Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Grey's Anatomy: Scars and Souvenirs

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Mar 16th 2007 7:59AM

T.R. KNIGHT and SHOHREH AGHDASHLOO

(S03E18) Greetings and a myriad of salutations to all. I'll be covering Grey's Anatomy from here on out as Joel was recently pushed into a large body of water by a careless, mute child. He's currently residing in some sort of "not quite dead yet" limbo and from what I've been told, the internet access sucks. So you've got me in the meantime and after what we saw last night, it looks like Grey's is back on track following the conclusion of the "Meredith can't swim" story.

It was a very good episode I thought, but as with any Grey's installment, there were plenty of pros, plenty of cons, and plenty of things that just made no sense whatsoever to me. First off, and no exact time frame was mentioned, but does anyone else think that Meredith came back to work too early? We know she at least had time to have her mother's body cremated, but it felt like it had only been a few weeks since the ferry incident. If I were in her shoes, I'd be milking this for all it's worth. Sick days. Personal Days. I Almost Died Days. I'd take 'em all.

So the big three things the episode offered up was essentially the deterioration of all the relationships in the show - from three angles. We saw George and Callie reaching a tipping point. She's loaded apparently. "An heiress" as George called her. The family has quite the bank account and Callie just gets $2,500 a week for... whatever. That must be nice. It seems what most people (including Izzie) have predicted is playing out - they rushed into the marriage too fast. Of course the big bombshell was Callie's revelation to George regarding Izzie: she hates me because she wants you. Internet buzz travels fast and I believe people are already calling it "Gizzie."

Well it happened at the end of the episode. Izzie needed a release after her heart-to-heart with "bullet in my shoulder" man. George needed to feel good about himself. So they got drunk and had sex. As far as crazy episode endings go, this one wasn't all that surprising to me. We saw them getting drunk and you sort of knew what it was leading up to. It would have been smarter to just show George coming over with the booze, skip the getting drunk scene, then jump right to the empty bottle and the two of them in bed. It would have been a little more shocking I think. Anyone else notice the bottle of whiskey George had? It was a bottle of Knob Creek, but rather than endorse the brand, the art department got a little creative and gave it a fake label with a fake name: Door River. Hilarious.

Elsewhere, as the battle for Weber's approval grew, all the attendings got a little crazy. I like the addition of Roger Rees as Dr. Colin Marlowe, but I feel like he's playing the same character that he played on The West Wing (Lord John Marbury). Just a cocky, know-it-all Brit. Being an attractive male on Grey's Anatomy allows you the earning of a nickname though and while Marlowe's doesn't start with "Mc," he'll have to settle for The Cardio God.

As far as finding out that Cristina dated him for three years while she was his student? It's believable, but I'm not sure it's the act itself that matters. They could have done anything. It is, however, the first real roadblock faced by Yang and Burke. She likes fooling around, leeching off men with authority and knowledge. That and she hates marriage. I'm happy with this storyline though. There needed to be some tension between those two and this is the conduit for that to happen. The fact that Marlowe is a bit of an icon to Burke does makes it more compelling too.

Other things that caught my eye:

  • The guest stint from Shohreh Aghdashloo as one of Derek's old colleagues from New York. I think we were supposed to really feel bad for Helen and what she was going through (brain tumor), but it didn't come across. She was just like any patient and the fact that her and Shepard shared a bond was lost in the fold I think.
  • When the power went out during dinner at Meredith's. This was something little, but I liked it a lot. Derek and Thatcher were both in the laundry room and Thatcher had just flipped the circuit-breaker, turning the lights back on. Derek's beeper went off and Thatcher sort sarcastically said, "Gotta go back in?" You have to wonder, even though beepers weren't around yet, how many times must he have stood in that room with Ellis, heard the phone ring, and said those same words?

So as I said earlier, I was very satisfied with this episode. There were a few things I was hoping for. I don't think we'll be seeing any more Alex/Addison sparks with the spin-off on the horizon. But I did like his progression with Jane Doe. It's just going to be interesting to see what becomes the big story for the end of the season. Because right now, it's feeling strangely similar to the end of the last one and they can't have everyone just get in a fight or whatever and break up again. I don't want to go into the hiatus wondering who Meredith will choose or will Izzie be able to find herself again. It's a medical drama. ER and St. Elsewhere both balanced all the pieces when they needed to -- give me something serious with heart and I'll be happy.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

17 Comments

Filter by:
Brent McKee

I guess I's the only one who not only thought that George and Izzy was inevitable but that it wouldn't be such a bad thing. I did love Izzy's facial reaction in the morning (somewhat better than Meredith's reaction to waking up with George) which was essentially, "Am I naked? Oh God, I hope I'm not naked. I'm naked!" Now is anyone taking bets on whether Izzy is on the pill?

March 18 2007 at 5:46 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kendall

The show has gotten to be terrible. If they slept together(which I'm not going to watch next week to find out if they did) it was all WAY to obvious. The problem is the characters are so horribly written now, the few characters that are actually written well get the least screen time(bailey and the chief, also Addison), and then you're left choking down all the horrible dialog,
He's my person? Your person? Yeah my person.
It stops being cute when it replaces actual dialog and character development. Also, they should have killed Meredith. Title be damned. This show has jumped past sharks and has moved up to jumping grey whales. "ER" balances between personal relationships and those people actually being doctors. Something Grey's has stopped doing. I'm not sure who annoys me more, Blondie mcwhines a lot, or blondie mcwidow/whines almost as much.

March 17 2007 at 9:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Nurse Ratchet

Hmmmmm...teaching hospital+horny interns= inappropriate sex. I am not surprised....

I work at a small teaching hospital and everyone is either hooking up with each other, coming out of the closet, or trying to hook up with anything that has genitalia.

Hehehehehehe...Gizzie is gross, and I do hope they didn't actually do "it", but I find it totally believable!

Great Episode!

March 17 2007 at 6:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
slutty_whore

It seems as if since TR Knight has come out of the closet, they are trying to shove down our throats the idea that George is some sort of a stud. Whatever! Come on! This is BS. And so is the show.

March 16 2007 at 9:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
chrisb

Dr. Marlowe=McWrinkly

March 16 2007 at 9:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bebop

They've all slept with each other now. (if you go by a sort of six degrees of separation thing).

I'm think the writers pretty much suck at this point since the only means they use as a catalyst for changing relationships is sex, that's it....very weak.

March 16 2007 at 2:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Courtney

Heather no kidding, that's what I thought too, every friendship on this show they end up sleeping together. Apprantly no one at Seattle Grace can keep their pants on. I miss season 1 and 2, so far I have been waiting for season 3 to pick up and it has not.

March 16 2007 at 2:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
JW

This was a great episode! But I would say that anyways because I have missed so many episodes; or there was re-runs. I wonder if Dr. Marlowe will be the new Chief? It looks like George and Cristina are having relationship issues...I hope George and his wife get back together (she is hot!) And it's pretty funny that Cristina "sleeps her way to the top." I like how they have given Alex a softer side...He's always trying to get in some girl's pants, but he seems to really care for Jane Doe; it surprises me he has a softer side. I will have to record next weeks...darn.

March 16 2007 at 1:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Barney Girl

Completely wrong to have George and Izzie have sex. The great part of their relationship is (was) that they were friends, not lovers. Friends is the stronger of the bond. Shame on the writers for letting a great relationship go bad!

March 16 2007 at 1:48 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Patti

In regards to the amount of alcohol ingested, do you really think they had sex at all? They could have just started the whole thing, then promptly passed out. Izzie woke up with nothing on, wondering what happened, assuming they 'did it'. I'm sure in the weeks to come we will find out for sure. Also, men don't tend to perform too well while under the influence.

March 16 2007 at 1:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners