Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Battlestar Galactica: Rapture

by Keith McDuffee, posted Jan 21st 2007 11:05PM
battlestar galactica
(S03E12) I think I said this the last time I posted about this episode, but it felt very much like a season premiere or finale, even though it technically isn't a premiere. So many plot points are either semi-resolved or introduced, leaving me to thank the gods that this is just the beginning of another whole half-season of goodness.

Let's go over what I think are the main plot points of the episode, based on the quotes I teased you with last week...

Athena (to Helo): "I'm begging you to do this. Find the courage to do this for both of us, OK?"

I was surprised at how quickly some of you guessed what this quote was referring to -- good call! When I first saw this scene I was taken by surprise, just as I believe the writers were hoping for. If there was any question before that their love for their daughter was true, this certainly settles it.

Tyrol: "Welcome home, Mr. President."

Here again I was surprised at how little this caused a stir with readers. It was pretty obvious that Tyrol encounters Baltar here, though no one questioned why he seemed to be welcoming him home? Maybe you all thought it might be a dream?

Anyway, I can't wait to see how this all plays out with Baltar back on board the Galactica. My guess is that Tyrol hid him in a body bag to show Tigh si they could have a bit of "fun" with him before Adama caught wind of his capture. I think we haven't seen the last of Baltar's bouts of torture just yet.

D'Anna: "You. Forgive me, I ... I had no idea."

I think many of us assumed this would happen eventually, but even still, this is huge! The speculation that'll be tossed around as to who D'Anna could be talking to here will last for quite a while. However, the one quote I didn't add to my list, and one that could possibly considered just as important, is what she says to Baltar: "You were right." And now we all have to wonder just what Baltar's wondering: "Right about what?"

Remember, D'Anna was among the ships of Galactica for quite some time under the guise of a reporter, so she knows quite a lot of that crew. But who could she have thought she'd have to apologize to once she realized that person was a Cylon? Remember, also, that D'Anna looked at at least three of the other Cylons before seeing a face she recognized, so I guess we could assume they are ones we really haven't seen before.

Another observation: Why are there six white tapestries and only a "final five" Cylons? Does D'Anna now take that sixth spot?

Athena: "Don't shoot! She helped us escape!"

Not as huge a plot point as the others, but still a story changer. Another Cylon on board the Galactica, and although she did help Athena escape the Base Star, I'd be pretty disappointed if she suddenly became so quickly trusted as Athena has become. But now with Athena knowing that her baby was hidden all this time from her by humans, will she work with Six to do some damage in retaliation? Lots to look forward to with this.

Brother Cavil: "Your model is fundamentally flawed."

I thought it was pretty obvious all along that D'Anna's model would be the one to be boxed, as many spoilers had indicated would happen. What's surprising now, though, is what her model has taken to the, er, box with her: the knowledge of who at least several of the unrevealed Cylons are.

While these weren't the only advances in the story, it seems everything else is vastly overshadowed by those mentioned above. Though there's some advancement in the Galactica's search for Earth, it's almost a little insignificant here.

What were your thoughts on the show airing on Sunday night? Personally I like it a lot better, though luckily I didn't have to contend against football tonight with having the DVD ahead of time.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

70 Comments

Filter by:
chris w

Kara as Cylon.....Hmmmm. Just throwing that out there...

January 28 2007 at 6:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chris w

lol Akbar: "That place put Mos Eisley to shame in terms of scum and villany."

January 26 2007 at 9:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Akbar Fazil

I do my main chatting for BSG here and over at ragnar anchorage.

I stay well away from the scifi.com message boards. That place put Mos Eisley to shame in terms of scum and villany.

January 25 2007 at 11:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mb

@akbar,

I hadn't realized that the second-from-left cylon does look like Samuel Anders.

I wasn't aware of other threads elsewhere, so I apologize for that. This might be inappropriate to ask here, but what other forums do you visit for BSG threads?

Thanks.

January 25 2007 at 10:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Akbar Fazil

mb, ive seen many discussions on that pic.
Your ideas are interesting but I hadn't heard any of them. The two I had heard were Anders and Cally.

I think RDM let it get released without the glow effect just so we would speculate on the internet about who the final five are. I do not think we have met ANY of the final five yet at this point.

January 25 2007 at 9:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mb

Whoops... sorry about double posting my entry.

January 25 2007 at 9:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chris w

mb

I am not seeing it. Although the Helo and Caprica references are plausible.

January 25 2007 at 9:26 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tim McCleese

Ian: I will add to your question in why didn't D'anna tell somebody anything? She was silent to the end and would not talk details about this exraordinary experience even to save her skin. She must have gotten some divine instuction in the matter not to reveal any specifics. Another of your points that I agree with...why did Caprica go along with Sharon? I don't think it was for the messhall food.

January 25 2007 at 8:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mb

I apologize in advance if this has already been discussed, but...

Has anyone seen this hi-def screencap of D'Anna encountering the final 5 cylons in her vision?

http://galactica.emedian.net/episode/3.11/images/NUP_101665_2694.jpg

You can clearly see the bottom half of their faces if you zoom in (one female model is smiling). Are these actors the real deal or are they only "stand-in's" and not intended to be seen up close????

*IF* they are the real thing, then who do you recognize? My odd thinking says:

- leftmost cylon looks like Tigh with a goatee (doubtful, I know because he looks short).
- cylon second from left sort of resembles Helo.
- middle cylon (smiling female) sort of looks like Caprica 6.
- cylon second from right looks vaguely like the medic who operated on Commander Adama (SE02EP01).
- rightmost cylon looks like Captain "Aaron Kelly" (sp?) who joins Tigh on the bridge after Adama is shot (SE02EP01).

Ok... what do you all think? I think this show is my new favorite series now that Dexter is on hiatus...

Thanks!

January 25 2007 at 8:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mb

I apologize in advance if this has already been discussed, but...

Has anyone seen this hi-def screencap of D'Anna encountering the final 5 cylons in her vision?

http://galactica.emedian.net/episode/3.11/images/NUP_101665_2694.jpg

You can clearly see the bottom half of their faces if you zoom in (one female model is smiling). Are these actors the real deal or are they only "stand-in's" and not intended to be seen up close????

*IF* they are the real thing, then who do you recognize? My odd thinking says:

- leftmost cylon looks like Tigh with a goatee (doubtful, I know because he looks short).
- cylon second from left sort of resembles Helo.
- middle cylon (smiling female) sort of looks like Caprica 6.
- cylon second from right looks vaguely like the medic who operated on Commander Adama (SE02EP01).
- rightmost cylon looks like Captain "Aaron Kelly" (sp?) who joins Tigh on the bridge after Adama is shot (SE02EP01).

Ok... what do you all think? I think this show is my new favorite series now that Dexter is on hiatus...

Thanks!

January 25 2007 at 8:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners