Could Jory Steinberg be the next American Idol?

by Liz Finn-Arnold, posted Jan 31st 2007 4:53PM
Jory SteinbergWho is Jory Steinberg, you ask? She's a 25-year-old singer, originally from Canada, who showed up at Idol's New York auditions, and impressed the heck out of the judges with her "professionalism."

It's only been a week since the rest of us set eyes on Jory, and yet she's already creating a small buzz on the internet. That's what a little bit of exposure in front of 30 million people will do for a young artist. Jory has some impressive experience, and seems like a shoo-in for this competition.

But let's not get ahead of ourselves or count our Canadian eggs before they're hatched. We haven't even met all the contestants yet, or gone through Hell Week. And we all know things can get pretty unpredictable once the American public becomes involved with the outcome of the competition.

Still, Jory certainly appears to have the "total package." She's young, skinny, and attractive, and sure can belt out a song. She's also well-spoken, polite, and seems like she's a fairly nice person.

She appeared nervous before her audition, but then pulled it off like a pro, because, well, she is a pro. This girl is not a stranger to performing. Once referred to as Canada's "next Alanis", she signed a recording contract with producer David Foster at the age of 15, and recorded a single for the movie soundtrack, "I Know What You Did Last Summer." Unfortunately, Jory's album was never released, and now, she's reportedly hoping to launch a comeback via American Idol.

Despite Jory's extensive professional experience, she is allowed to compete in the Idol competition because she doesn't currently have a recording contract. According to rumors, Jory has already advanced to the Top 24 in Hollywood. Of course, an Idol spokesperson refused to confirm this. And Jory is keeping things quiet, as well.

So is Jory the next American Idol? I know in the past when a contestant comes in too polished, it can turn fans off. I truly think the public likes to choose a nobody, perhaps a little rough around the edges image-wise (think Bucky or Elliot) that they can watch bloom before their very eyes.

The American public also likes an "underdog." And right now, Jory may be coming on too quickly as the "top dog." For this reason, I think a lot of us are going to have high expectations for Jory and we might hold her to higher standards than some of the others (like Jamie Lynn, the Southern girl who lives with grandma and takes care of her paralyzed daddy who shot himself and his wife when he caught her cheatin').

So what do you think? Will Jory's experience and professionalism take her to the top? Or is all of the hype going to burn her when it comes time for the audience to vote?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

28 Comments

Filter by:
Jan

Hey look people. I realize that Jory is from Canada and that she can sing but Jory has the right to be in that competition if she pleases. BTW...the show is American Idol not United States Idol so yes, Jory has the right to be in the competition. Canada is part of America (North). As for her looks..... well, everyone's good looking in God's eyes. :)

February 14 2007 at 10:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Maggi

Jory is a very talented singer.... BUT.....through the years, the competition for the best UNDISCOVERED talent in America has gotten a little too close to the line for me. That line being the one between professional singers and amateurs. Why do the producers allow someone in who, in the past, signed a contract and cut a CD with big time producer David Foster?

Personally, I would like to see the Pro's left out of the competition and give the opportunity to someone who hasn't already been signed or cut a commercial CD. I believe that the fact that it wasn't released was just one of those, "Breaks of the game."


February 02 2007 at 1:19 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
B. Chance

If I'm not mistaken (I'm not) many of these hopefuls have had some entertainment experience, and some have recording experience prior to competing, like Taylor Hicks. Anyone with a few bucks can make a CD these days and there are zillions of them. I don't think these folks who may be further along in their dreams should be excluded. Talent is talent.
As far as this contestent being Canadian, I'm sure the rules are crystal clear as to who is eligible and who is not.
The people who vote will expect more from this girl and one bad note will likely send her north. She deserves a chance to succeed or fail based on her vocal range and not on the chance she already had in the past, that obviously fizzled oot. Eh?

February 01 2007 at 2:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bobbi

I think if you look at the recent threads that Chris Sligh (the "Fro" guy) has quite a number of very good threads, too. He will also be one to watch.

February 01 2007 at 1:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
russ g

i'm pretty sure kelly clarkson had a recording contract once, before she won american idol

February 01 2007 at 1:38 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
denise

im also in agreement she has an unfair advantage over contestants who are off the street the whole purpose of idol is to give a chance for an everyday person to have a chance at the big time boot her

February 01 2007 at 12:49 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Pat

I think all that experience plus being Canadian will hurt her with the general public. Then again, Taylor and some other season 5 top contenders weren't exactly green newcomers.I think the addition of the semi-pros has added a lot to the competition in recent years. Guess we'll just have to wait and see.

February 01 2007 at 12:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
april

The girl to watch is Jordin Sparks.

February 01 2007 at 12:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Debbie

She signed with David Foster at 15 and didn't make it, what's wrong with that picture? Could be, she doesn't have it after all. I agree that this competition should be for the unknown trying to get discovered.

February 01 2007 at 11:53 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Debi

Sorry..we all now its the good ole USA IDOL....#1, number 2..she is not someone singing in a Club waiting to get discovered....she has already cut an album..just not released....this does sound like what the idea behind the whole idol competition is...and #3 sorry she may be able to sing but she's not that good lookin!!

February 01 2007 at 11:47 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners