Powered by i.TV
February 11, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Gilmore Girls: To Whom It May Concern

by Joel Keller, posted Jan 30th 2007 10:43PM
Gilmore Girls(S07E12) For some reason, despite everything that has happened to make this show start circling the drain, four Gilmore characters can be relied upon to entertain, no matter who is writing the episode: Emily, Richard, Sookie and Paris. All four of them are in tonight's episode (Emily is just in the cold open, but it counts), and, I've got to tell you, their presence made it pretty decent as a result.

Otherwise? Um... well... Let's just say this crawl towards the inevitable Lorelai - Luke reunion is driving me nuts.

Oh, come on, people; we know it's going to happen. They couldn't project this in bigger letters if they rented out the local drive-in. First, there was the letter; it wasn't just a character reference for Luke's custody case, it was emotional, heartfelt, and emotional (yes, I said that already. It was that good). You knew the stomach-punch parts of it, if Chris were to ever find it, were when Lorelai said that Luke was always there for Rory -- implying, of course, that Chris wasn't -- and that when Luke enters a person's life, he stays forever.

And, of course you knew Chris was going to find it (It was in the coming attractions last week, anyway... thanks, CW promotions!), and of course you knew that he was going to overreact. But leave? Disappear? Over that letter? Really? Isn't Chris supposed to be mature and responsible now, not bolting at the slightest sign of trouble? I mean, for crissakes, he even had trouble choking down coffee from Luke's diner, much less dealing with this letter. What a baby. Granted, the letter was quite a bit more than a character reference, and maybe he was just realizing what the entire Gilmore-watching public knew already: that he was Lor's second choice. But being married means working through these issues, or at least trying. It's not about getting liquored up and running back to Hartford.

Anyway, it's not like Lor and Luke don't have their own issues. Anna, who all of a sudden has been made a bitch, tells Luke before their custody hearing that he bailed on Lorelai, to which he vehemently objected. Technically, he's right. But he became emotionally unavailable to the point where Lor walked away. If Anna had actually known how that all went down, she might have retained full custody of April instead of losing her on every other holiday (by the way, I was actually kind of surprised that Luke won so quickly. The letter may have turned the tide, considering his behavior during the visit with the judge. But that would be too easy for the writers to write... wouldn't it?).

Moving on... Was Sookie's harumphing over Jackson's non-vasectomy adorable or what? News of Melissa McCarthy's pregnancy had been floating around the web for a while, so this turn of events wasn't unexpected. But it's nice to see her and Jackson get more screen time; lately we've just seen Sook sitting in the inn's kitchen saying "Are you sure you're OK with Luke doing blah blah blah?" to Lorelai all the time. It's good to see that the writers have realized she's good at other stuff, too.

Here's what I want to know: why is Rory following Paris' nutty post-graduation scheme of grant applications and taking unnecessary tests like the MCATs ("Sanjay Gupta. CNN's chief medical correspondent. He's cornered the market.")? Is it because she doesn't know what she wants to do with herself? Is she humoring Paris? Or was she just trying to distract herself from the whole "Lucy hates me" issue? Thankfully, Paris decided to get Ror and Lucy back together with her own heartfelt speech about how Rory is one of the best and how lucky she is to be friends with her (believe me, I'm being more sentimental about it than Paris was). And those tiny, portable reproductions of Paris' whiteboards were pretty funny. Don't you think a Paris spin-off would be a hoot? Maybe as a half-hour single-camera sitcom...

So Lucy broke up with Marty. Do I see a Marty-Logan-Rory triangle in the offing? God, I hope not. And Richard decided to go have himself a heart attack; I guess all the years of cigars and awful Mexican quail dishes finally caught up with him. It's the perfect device to show what kind of a schmuck Chris is and how wonderful Luke is, isn't it?

Like I said, this episode was better than the season's average. But the continuing weird characterizations of Chris -- "I can't believe I drank his coffee!" -- and Rory -- "I don't know what I want to do with my life, even though I've wanted to be a journalist since I was in diapers!" -- are still bothersome to me. Oh well. I guess a half-decent Gilmore episode is better than what we've been getting so far this year.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

23 Comments

Filter by:
iroj630

Does anyone think that Rory should somehow, someway end up with Jess? I think he should propose somewhere along the line, maybe when Logan and Rory get in ANOTHER fight over Logan's immaturity. I DO NOT think Rory should end up with someone like Logan. I was so charmed by him in the beginning, but when I rewatch all the old seasons, Rory doesn't belong with someone rich and priveledged. She grew up with a funny frugal single-mother, and she loved her small town, bad eating habits, and her BOOKS. Jess was so attractive to her because he understood her like no one else could. Dean wasn't right for her, even though they were cute. And I see how Logan is charming, but I don't think he's right either. The only person I ever thought was right for Rory was Jess. And she loved him too.

February 12 2007 at 2:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tammy

FYI - the actress that plays Sookie is pregnant again and they wanted to write it into the script like her last two pregnancies. So this wasn't just because they were out of story lines.

We finally got to see this episode today because our showing was interrupted by college basketball on Tues. But I was a tad disappointed in how the whole custody case was handled. That just seemed wrong and why wasn't April there? It's obvious how much April wanted to be with Luke so was Anna leaving her out? Just seemed odd.

As happy as I am to see Lor and Chris break up but this was handled poorly. I just seems a tad dramatic. Plus what I didn't get is how much money Chris throws around and he's installing that flat panel himself?

February 04 2007 at 11:40 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Stevie

allison - how did chris bail on lor when they were 16? he was down w/ richard's plan to marry her and raise rory w/ her parents -- she's the one who ran away.
but it doesn't matter, b/c the show never really respected its own past. it has always bugged me that chris wasn't at rory's graduation, and even tho they're using that now as a way to show that he hasn't been there for her, it didn't jibe w/ the way his character had been acting up till then. he wasn't there b/c the actor had a crappy sitcom to do. period.
dean was a cool guy who read books and like indie music, until the show decided they wanted to make jess the cool guy who read books, and suddenly dean was an idiot who thought everything rory liked was boring. dave ragowski (sp?) was lane's soul mate until the OC came along, then after 2 mentions of his name the show acted like he never ever existed. any time a secondary char gets mad at a gg it's for the same reason: they found out about something lor or rory didn't tell them about b/c she was being stupid. how has lor not learned her lesson about hiding crap from her SO?
i think i mentioned in an earlier post that i was really annoyed by lane's pregnancy, esp since i felt they did it b/c when they want a new plot element to spruce up the show, they knock up sookie, so when they couldn't do that anymore they did it to lane. now they've done it to sookie again!!! wtf????!!!!

February 02 2007 at 9:03 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lissy

i want lor and chris to stay togeather! well it probally wont happen. and i think that insted of gettin into a marty/rory/logan triangle it should be a jess/rory/logan triangle. but that wont happen cuz since the time jess first came on Alexis and Milo were actully boyfriend and girlfriend but they broke up in like the 6th season so i dont think he will come back on for uh real life issues. but maybe! im crossin my fingers on that one!!

February 01 2007 at 3:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lissy

i LOVE gilmore girls but even though luke and lorelai are ment to be i want it to be her and chris!! and i was shocked when richard had a heart attack! but i found out that he will be fine and that in the end of the season lorelai and luke are going to get married and have a baby!! i hope it isent true!! i want it to be chris and lor!!
well toodles i hope u ppl reply to this comment!LOL

February 01 2007 at 3:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Karen

watching any of this season's episodes has been such a drag. The de-evolution of Rory especially. Just saw a rerun of the Chilton graduation episode. She *used* to be a self assured person. And this Christopher stuff is sooo contrived. Oh and what ever happened to all the people who live in Stars Hollow? What, did Patty and Taylor move?

January 31 2007 at 8:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Katie

Mandy, you're totally right, Anna has always been a bitch... and Christopher has always been immature. The only real chance they had was back in Season 2 but then his girlfriend got pregnant. They've both been grasping at straws trying to make it work now...

Rory has been annoying for the past few seasons and it continues. The whole Lucy thing? Rory just couldn't stand the fact that someone in the universe was mad at her and didn't think she was perfect. Joel, she said several times in the episode that she wasn't going along with Paris. She's just humoring her, partly because it's Paris, and partly because she doesn't know what to do with her life. Which is stupid! Now she doesn't want to be a journalist? Endlessly annoying...

January 31 2007 at 5:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Allison

Anna has always acted like that towards Luke. She never told him he had a daughter for pete's sake! Then when they made contact, she made it clear that she called the shots. I don't think her character has changed at all over the past year.

January 31 2007 at 1:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Margaret

This episode is the first one for me that truly felt natural Gilmorian, through and through. Paris is just a wonderful counterpoint to Rory's indecisiveness and people pleasing ways. More Paris!

Thanks to justelise and MrsEldubya for pretty much summing up my thinking as well on the Chris/Lorelai/Luke relationships.

January 31 2007 at 1:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jasmine

Okay, so my landlord's and I get together on Tuesdays for GG and last night's episode called for a pause of the DVR and commentary. WTF?!? I could not believe that Chris upped and walked out over that letter. Was the letter emotional? Yes, but Lor was freakin' engaged to Luke for crying out loud! I think the underlying issue was that the letter emphasized how Luke was there for Rory, for all of her birthdays and yadda, yadda, yadda and Chris is kicking himself because Luke was there for his kid (Rory) and he should've been. Let's not foget to mention that Rory turned out great (minus all the huffing and puffing about Lucy...c'mon now!)and I think Chris really regrets not being there. And Chris had his stankin' nerve to jump on Lor about still being in love with Luke! Hold up! How many times has he left Lor hanging? That's what he does best is up and leave. Remember when Lor fell back in love with him a few seasons back and he went and married Gigi's mom? I'm glad I'm not in Lor's shoes b/c Chris surely would've got told. Chris and Lor are married now, that's a whole other level of committment. No one said marriage was easy, but you're supposed to work at it. To fight for it.

Let me go to Luke and Anna a minute. Anna had her nerve talking about how Luke left Lor! If it weren't for Anna bitching it up and telling Luke she didn't want different women (Lor) around April, perhaps he wouldn't have drove Lor away. That's my thought on that. And who does Anna think she is? Her daughter found her dad, a dad that loves her and wants to be in her life. Why would Anna want to deny April of that?

January 31 2007 at 11:26 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners