Idol producer responds to Antonella's naughty photos

First off, I thought Frenchy could sing and would vote her over Antonella anytime. But bottom line is that Frenchy's pictures were for profit on a website before AI and Antonella's came out after AI and not for profit. It was probably better for Frenchy anyway cause then she wasn't trapped under the contract of AI and she could move on like others that were voted off like Chris Daughtry. So, let's stop crying over spilt milk. Neither one was going to win so does it really matter when they left?
Just my opinion

I think that she sholud be voted OFF, just because of the pics,either way u look at it they are still wrong, it does not matter who she posed for , they are still out here for the public to see. She need to ask herself HOW did they get out? She need to check her boy-friend. Now fair is fair she needs to go. I would not want My daughter to look up to her as a Idol in taking off her clothes. What else wolud she be wiling to do ? If you think like a freak soon or later you will become one.
Frenchie Davis has talent and that was what she should have been judge on. The little white girl will be booted anyway because she can't sing, she is ok but she's not an Idol.
And I am White, just in case people wants to know

Well, actually I think she looks pretty cute on that toilet. I sure could never look that good sitting on the potty...I wish I did! You Go Girl! No, seriously tho' her pics are not that bad, she is very photogenic. Besides, it's a singing contest, not Miss America. I do not agree, she cannot be compared to Frenchie who got booted off for being on an Internet porn site, that woman was paid for it. These are not professional photos of Antonella, not do they imply that she posed for money. But they do show that she is very photogenic. Maybe she won't win idol, she does have much better competitors for singing. But, my guess is she will go into modeling or acting. She definitely has talent. Let's face it kids, this isn't a church talent show, it's a singing competition. She just got free publicity, and it's very good publicity that will send her career into outer space.

Proof, from AMERICAN IDOL, that the pictures are Fake. -
http://photobucket.com/mediadetail/?media=http%3A%2F%2Fi165.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fu74%2Ftheamericanidolcsi%2Faicsi.jpg&searchTerm=antonella%20barba

Lots of Antonella's pics at http://www.barba.in

i think she should have been voted off shes not good at all. Shes not all that either there are plenty of jersey girls who look better then she does. why all the fuss over this girl amazes me. I think this is just what she wanted all along too bad she cannot get the attention by keeping your clothes on. that says something to me. think about it

IF, She hadn't taken the pictures:
there would be nothing to talk about
there would be nothing for the snitch to tell
the media would have none of this to report and keep going.
She for sure wouldn't be getting all of the press she's getting.
But then all of this stuff helps. Madonna, Cher and Vanasa Williams are prime examples of what can happen.

I don't think it's the fact of her having the sexual photos but the issue lies in the fact of the history of American Idol kicking Frenchie Davis off the show in the past. Now, if you get rid of one person for something and another person does something like that then the same rules should apply.

However, Antonella photos did appear to have been done in privacy and not for the public. So that does somewhat matter unless someone else knows something I don't know.

The pictures had nothing to do with if Antonella
went home or not. The girl cant sing at all to save her life. She should have been voted off this week but im sure next week after she sings she will be voted off. There are way to many good singers on there and she isnt one of them at all.

I believe according to past practice on American Idol when the gave Frenchie Davis the boot they should do the same thing with Antonella