Idol responds to Rosie's accusations of racism and weightism

by Liz Finn-Arnold, posted Mar 8th 2007 11:42AM
Rosie O'DonnellRosie O'Donnell weighed in on the Frenchie/Antonella controversy this week on The View. Like other critics, Rosie accused Idol of being "racist" and "weightist" in their decision to disqualify Frenchie for racy photos, while basically ignoring Antonella's sexy pics.

In a written statement, Idol Excutive Producer Nigel Lythgoe called Rosie's claims of racism and weightism "absurd and ridiculous."

Lythgoe also said, "Ms. O'Donnell has, once again, spoken without thought or knowledge. Viewers need only look at the show tonight to realize that American Idol constantly confirms to America that talent has nothing to do with weight or color."

Since joining The View, Rosie has started quite a few celebrity feuds, and this is not the first time she's attacked American Idol. In January, outraged by the judges' cruelty, she accused Paula Abdul of being drunk on the air.

FOX is apparently so fed up with Rosie's bashing they will no longer allow her to play Idol video clips on The View. Barbara Walters told Rosie, "You don't insult them with your left hand and ask for favors with your right." Joy Behar suggested putting a disclaimer on the TV screen warning, "Rosie's views are Rosie's."

How many more public feuds does Rosie have to start before Barbara Walters finally muzzles her? I guess as long as ratings continue to rise at The View, Rosie is safe to say whatever she wants.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

21 Comments

Filter by:
BobbyBuz

I guess it pays "to suck"

Antonella Barba offered $500,000 adult DVD site 'spokesperson' deal

By Christopher Rocchio, 03/08/2007

Should Antonella Barba's American Idol journey come to an end, the 20-year-old Point Pleasant, NJ native apparently won't have to look too hard for work.

SugarDVD -- the largest renter of adult DVDs online -- has offered Barba $500,000 to become their new "spokesperson," TMZ.com reported on Thursday. SugarDVD's CEO "Jax" said if Barba were to accept the offer, her first gig would be hosting a launch party for their new video-on-demand service.

"You saw her photos online, she's smokin'," Jax told TMZ.com.

Barba is currently one of the Top 16 semifinalists competing on the sixth season of Fox' American Idol. Despite the emergence of numerous provocative photos of her on the Internet in recent weeks, Idol producer Nigel Lythgoe has said the show decided not to disqualify her from the reality competition series. She's also received support from the Idol's host and judges.

The offer from SugarDVD comes on the heels of Wednesday's report that "Girls Gone Wild" founder and CEO Joe Francis offered Barba $250,000 to become a host for the video company, which found its niche by catching college-age women baring their breasts on film.

Needless to say, Jax welcomed a bidding war for Barba's services, telling TMZ.com, "We will not lose because of money."

March 09 2007 at 11:33 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
phantomprophet

My TT, that almost sounded sexist.
You might want to watch that.
Saying that men cannot have a valid thought because they have a penis is a very bigoted statement.
And I believe you were trying to speak out against bigoted statements.
Ironic.

March 09 2007 at 10:01 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
TT

Since most of you who are responding are MEN, I will say that, as usual, you are all thinking with your DICKS about Antonella Barba!
If the women (her & Frenchie) and their situations were switched, everyone would be pissed that Antonella was allowed to stay in. You are not ABLE to be objective because of "Junior" in your pants! How hypocritical!
Whether Frenchie made any $ is not the point! American Idol's image is supposed to be that of someone who is marketable, who will be liked by people, so they will buy the music. Just as others have been bounced in previous seasons for arrests & questionable pasts, these contestants should be held to the same standards.
If Rosie is so wrong, THEN WHY HASN'T FOX GIVEN A REASON FOR ITS DOUBLE STANDARDS??! It's taking advantage of Rosie's remarks to side step the issue of why they did nothing to this cute, THIN white girl yet they booted the fat black chick. Rosie is merely commenting like other talk show hosts do!
You all need to get past the fact that despite narrow-minded thinking such as yours, an overweight gay comedienne beat the odds and hosts a daily TV show...where she is PAID for her VIEW!! The only difference between her and you is that you all make your comments on the internet and she does it on live TV!!!!!!!!!

March 09 2007 at 1:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Emily

#7 - Do you have any idea what ratings are? AI is a juggernaut and owns its timeframe.

#2 - With a callsign like Dr. Funbags, the man (I am so hoping you are a man) must know his stuff.

re: Rosie - speaking as a peri-menapausal woman myself, perhaps "the change" is upon her and she has just lost her mind. I used to find her amusing, but now just the sound of her whiny voice annoys me.

March 08 2007 at 3:22 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Creep

She will say anything for people to pay attention to her. How pathetic.

March 08 2007 at 2:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Charles

#7... The Weakest Link lasted one season in America. American Idol is on it's SIXTH season, with still-phenomonal numbers, rivaled only by the Superbowl.

I think American's can handle at least Simon. :)

March 08 2007 at 1:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

Elizibeth is the biggest bitch on the show, she is just so god damn dumb.

Rosie is a dumbass too, I'm a "weightist" because i think she needs to shut your fucknig fat ass mouth.

We have had two black winners, and the top people this year are black. This is almost as insane as when Elton John called Americans racist a season or two ago.

And who haven't thought Paula Abdul is drunk on TV?

March 08 2007 at 1:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bobby

PLEASE SOME SHUT ROSIE UP . I MEAN HELL SHE WAS NEVER THIS VILE ON HER OWN SHOW . HELL IN FACT SHE WAS FUNNY . THANK GOOD WE HAVE ELLEN WHO SHOWS WHAT FUNNY IS AND A REAL GAY PERSON IS . ROSIE IS A POOR EXAMPLE FOR ALL HUMANS . I USED TO LIKE ROSIE BIT NOW I CANT STAND HER AT ALL. FIRST THE DONALD , THEN THE DAUGHTER , HER CO-STARS , NOW AMERICAN IDOL. WELL SHE HAS TO GET RATINGS SOME HOW BECAUSE SHE ISNT THAT GRAND ANYMORE . IN FACT I THINK SHE IS A FLAT OUT BITCH. SHAME ON YOU ROSIE.

March 08 2007 at 1:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bobby

PLEASE SOME SHUT ROSIE UP . I MEAN HELL SHE WAS NEVER THIS VILE ON HER OWN SHOW . HELL IN FACT SHE WAS FUNNY . THANK GOOD WE HAVE ELLEN WHO SHOWS WHAT FUNNY IS AND A REAL GAY PERSON IS . ROSIE IS A POOR EXAMPLE FOR ALL HUMANS . I USED TO LIKE ROSIE BIT NOW I CANT STAND HER AT ALL. FIRST THE DONALD , THEN THE DAUGHTER , HER CO-STARS , NOW AMERICAN IDOL. WELL SHE HAS TO GET RATINGS SOME HOW BECAUSE SHE ISNT THAT GRAND ANYMORE . IN FACT I THINK SHE IS A FLAT OUT BITCH. SHAME ON YOU ROSIE.

March 08 2007 at 1:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Duane

Rosie's an idiot, plain and simple. She tripped over a method for generating buzz (albeit all bad) and now she's just a one trick pony scanning the newspapers to find something offensive to say next.

Racist and weightist? Lakisha ain't no skinny white girl, Rosie.

March 08 2007 at 1:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners