Powered by i.TV
February 12, 2012
 
CONNECT    

House: One Day, One Room

by Tom Biro, posted Jan 31st 2007 11:55AM
House - One Day, One Room
(S03E12) It's certainly been a while since we've been treated to Dr. House's charms and ability to make patients feel better in a single bound, but now he's back, and better than ever. Or, at least he's out of jail, and back on the Vicodin. One of the better strings of dialogue that this show has had was in last night's show, when House and Cuddy are discussing the fact that she perjured herself to keep him out of jail, and now he's going to do clinic duty, and next he's going to do his paperwork because she kept him out of jail, and so on and so forth. He's *so* right, and she *so* knows it, and that's why you have to love their interaction, because it digresses to the high school-esque flirting situation, even if it is only from one side, every so often.

Other than the "opening up" that House did on this episode, the other thing that struck me in a big way was the lack of focus on the rest of the characters, sans Cameron. She's left to contend with a patient struck down with a cancerous mass in his lung, who is looking for a place to sleep. He appears to have figured out about her husband's suffering, but she quickly determines that a nurse led him on. To me, this almost felt like this patient was playing a "ghost of Christmas past" type of character, sent there just for Cameron, to change her perspective on things.

House's dealings with Eve, the only clinic patient who happens to have an STD, definitely broke down a fence that we hadn't even approached before. She, after being raped, and coming down with chlamydia (and later is determined to be pregnant), lashes out at House when he touches her. His attempt to pawn her off to another doctor in the hospital end up drawing him back to her in a number of ways, especially when he sees how she reacts to the other doc by trying to kill herself with medication.

Telling stories is something House is prone to do, especially when dealing with younger patients, and others he just wants to get rid of. This time around, with Eve, he tells a story as it traces back to his grandmother, and she doesn't believe that it could be the case, and he just boiled down and played it off as a lie. What I was so surprised by was that, in the end, he came out and told her what the real deal was, how his father was the one forcing him to take ice baths, among other things. He knew, deep down (is there a deep down in House?) that he had to give something up to get her to tell her story, and that that would be the only way that Eve would be able to heal. He also seemed to want to say that she would have a hard time, later on in life, if she had given birth to the baby of the man who raped her. Cuddy wanted House to get a little more humanized by working with patients in the clinic, but I am guessing she wasn't expecting to have this kind of result in this short of a time period. He didn't even have to spend the whole three days there before having a solid breakdown of his own that helped someone for the better.

With Tritter far out of the way, House seemingly making Cuddy a little more happy, and Cameron having a life-changing experience, what could come next for this band of physicians? More random, reckless surgery, or perhaps just more dramatic caseloads that make us all want to scratch our eyes out? I'm still one to say that there's a high chance of someone leaving the team, and the money seems to be leaning towards Cameron, more than Foreman, who had his taste of power not so long ago, and might want more of it. But a little foreshadowing doesn't go a long way on this show, as we've learned a number of times before.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

21 Comments

Filter by:
DeAnn

I loved this episode...it was fantastic, philosophical, but not in a boring way, touched on deep issues, such as abortion and rape, and gave us insight into why House is House. He had an abusive a-hole for a father, obviously, and I am sure further eps will reveal more about his characters internal workings. My only qualm was why the rape victim never did tell us exactly why she had to have House as her doc, or to tell him her story. Was it an attraction to him? Was it because he reminded her of her rapist? I thought it was a bit too convenient that she did abort the fetus in the end, when she'd been so adamant about having it and, I assume, giving it up for adoption. I am very pro-choice, but it seemed to me that she was using her pregnancy as a way to get further attention from House. Having been a rape victim myself, I can honestly say that she made the right decision to terminate the pregnancy, but I would have thought, for someone as smart as this gal seemed to be, that she would have come to that decision on her own, instead of needing a lecture from House on how its not her fault, blah, blah, blah...she certainly already knew all that. And to the person who said they expected the grizzled street guy to be the rapist, so did I! I figured then Cameron would find it easier to watch him die in pain, knowing he was a dirtbag. Really, having worked in Hospice for years, I found the whole "let me die in pain" thing to be a bit much. I think the guy was just looking for a warm bed and a last meal. And none of the people I took care of said no to pain meds at the end. Not one. That's because the pain of dying from cancer is tremendous. Not something you can withstand without drugs. He died too fast and too peacefully for it to be realistic. Anyway, great ep, certainly one of the top 5 in my book.

February 07 2007 at 4:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
rod

'I think that it would have been better with a real medical mystery that he would have knocked it out of the park with, one that reminds Cuddy and Wilson WHY House is... well... House.'

That has been made clear on many episodes, including the last one with Tritter and the cartilage-hair dysplasiac woman with the daughter who was misdiagnosed until House had the 'Eureka!' at the end. This was a good time to bring out something challenging to him beyond medical mysteries, his feelings that he's avoided confronting and discussing with anyone. As he said in the last episode, he doesn't know how to handle the situation of a girl being raped. I like to compare this episode in a way with the one that had John Larroquette starring in 'Son of a Coma Guy.' House had to give up something of himself in order to know more about this guy and how he might've gotten sick. And near the end, when he's confronted about why he became a doctor, the manner in which House tells the story is just as it was with the girl in the last episode when wanting to know what horrible thing happened to him. Some people think he lied in the last one to get what he wanted, to help with the girl's suffering by being open, etc., but I I don't believe so. As far as the girl OD on meds and her quote about life being sacred, I agree House could've questioned her as to why she tried to kill herself. But, we already knew her motive, as it was more for attention, his specifically, so the argument would've been useless by then.

February 06 2007 at 12:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Steve

campy psuedo-intellectual talk gets them every time.

I feel sorry for the people that think anything spoken about in this episode was "deep".

I also don't like the fact that the people writing for an atheist house are obviously not atheist. It really gets annoying that he has no answers to simple "philosophical" questions posed to him.

Luckily the rest of the writing and the cast make up for what is easily one of the poorest episodes of House. I did like the lack of a major medical dilemma though, but it only went far enough to point out the inadequacies of the writing staff of this show.

Here's looking forward to next week!

February 03 2007 at 5:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Misty

Personally, I think that the show needed this episode. We have been trying for weeks to get inside what makes House the way that he is. This episode helps explain why he has to be so annoyingly perfect on every case. As for Tritter being long gone, I don't think so. He was gnawing on that nicotine gum more than House was popping pills for the past couple weeks. In my opinion, Tritter will reappear in the form of a patient that needs House's profound medical voodoo power to make things all better and then the question will be...will House help him?

February 01 2007 at 1:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Michael

You've also GOT to love House's explanation to Cuddy just why he wasn't in rehab any longer. After teasing us and his fellow physicians with all the reasons he should go and promising that it wasn't just an excuse to get Tritter off of his back, lo and behold it was just that after all! Classic House!

I too loved this episode and I disagree that this should not have been the episode they returned from a break with. This was the strongest episode since the final two episodes of Season One and it served to hook us right back in for the remainder of the season. I was getting soooooo tired of the predictibility of how the episodes were getting and this one did a 180 on that. Thanks for renewing my faith in one of my favorite shows!

February 01 2007 at 1:13 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jack

The interaction between House and Eve was... strange. I half-expected this to be a drug-induced hallucination by House, when he was talking to the guy in his mind after he was shot.

And I know the girl was troubled, confused, had been raped, had an STD, and was pregnant, but her "Every life is sacred" argument could have been stopped with "Then why did you try to kill yourself?"

I dind't understand that part.

February 01 2007 at 12:22 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Alicia

Although I am in the minority here, I didn't like it. I didn't like that they gave us this episode after a 3 week break. Next week it would have been better.

I just thought it was too... campy. Although the line about being stuck in a room was rather deep.

I think that it would have been better with a real medical mystery that he would have knocked it out of the park with, one that reminds Cuddy and Wilson WHY House is... well... House.

February 01 2007 at 7:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
scott mclendon

BOOOORRRRIIINNNNGGGG!!!!

February 01 2007 at 1:50 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Stevie

AWESOME ep; i was really surprised they didn't have a medical mystery, but i am a sucker for the philosophical talkiness. i've said it before - when are they going to run out of ways to get house to open up to people? this one was beyond transparent: the girl insisting on talking to him for reasons even she doesn't know? i half expected her to say, "because the writers want me to." who cares? their interaction was great. what makes hugh laurie so brilliant is his ability to convey exactly what's going on and still be enigmatic. i knew during the whole grandmother story that it was a lie because of the way he said it. finding out that it was actually covering a truth made it all make sense (unlike this post). i guess i'm trying to say he tells us tons without saying anything outright. it's one of the things that makes the show really fun.

January 31 2007 at 9:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Karen

overall, a very, very fine "House." Missed having a real case though. As far as the rumors of anyone of the team leaving, I don't think any of them should go. The three of them balance each other well... and act as sort of a nice greek chorus. Now with Tritter out of the picture, I'm hoping Cameron/Chase/Foreman finally get some screen time.

January 31 2007 at 8:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners