Powered by i.TV
February 10, 2012
 
CONNECT    

24's family affairs

by Meredith O'Brien, posted Jan 23rd 2007 4:01PM

Paul McCrane*Warning . . . spoilers about the recent episode of 24 ahead . . .*

I had a long conversation with a big fan of 24 who thought that last night's plot twist -- having Jack Bauer's brother Graham (see actor Paul McCrane from his ER days on the right) turn out to be a villain who wanted his brother killed and having his father Phillip be sketchy -- is a bad sign for the show.

Saying that the new family connections "make it all seem like it's just about three people" and not about global terrorism, seemed to him to be jumping-the-sharkish. In fact, this 24 fan told me that the story line reminded him of Alias, when the writing started to go awry and there were all these sudden, forced familial connections between characters during its last season.

I, however, defended the Jack-Bauer's-family-is-screwed-up-and-mysterious story, saying that it was intriguing to sprinkle in Shakespearean drama amidst the likes of Abu Fayed and suitcase nukes. But I must say that having Graham be the same guy who gave orders to President Logan last season did strike me as stretching the limits of credulity, even when you really, really try to believe. Jack's father having business ties to an ex-Soviet general, I can buy that . . . plus I love James Cromwell, who's playing Phillip Bauer and can't wait for him to appear. However there's something about the Graham thing that does feel somewhat forced.

And if some of the folks who've posted comments about the new episode are correct in their suspicions that Jack's nephew Josh is really his son, the result of an affair with his sister-in-law Marilyn, then I will vigorously roll my eyes and wonder whether I've accidentally switched the station and am watching something other than an action-adventure show, maybe something from a soap opera network.

Last week, a TV Guide blogger, suggested that, despite some weird story turns (Think Kim and the cougar), that 24 might be "shark proof." I hope that the antics of the Bauer boys on day six don't prove him wrong.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

15 Comments

Filter by:
griff

for some good fun 24-esque action, click here ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xMtmESwB9o

January 24 2007 at 5:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mack Swift

A lot of people last season thought the show jumped the shark when they killed off 3 major characters in the first ten minutes (2 and severely wounded Tony).

I thought that was a great plot twist last nite and adds something different to 24. The last few seasons were about Jack and his crew racing the clock to save the country. Remember, before this season started up, the producers did say that this time it was also going to be about Jack saving his own ass as well as the country's.

January 23 2007 at 7:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Europa

I meant to say, "How freak'n cool would it have been for Donald Sutherland to play Jack's *father*?!" (Sorry about that.) Donald Sutherland playing Jack's brother? Now *that* would be a twist.

January 23 2007 at 6:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
radwimp

I agree with #7, bring back Nina! The one true 24 villian!

January 23 2007 at 6:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jake

Let's not forget that the big success of last year was not the terrorism itself, but the President, his wife, and the character drama that resulted. Also, Alias was a family drama disguised as a spy show. 24 is an action show that has always had family drama:

Season 1 : Jack's family. Palmers part 1
Season 3: Michelle and Tony, Kim and Chase, Palmers part 2
Season 4: Michelle and Tony part 2: the splits, Jack love triangle, Jack letting 1 of the love triangle die (paul)
5: Presidential circle drama.
6: Jack's family part 2, Palmers part 3

So this really isn't out of the blue and not all that unexpected.

January 23 2007 at 6:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Europa

You know I was worried about the fact that I chose to watch "Heroes" last night instead of "24" (and recording one while watching the other, unfortunately, doesn't work on my cable set-up) but after reading this I'm thinking I made a wise choice. Agggh! Besides the now obvious endangerment of this show "jumping the shark," Paul McCrane as Jack's brother?!?! I have nothing against Paul as a person, and he's a fine actor (I've been a fan since he's guest starred on "The X-Files"), but in the looks department him being Jack's brother is somewhat of an insult to Kiefer! (In the eye of the beholder, I guess.) And I all ready thought Palmer's brother becoming president was a bit of a stretch but in some ways I can see that. (Bobby ran after JFK was assassinated and so forth.) But I don't know how I feel about this little wrinkle especially with the "middle eastern terrorist" thing starting to wear a little thin with me. Can't we find something else to give Jack a bad day? And I guess Kiefer and his real life dad haven't made up much either. How freak'n cool would it have been for Donald Sutherland to play Jack's brother?!

Anyway, I know many people were a little hot under the collar last week when they felt you had to many spoilers right up front without any warning. I was not one of them. (I figure in this day and age any half way savvy TV-file should know not to read blogs and such of their favorite shows before watching the episode in question. I mean forget about the Internet. How many times has the networks themselves presented significant spoilers in the 30-second promos or previews?) As long as this show is up against "Heroes" I'm glad you're here so I can stay caught up. Thanks.

January 23 2007 at 6:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
tcc3

As long as this show is being rediculous (i love every unbelivable, explosive minute) I want Nina's clone or evil-er sister to come back one year.

January 23 2007 at 6:13 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ac

Anyone think Jack is adopted because I see no family resemblance. Also I rolled my eyes with the brother twist too.

January 23 2007 at 5:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ac

Anyone think Jack is adopted because I see no family resemblance. Also I rolled my eyes with the brother twist too.

January 23 2007 at 5:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ben

Here's the key difference between 24's Bauers and Alias's Bristows: overuse. Consider: Alias's first season had to do with Sydney Bristow and her father (not to mention her fiance, since it's understandable that the main character of a show gets a romantic storyline). Season 2, Syd's mother becomes a main character. Season 4, her sister. Season 5, her mother again. So while Alias was jamming Bristows down our throats, 24 was pretty restrained after the first two seasons. Yes, we had the Audrey and Daddy Heller characters, but that' s more relevant romantically (see above). I, for one, thought it was a mind-blowing revelation. Graham was such a creepy character last year, and I was wondering if we would see him again. Then he's involved in this year's plot (ok, a little stretch, but still) AND he's Jack's brother? I'll give the writers a lot of room to fit that into the plot, since they've rarely let me down before.

January 23 2007 at 5:10 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners