Powered by i.TV
February 11, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Gilmore Girls: Gilmore Girls Only

by Joel Keller, posted Mar 6th 2007 10:34PM
Gilmore Girls: Gilmore Girls Only(S07E17) When Dawn Ostroff, the CW's president of entertainment, was doing her "state of the network" press tour session in January, she said this about Gilmore Girls: "(David Rosenthal) was painted into a corner into with a storyline that he got out of. The second half of the season is much stronger, and I think viewers will be surprised."

I scoffed a little when she said that; nothing about the season to that point had suggested that the show was going to improve. But I've got to hand it to Rosenthal and company; the show has been on an upward trend, giving us about a month's worth of entertaining episodes that, while not quite up to the level of the show's creative peak, certainly give me hope that the show won't go out with a whimper, whether it's this season or next.

The key? Keep the Gilmore girls together. All three of them.

The key to the show's chemistry has always been the interaction between Lorelai, Rory, and Emily, and since Richard's heart attack, we've been seeing more of that lately (don't ya just love how great a plot device open heart surgery is?). The almost-musical interplay between Lor and Rory, the admiration and love Emily and Rory have for each other, and the chilly-but-somehow-loving interaction between Emily and Lorelai have all carried the emotional load for the entire series; no matter what silliness is going on in Lorelai's or Rory's love lives, the most emotionally satisfying scenes have always explored how the Girls relate to each other.

And this episode brought all that out. Lorelai is finally realizing that Rory is leaving the nest for good; we saw that in the cold open when she tried to get her daughter to come to the wedding of Mia (Kathy Baker, who I haven't seen on TV in a while), who took Lorelai in when she was pregnant and put her to work at the Independence Inn, while Rory was trying on interview suits. Emily came face to face with the mistake she made when she and Richard shut out Lor all those years ago; we saw that when she inadvertently got herself invited to the wedding, even though she wanted to go to a spa instead. And, Lor realized that, no matter what happened in the past, she needs to stay connected to her mother, even when the person that previously connected them, Rory, goes to work for the San Francisco Chronicle or the Detroit Free-Press or what have you.

(By the way, why is Rory only considering certain papers? There are fine journalists working at tabloids like the Boston Herald, New York Post, and the New York Daily News, among others. Some of them actually used to work for papers like the Times and the Boston Globe. I don't care if she's going to Yale. She shouldn't be so damned picky.)

Kelly Bishop was again in fine form; she's one of the few actresses who can make you angry and sympathetic all at the same time. When Emily talks down to a waitress at a Denny's-like restaurant -- "Chardonnay. That's the clear one." -- you want to tell her to stuff it. But when she's confronted by how Mia was "almost like a mother" to Lorelai, you can sympathize with how hurt she's feeling at that moment. She's also one of the few actresses who can take two words, "Lucky you," and make the viewer just sit there and go "Oooohhh. That hurt."

There were some distractions: The Rory/Logan relationship came to a bit of a head, as Rory agreed with Mitchum that Logan needs to face up to his screw-up and accept responsibility rather than booze it up with Colin and Finn. In fact, the relationship took a nice turn when Logan came down to Mia's wedding in North Carolina to talk to Rory. Wimpy Rory's heart would have melted at the gesture. But the suddenly Tough Rory just scoffed and said "This is so last year's Logan." Nice. I think that was a call-out to the fans who were also sick of the grand gestures. But I was very surprised that Logan not only owned up to his mistake, he decided to quit his dad's company. Snipping the cord like that took balls. How is Logan going to deal with not being rich anymore? How will Rory deal with it? I'd be curious to see if it stays strong or falls apart quickly.

The Zack daddy freak-out was fun, if kind of by the books, plot-wise. What young father-to-be doesn't freak out right before his wife gives birth? I mean, hearing Zack "dude" it up during the freak out gave it a unique spin, but it wasn't any different than your standard father-to-be panic scenes. Of course, the story only illustrated how ready Luke is to be with Lorelai. He calmed Zack down and told him about finding his "daddy mode," relating to his experience with April. Oh, he's ready all right. Though, I really wonder why he had such a bothered reaction when Zack and Lane asked him to be the twins' godfather (so they're not against using the term "Godmother" or "Godfather." This puts extra significance behind Lane's wish that Rory be her twins' "Lorelai Gilmore"). Oh, and Lane had the twins. Amazing that they didn't make a big deal out of it. Refreshing, though.

Anyway, it seems like Gilmore Girls is on a roll of some pretty decent episodes. We even found out that Emily had a "thing" for Will Smith (great final scene, by the way. It encapsulates the Girls' relationships in a nutshell). We've got five episodes left. Let's see where they go from here.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

26 Comments

Filter by:
DelBocaVista

I noticed also that the part of Mia was played by a different actress this time. I wonder why it was Kathy Bates this time? I only watched this episode recently from my DVR. I do hope that this show goes for at least another short season so things can play out without cramming everything into a few episodes. I think loyal fans (of which I am one) deserve it!

April 20 2007 at 8:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bluekidcory

I know it's been a while since this episode aired and most people will stop reading now but I was amazed that no one else noticed this. It wasn't the same actress that played Mia!
Am I the only one that was upset with this? The portrayal of her character was far different than it had been back in the first season as well.
TOODLES

March 27 2007 at 12:14 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Manda

I just felt the need to add this: Depending on how you look at it: Lorelai was not preganat when she left Richard and Emily for real, she had a newborn. Unless you say she left them when she went to the hospital.

I agree, refreshing that they didn't drama-up Lane's labor/delivery...we didn't need that. Great cliff-hanger too...I want to see those half Korean half Rocker babies!

March 07 2007 at 10:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lorilei13

(Gasp)!!! Scott Cohen? Really? I am soooooo on board. I heart him.

March 07 2007 at 9:08 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lorilei13

I agree that the second half of the season is way better than the first half; for the first time in months, I find myself looking forward to the next episode. I really hope it gets renewed for one more season. It doesn't need to hang around any longer than that, I don't think, but that would give them a chance to end it in a way that would do it justice. I'm afraid it's going to feel rushed and unresolved otherwise.

March 07 2007 at 5:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tracy

At the beginning of the episode when Lorelai was trying to convince Rory to go to the weding she said that Mia had taken her in, a 17 year old with a baby in her arms in the middle of the night. Also, there was a flashback episode where Richard and Emily came home from an evening out and Emily was happy that Lorelai had moved the baby stroller that had been cluttering the foyer. It turned out that was the night that Lorelai and Rory moved out/on.

March 07 2007 at 1:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
floretbroccoli

Wasn't it stated explicity in an earlier episode that Logan sunk his trust fund in this failed venture?

March 07 2007 at 12:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Violeta

Lorelai had already had Rory when she left her parents' house. She did sneak out to deliver Rory but her parents found her and presumably brought her and the baby back home. It was all in the flashback episode, but Lorelai has definitely already had Rory when she came to Mia's, as it was mentioned in another episode, the first one where we met Mia.

March 07 2007 at 12:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
margot

Lorelai was most definitely pregnant when she left Emily and Richards back in the 80's. Remember Rory's coming out episode? They flashed back to Lorelai's and her dress didn't fit b/c she was pregnant.

March 07 2007 at 11:46 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

justelise I agree with you, but that ship has already sailed.

I thought Logan would be rebound guy after the affair with Dean, sadly that wasn't the case. If the writers knew what they were doing the last few seasons Rory would have dumped Logan and went to Marty the naked guy.

March 07 2007 at 11:45 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners