Powered by i.TV
February 11, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Friday Night Lights: Black Eyes and Broken Hearts

by Brett Love, posted Feb 15th 2007 10:42AM
Kyle Chandler - Friday Night Lights(S01E16) After where we left off last week, it was pretty clear what direction we would be heading this week. Where we would end up, that was the mystery. The resolution to the "Blinders" cliff-hanger wasn't all that was on the agenda though. And as good as it was, it wasn't even my favorite part of the episode.

This week, that title goes to the Taylor family drama. While part of that plays off of the controversy surrounding the team, there were also a couple great scenes as a result of Eric and Tami's struggles with Julie. Her fall from grace has come about a little quickly, but I'm willing to chalk that up to the compressed time of the television season.

Even though the setup could have been smoother, the results made for a great payoff. I've said it before, but it bears repeating. Much more than a show about football, Friday Night Lights is a family drama, and a very good one. The fight over Julie's new friendship with Tyra early in the episode was well done. Connie Britton continues to amaze me as Tami. Eric's explanation about the one person that doesn't wear enough clothes, and the other one that used to be a pretty good kid kind of confused me while he was saying it, but I think that made it work. It had the feel of real dialog, not just another well constructed line.

The continuation of things at the police station just added to it. "All the other parents have picked up their perps. Why can't we pick up ours?" Tami is a tough customer. I also really liked the conversation between Eric and Counselor/Wife/Friend Tami. Eric was in a tough spot and it again showed just how important Tami is to what he does. Both "Anyone else I can talk to?" and "The three of you scare me." were also very good lines.

Meanwhile, back at the Coach McGill controversy, I liked how both sides played out. They did a nice job of showing just how important Smash is as a leader for the team. Saracen has certainly surpassed everyone's expectations where his play on the field is concerned. But he still leaves a lot to be desired as a leader. He just doesn't have the Smash swagger.

The scene with Waverly in the background pushing Smash down the road to revolution was interesting. Not only did it show Smash having second thoughts, but the look from Mrs. Williams told us just what she was thinking. Something we saw later when she finally put her foot down. I got the feeling that hit mother's ultimatum came as something of a relief to Smash. He got in over his head and swept up in the drama of the situation.

Coach McGill's end of it also provided some good stuff. The key scene, I thought, was when he visited Eric and told him about how he had grown up. That seemed to be the first time that he really acknowledged that he made a mistake, and showed remorse rather than anger. And I think that is what eventually led to Eric's decision to keep Mac on. "I know what's easy, but I know what's right." was another good line. It does seem now that Mac and Smash have come to an understanding and things are going to be ok on that front. I'll be curious to see if the whole issue gets dropped, or if they revisit it. A scene where Mac confronts Buddy about trying to get him fired would be good.

The Julie/Matt romance got what I would have called an expected sub-plot. The whole hot-tub, rally girl break up was destined to be short lived, so their reconciliation didn't come as any sort of surprise. It did provide some fun scenes though, including some of the best Landry bits of the series. From the way he threw Matt under the bus for the mixed CD, trying to impress Tyra, to his running conversation at the jewelery store. "Reach into those Alamo Freeze pockets....Three girls in a hot tub is diamond bad....Blood diamonds." And of course his reaction to the strip club, complete with his Crucifictorius t-shirt. "Her, a naked lady. No big deal." Landry is a fun character, and he added a nice comedic element to an otherwise pretty heavy episode. And we can't forget that final "Will you be my girlfriend?" moment with Matt and Julie. Very cute, and a nice touch for Valentine's Day.

The only thing that didn't really work for me was the brief Street update. It seemed almost shoe-horned into the episode and didn't really tell us anything we didn't already know. The whole thing could have just been passed off as a line from Lyla acknowledging that he had left for tryouts and that would have been fine. I'm still curious to see where that all ends up, but I would like it to get more time when they do it. Could it be that making the rugby team leads to Street calling off the lawsuit?

Finally, another win for the Panthers. Some pretty good football footage to go along with it too, and more than we have seen in an episode for quite some time. An interesting twist to how they won as well. Kyle Chandler was great in that post-game speech. It looks like they are going to be able to stretch the football season out to the end of the television season. It should make for quite the dramatic finish.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

11 Comments

Filter by:
Joe Hyde

This is the best writing I have seen for TV ever. It is so damned real and engaging and it teaches me about the human spirit.

Coach Taylor's decision on Mac was the correct one. He took into consideration that Mac was a big part of the team's success and had a history with great things ("Mac, you integrated this team.") At the end of the day, the kids will be gone off to college or elsewhere, but Mac will still be there. And the integrity of the team relies more on the ability of the coaching staff than the kids playing. Had Taylor destroyed Mac's career over a mistake, he'd have issues with other coaches on his staff and it would hurt the program in the long run.

Smash's mom is right on. I love that lady.

www.swtexaslive.com

February 18 2007 at 4:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Crambam

Actually, I thought Coach Taylor handled the Mac situation as best as he could. Mac screwed up. It was very clear that Mac has been around this team for decades, and not only that, was instrumental in INTEGRATING the team. The show was clear that the guy just put his foot in his mouth and said something stupid.

It was a good example of how our society and the press tends to be too damn sensitive and politically correct, to the point that they swooped on this man like vultures.

Mac made a dumb mistake, but the problem was that he compounded it by refusing to admit he made a mistake. I think had Mac been TRULY remorseful and addressed the situation better, the whole thing with Smash and the other black players wouldn't have had to happen.

Smash didn't handle the situation right either. That walkoff was not the way to handle it. You have to look at the big picture. The smartest person was Smash's mom. I like that character. Not every fight needs to be fought so overtly. Black people aren't leaders on the field? Smash proved that wrong by BEING a leader on the field.

He even turned the other cheek when he took that late hit, which is leading by example. Not that I was against Riggins stepping up, because that also was appropriate given the situation.

But getting back to the original point, Mac was NOT a bad person. Not all screw ups deserve a public lynching. He SHOULDN'T have been fired. And Coach Taylor decided to take the harder road, because it was the right road. That's a level of integrity that you don't always find.

Geez I'm mad this show is going to get canceled.

February 16 2007 at 1:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chu

Please don't cancel this show, NBC. Some of the best written tv out there.

February 16 2007 at 8:42 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
BillS

Totally agree with #1. I loved this episode. They could've made Mac out to be a Klansman, they could've had him break down and apologize teary-eyed and Smash hugs him and all is forgiven, they could've had Coach fire Mac and the team is reunited and has a dramatic win over their opponents and everyone is happy.

But they make everyone sympathetic and real.

http://popculturejunk.blogspot.com

February 16 2007 at 3:40 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
D Colin

I love this show, and thought this was a great episode. The scene of Couch Taylor and his wife Tami in the office was great, and then them dealing with Julie. I'm glad Julie is standing up for herself with her mom about Tyra.

What bothered me and made me lose some respect for Coach Taylor was how he handled this whole situation with Mac. I didn't feel he was there for his team. He seemed way too concerned about one man-- who may of made a mistake or showed his true self. But Mac got compassion from Eric, where as Smash and the 13 others never got a word of support. These guys didn't do anything wrong and their coach just replaced them. That bothered me. He never reached out to his players. And by him supporting Mac, as Tami said it does make him seem like he shares his view. I realize that Eric was put in a tough postion, but I wish he had stood up for Smash and the others more.
And Mac at the end doesn't clean the slate for me. Oh and after the game was called and Coach Taylor told the team he was diappointed in them and that they needed to take responsiblity. Well where was this thought towards Mac from the coach. Yes he had him say I'm sorry (last episode), but that was half assed.

Okay enough from me-- just my thoughts. Love this show so much, and hopes it continues on past this season. Oh and love Landry needing singles, he always makes me smile.

and really what is up with so many shows show the last couple minutes in their previews. Gilmore Girl's has down it for over a season and FNL did it with the Matt and Julie moment

February 15 2007 at 2:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Crambam

The more I watch this show, the more I get mad that it's going to be canceled. I say that every week. I'm not so much a fan of the racism subplot, since it's been done to death on other shows, but the bottom line is that they did it well, and I completely agree that the true plot that ruled was the Taylor family drama. None of these characters are perfect, but that's great.

And I liked that Riggins was the one who defended his teammate. The cops pulling over the team bus was downright stupid though. That could never happen, especially since the whole thing would be on video and Smash was the victim of the late hit, which was also a criminal assault (assuming the Riggins brawl was criminal assault).

The bottom line is the team unity that should come from that brawl. They would be closer than ever.

February 15 2007 at 1:30 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
innamorata

I don't think I could care less about Matt and Julie if I were paid billions to. They just bore me.

However I love the Eric/Tami relationship (and Tim/Lyla but that's nowhere here or there right now *sniff*).

As usual my favorite bits were with Riggins. From his yelling to the kids, to his "educating" them I couldn't help but laugh.
I also loved his conversation with Smash and I regret that the deleted scene showing that the idea to talk to Smash about "his boys" last week actually came from his father as it paralleled well with McGill's story imo.
Even though violence on any sports field drives me nuts (*cough*Zidane*cough*) , I couldn't help but be glad that Tim went against the guy who was pushing for Smash to lose his focus by tackling him and insulting him. Totally wrong but damn me if I didn't cheer.

Question though, since when is Tim the team's captain?

February 15 2007 at 1:22 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
michael75204

What struck me was the music used for the scene where Smash leads the walk-offs onto the bus to go to the game. That ostinato "head-banging" chord repeatedly clashing over a practically silent scene, then ending with that gentle guitar strum as Smash's grim face is highlighted in the middle of the bus. Fadeout. Outstanding. A lot of the editing on FNL is really enjoyable.

February 15 2007 at 12:30 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
khamel

you forgot to mention the street justice that mac stopped at the end of the episode. did smash even throw a punch? from what i remember, riggins took the racist guy down on his own. i liked how the whole race thing worked out, it wasn't like an 80's sitcom but it wasn't too intense. these ARE kids after all. Smash is an unlikely leader of a race protest and i'm glad his mom let him know what he was actually doing. I don't think his girlfriend knows how important football really is to his future. Maybe SHE's a bad influence too (i actually dont think Tyra is a bad influence, i just think she has a complicated life and bad luck).

February 15 2007 at 12:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Goody

This is a great show with terrific acting and writing. Please watch people!!!

February 15 2007 at 11:45 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners