My two cents about the length of the article:

I don't have showtime, but was curious about this series. I'm glad that he went into as much tasteful detail as he could. Everyone watches Prison Break and BSG after all, so there's not as much need to recap, I think.

Keep up the good work!

Wow, I was hoping to read some comments on the show, which I did not get a chance to watch.

One thing the internet has an endless supply of is smart-assed children with little or no grasp of the English language.

If you want your points to be taken seriously you should pay attention in school so you can get this elusive thing known as an "education". Whilst there you will have the opportunity to learn how to properly spell words the average third-grader should know, and as a bonus you might even acquire the rudimentary skills needed to capitalize and punctuate your sentences better than a drunken orangutan.

In your present state, you just come across as the ignorant and cocky child you are. Unless you can present your arguments in a more coherent manner, you'll never be regarded as more than a nuisance, much like a mosquito.

omg, i gotta say that your guy's justifications for bitching is sooooooooooooooooooo weak...
you must remember bitching and constructive critisism are not the same thing...
heres some contructive critisism (in your style):
i love this site and would love to see you shut up, cause it seems like this site was great until your guys bitching started, now i dont read this site as much..

since the owner of this site hasnt accommodated my every whim and the site isnt being designed to my exacting desires, i will go hang myself with a bungie cord...never to return to this site that has thrown me into such a state of dispair and anguish... woah is me!!!!

Tucker,

Great post and very well put.

Yeah, we've had some disagreements, but I like to think we can "go at it" over what we disagree on in one post and turn right around and have a genial discussion about something we agree on. For myself, a lot of being able to do that comes from being, and staying, married. It's something I've noticed in your posts and a few others which to me indicates how many revolutions around the sun you've likely seen.

To be totally honest, I don't think I've ever encountered someone who I didn't eventually argue with, at least after a certain age when "curmudgeonliness" set in. (Dear God, I hope that's a real word!) Sometimes I feel I must be the oldest person on the damned internet. Tucker is one of those people who can argue with me over something and know it's not personal and only about whatever we happen to disagree on.

Getting on track, the point we're making (and Tucker's done it so well above I probably shouldn't even bother, but I never shut up) is that we love this site and our complaints are because we're seeing something we love change in a way we don't like. I made specific mention of layout, but that's really superficial to the content and direction. I'm nearing the point where I just don't much care about, or for, TVSquad any more. If I left I know it would probably make a lot of people very happy, but I seriously don't want to go away.

Chalk it up to being married for longer than most of the commenters here have probably been breathing, but I tend to stick around through bad times. Usually things work out even if it's not always exactly the way I want them to. Even so, we all have our breaking point and I'm not relishing finding what mine is, so I hope I don't have to.

Now that I've made my pointless ramblings for the moment, I'll head back to my wild Saturday night of cooking 6 gallons of homemade salsa and drinking a wee bit of my latest bottle of single-malt scotch whiskey. Here's looking forward to many more arguments, and agreements, with you Tucker! :o)

Fair enough, matybe I dont have enough perspective. I found this place several weeks ago after years of following Engadget and Joystiq.

I guess my point is just that the constant complaining - about absolutely everything - makes several posters look like self absorbed, demading whiners. It seems they can do no right and I get tired of all the bitching. Its like the constant shouts of "bias" and "this is so old" over at Joystiq. I just chalk it up to them being immature assholes, and try to ignore them.

It's not about "starting our own" or slipping quietly into the night. It's about pleading with people who some of us have grown to respect over the course of several YEARS and watching a site that we go to multiple times a day to stop the downward spiral that's occurred recently.

Go back through some of the old posts. You'll find that I've historically been one of the biggest TVS apologists out there. I used to look forward to visiting all the time to read insightful, witty, whatever posts. It's simply not that way around here anymore - I come hoping that it's the same old site (and occasionally it is, but as with all criticism, you're not going to find people lighting fireworks and jumping up and down when you do something right, unfortunately), but more often find myself shaking my head.

I'm not just some ass who came out of the woodwork a couple months ago who has nothing better to do than sit around and rag on a blog. I'm an extremely longtime and loyal fan who's looking to support a site that I have always enjoyed. I don't like to see it in this state, and if this is an overall indication of the "new direction," then I think a lot of us would like to know. Maybe it attracts new readers, but sadly I think it'll ultimately lose some of the old farts like me and erroneous nick (who, I might add, I've had some heated arguments with in the past, so it's not like this is some hand-holding Kumbaya-singing group of haters - we're just a couple of like-minded old-school TVS fans).

Hold on! Whats that sound?

Its the Waaaaaaaaambulance.

Really guys. If web development and TV show reviews are so easy, then go start your own. Im sure you're so good at it youll pull all the traffic from TV Squad within weeks, making zillions in ad revenue.

Keep it up TV squad. Theres plenty to like here.

don't listen to those fools, keep doing what you're doing.

the site is great.

Gee Patrick and NDUO, this site is designed, albeit poorly, for comments. It's fine that you disagree. Lord knows I have plenty of disagreements here, but the "you don't have to read it" or "go away" comments could just as easily be turned toward yourselves.

If you don't like the comments we've made, you don't have to read them and you could easily go away. See how easy that was to just turn around back at you? It works both ways.

I'm sure there are plenty of readers/commenters who are no longer reading articles here and are quietly going away. Those of us who complain are still here hoping the site will improve rather than simply giving up on it. While you look at the complaints as completely negative, we actually hold out hope for improvement instead of just moving on.

Keith hasn't commented on it recently, but he did allude to an overhaul for the site layout a while back, but nothing more has been said or done in that regard. That doesn't speak to the quality of the content, but at least a new layout might make reading and commenting more pleasurable and nobody likes bitching in a comfortable enviroment than myself.

Really, given time your wishes may just come true. Even those of us sticking around to complain and sometimes even offer marginally constructive criticism in the ever-fading hope that the overall quality of this site will improve have our breaking points.