Powered by i.TV
February 10, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Gilmore Girls: Santa's Secret Stuff

by Joel Keller, posted Jan 23rd 2007 9:55PM
Gilmore Girls: Santa's Secret Stuff(S07E11) When I was out in LA, I ran into a few members of the Gilmore Girls cast at the various network parties. Whenever I brought up the topic of whether there's going to be another season or not, the answer I got didn't seem to vary much. It wasn't definitive by any means, but the general feeling was that, yes, we're probably seeing the last episodes of the long-running show.

That's a good thing, folks. While episodes like tonight's had quite a bit of the chemistry of the first five-plus seasons, you just know that it's not going to last. But at least we're seeing some peeks into what we might see in the second half of the year, and it certainly looks like the Chris/Lor 'shippers are going to be disappointed.

Think about it; didn't it just seem like Lorelai had this look of "My God! Luke is maturing before my very eyes!" as she listened to his plea for her to write that letter of recommendation? After all, he's now stepping up and defending his right to be in April's life and he's asking Lor for help. Too bad this didn't happen a year ago, right? Anyway, between this scene and the scene in the science store, Lor realizes that Luke hasn't only been in her life a hell of a lot more than Chris, but he's been more of a father to Rory than Chris has ever been. And judging by the scenes from next week, Chris is going to find that out as well (you knew the minute she got up from her typewriter that Chris was going to find the handwritten version. Too bad we have to wait until next week to see it).

This episode proves once again that Lorelai and Rory speaking to each other on the phone can't replicate the chemistry between Alexis Bledel and Lauren Graham when they are interacting in person in a scene. That has been in woefully short supply this year, and I hope they give Rory more excuses to hang around Stars Hollow; maybe make her winter break two or three months long or something.

The whole Christmas-in-January plot? It was cute, I guess. It served as a convenient way to show that Rory has been in London with Logan. It also gave them an excuse to show GiGi (I thought she was in France?) talking about Santa and to put Rory and Lorelai in silly holiday sweaters. I thought it was funny that Lor didn't mind talking about Luke in front of GiGi, figuring she wouldn't understand a word of it. I'm surprised she didn't blab when Chris walked in the room; that's what usually happens in TV-ville, right?

And Chris still doesn't seem to get it; yes, the Ror/Lor Xmas tradition seems weird and closed-off. But instead of going with it, Chris overdoes it again, pulling out stockings that even Martha Stewart would find too ornate. He's trying to force the family together instead of letting it find its flow, and it's not working.

Here's what I don't get, though: Rory's a pretty sharp person. How can she equate "I didn't tell artsy chick about me and Marty" with "hey, how 'bout telling Dad about helping Luke keep his kid?"

Always nice to see April again, and that's saying a lot, considering what a disruptive force she was last season. You can see that she's Rory from Season One, with all the precociousness and desire to break out of being a kid and just do what she wants. It's kind of sad that such a bright kid, even a fictional one, needs to be stuck in the middle of such a dispute, but that's the way it is. I mean, how many teenage girls get all happy when they get a rock-polishing kit?

OK, a quick word about the "Lane is giving birth to a beach ball" plot. When was the last time we saw her and Zack? Because she's gone from "I'm pregnant!" to being seemingly 8-9 months along. Yes, I know twins are a hefty load for a woman to carry; just ask my sister-in-law (Rich's wife, of course). But, if the calendar is to be believed, Lane should only be 4-5 months along. I guess she could be this big already, but it seems like they're exaggerating her belly just so we could have an episode full of "Angry Behemoth Lane." It does seem like she never got a chance to have fun as an adult; from hiding her drumsticks from her mother to being pregnant within two years. Yikes. I don't blame her for still wanting to be rock 'n' roll, despite the bundles of babies she's got growing inside her. Nice touch with Sebasitan Bach's kid (not his real kid, his character's kid). It's a little girl wearing a Ramones t-shirt and a ski cap. "What up?" Cool.

By the way: one Michel scene and one Sookie scene. Why even bother calling them to the set if you're not going to give them anything to do?

So, like I said, overall, the episode wasn't bad. And the Aerie Girls finally got the boot, which is always a good thing. But I can start to hear a faint sound in the background of this show. When I strain to hear it, I recognize it's sound: a rattle. The death rattle. Can you hear it, too?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

23 Comments

Filter by:
Kate

Please bring back Amy Sherman-Palladino to write and direct at least the last few episodes. Only she can untagle this web of mediocrity that the show is now in. My amazing husband (little plug for my sweetie)and I are HUGE Gilmore Girls fans...have loved the show for years. But it's just a shadow of what it once was, lacking in vision, and using cheap ploys in the form of soap opera-esque storylines to gain viewers. Bring back Rory's intelligence, wit, and personality - don't make her flaky and silly! Bring back Lorelai's backbone and vision for her and her daughter - sure she's always been dysfunctional - but she at least had a plan while attacking the world with her quick wit and tireless enthusiasm. And all the quirky Stars Hollow freaks - bring 'em on!! The talent is there in the actors...they just need great writing (not references thrown in just to add references), and direction that conveys the expressions and range of the characters. You can do it, CW! Those bus ads give me hope! ;-)

January 26 2007 at 12:49 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Julie

I am so glad the aeire girls are gone for what ever reason. Are the CW and AE the same company? Really those spots were bad...it made me not want to shop at AE or watch the show...glad they are gone!

I would like to see Rory graduate ...then the series end. Just my thoughts.

January 24 2007 at 10:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Adrienne

Exactly, Viv! ASP was the one who had to give Luke a daughter that he didn't need. She was the one who had Lorelai end up in bed with Christopher at the end of last season. It would have been nice if Christopher and Lorelai hadn't married, but those are the cards we've been dealt.

January 24 2007 at 5:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

Viv

Amy what's her name wrecked the show. The last few seasons she wrote the show into a ditch and then went "Well I screwed up this show, let's leave".

January 24 2007 at 11:24 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Robin

I felt that Lane "appearing" so big (even with twins)was more of her perception of what she looked like to people.

January 24 2007 at 11:06 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Lee

Personally, I've never seen anything as stupid and absurd as those aerie girl sessions. I watched just a few seconds of the first one and thought "yikes, is this what the once wonderful, clever GG has been reduced to?" Sadly, the answer was yes. Good riddence however the end came about.
I fell in love with this show from the pilot - and, now, it is so hard to watch - I too would like to see it end this year. It's painful to watch the horrid dialogue, bad direction and silly storylines.
I watch the first five seasons now as if they are a different show because, for me, it is a different show. Watching now is mostly from habit and because I would like to see a good ending for the characters I care most about. But, I haven't watched a full episode since last year's terrible Valentine's episode.
(I'm a different Courtney that the earlier one above. Just wanted to clarify.)

January 24 2007 at 10:09 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kassy

The aerie girls did not "get the boot" per say. American Eagle was giving away a walk on roll to veronica mars as part of their campaign. Along with that, at AE when they play music videos and such, they played all the "extras" from Gilmore Girls and Veronica Mars. Despite the Aerie girls being annoying, they were beneficial to both shows. I work for the CW and American Eagle, and you would surprised how many more people starting watching both shows because of AE. The aerie girls left because the campaign was over.

January 24 2007 at 9:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Viv

Bring back Amy!

Bring back Amy!

Nothing has been the same since she quit writing the script. We're praying it dies this year -- we can't quit watching, but it's like seeing a beloved family member fade from disease. You really want to move on to other things.

January 24 2007 at 9:01 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mandy

I think Lily is right, Lane should be about eight months pregnant now. However, I hate that TV seems to think every woman carrying twins is the size of a cruise ship. And if Lane really was that huge, I would be amazed if she could be on her feet all day waiting tables.

I thought last night's episode was mediocre. I'm tired of Lorelai acting like a child and Christopher acting like, well, Christopher. I have loved this show since the pilot, but I really hope this season is their last.

January 24 2007 at 8:52 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jamie

I tend to agree with Lily on the timeline of Lane's pregnancy. Remember she got married in April/May & got pregnant on her honeymoon, which would make her 8 months pregnant. The season premiere happened right after the finale, but the first couple episodes kept happening weeks and weeks later until the third or fourth episode it was fall.

Even though Logan wasn't in this episode, I'm just glad we got to see Rory and Lorelai together, it seemed like forever since we've seen them together.

January 24 2007 at 8:41 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners