to fill that time-slot now?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

18 Comments

Filter by:
trachein

Yvonne (#17)
Morgan's mother was played by Kerrie Keane. She's been in a lot of stuff, including on 90210 for a stint, that may be where you are remembering her from.

December 24 2006 at 5:51 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Yvonne

Who was the lady that played Derek Morgan's mother? I think I remember her from a soap opera. Can't find the information.

December 17 2006 at 8:38 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jonathan Toomey

CC--

The football coach didn't kill the first two victims. They were unsolved, but the circumstances suggested they were killed by the same person. He killed Damien to look like it was the same person, and when he framed Derek, all three murders were thrown at him.

December 17 2006 at 9:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
CC

They didn't really explain why the youth center guy (Carl Buford) killed the 1st two victims - the 3rd boy (Damien) was probably because Damien knew about the abuse and told the boy (forgot his name) to contact Morgan and tell him. Or at least that's what Morgan pieced together. Maybe the 1st two victims resisted Buford's molestation and he killed them? It wasn't clear...

I also thought that the grave Morgan was visiting was his mother's (based on Reid's comment that Morgan always goes to Chicago for his mother's birthday) and then was surprised to see that his mom was white. Also thought it might be a foster parent situation but then I just figured that maybe his father was black, mother was white.

December 17 2006 at 2:34 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ik622

Can someone give me a brief recap. I can not find it anywhere. Our crappy DVR failed and lost the last 15 minutes. Thanks! I gathered the youth center leader did it, but why? Did they give any reasoning, etc. The DVR stopped when the youth center guy was in the police station stating how he regretted having Morgan's record expunged. THANKS:)

December 14 2006 at 11:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mindy Orr

The show dealt with that pretty well. He said he was trying to let the guy keep being a hero...I think its also true that a male victim of sexual abuse has a much more difficult time bringing that out into the light than wome would. Call it male pride... but he was trying to move on with his life. I felt it was believable.

December 14 2006 at 3:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
TomB

Am I the only one who's bothered by the fact that Morgan, after becoming an FBI agent, never did anything about the guy who molested him? From the story, sounds like more than a few kids had been molested since he was. You could argue that the kid he helped was molested because of his inaction.

Hey Prof, there's a link for corrections on the bottom right side of the screen - use it instead of the comments. BTW, Brent KcKee, when you write for a living you really should get it right the first time. Even though you made no errors here your attitude bothered me.

December 14 2006 at 3:44 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mindy Orr

I liked the fact that they didn't explain the white mother. Shows that assume the viewers are intelligent are always more intriguing. On the comedic level, Fraser did the same. Viewers are more savvy than writers give us credit for.

December 14 2006 at 3:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Courtney

There wasn't anything odd about the fact that his on-screen mother was white. It is the same as Shemar Moore's real-life situation--black father/white mother.

December 14 2006 at 3:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Brent McKee

I'm going to stick up for Gordinsky a bit. He is proof positive of the old saying that "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing." His little bit of knowledge is the fairly bare bones profile of the killer that Gideon provided him with. He then took that knowledge and applied it the wrong way. He looked at the case and saw Morgan as the "obvious" suspect. Admittedly it was based on his personal biases against Derek as a "troublemaker" but it fits the profile. Or rather he made it fit the profile. At the same time Gordinsky doesn't consider the actual killer to be a suspect because who really considers his friend to be a possible serial killer? The man was quite literally the pillar of his community, someone who did his best to keep the local boys from turning into the local gangbanger. Gordinsky may have been totally wrong but I'm not sure that calling him incompetent is entirely valid either.

December 14 2006 at 2:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners