Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

Grey's Anatomy: My Favorite Mistake

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Mar 22nd 2007 11:54PM

T.R. Knight and Katherine Heigl

(S03E19) Ehh... not so much. This wasn't exactly the follow-up I was expecting after last week's Close Encounters of The Gizzie. It just felt off. Like that scene in the supply closet? I found myself asking, "Really... those two?" Last week I thought it was great. Not a huge surprise, but it was something fun. Now I feel like I was in bed with them because it's the morning after and I'm being all weird about it too.

You know how Curb Your Enthusiasm has that ability to make you feel really uncomfortable as a viewer? That's essentially what every scene with George and Izzie in this episode felt like. Something out of Curb. The horrible thing about this is that we better get used to it because I don't think it's going away. It's obvious they want each other (at least from Izzie it is) and it's just going to have to wait until George is willing to break Calleigh's heart. Season finale anyone? I'd be happy if this all went away and Izzie just went back to Alex now that his flirtations with Addison have stopped.

Elsewhere, the race for chief was still moving forward and all the attendings were being interviewed by the hospital board. First off, Marlowe is starting to become a real prick. He seems pretty convinced that he has the job in the bag. Not so fast. Being the one person who probably doesn't deserve the job, I can't say that I'm surprised that at the end of the day Sloan came out on top. The guy is pretty sleazy, but he used his charm, listening skills, and manipulative techniques to his advantage. Much like Webber though, the "right now plan" makes more sense to me too. However, Derek made the smart observation: who knows where you'll be in ten years? Too bad he didn't come to the same conclusion Sloan did. Although Bailey helped Sloan... sort of.

Other stuff:

  • This I didn't even think about until Joel wrote about it, but he made a damn good point. Ever since the accident, Meredith looks way better than she ever did before. Almost dying does a body good apparently.
  • I'm glad Cristina finally made a move and decided to go forward with Burke. Her little holding pattern was getting harder and harder to deal with.
  • Catherine Dent! I love that she guest-starred and unlike Shoreh Aghdashloo's turn last week, I actually cared about Dent's character.
  • I'm gonna flip out if Alex starts up a relationship with Jane Doe. I don't care how hot her new face turns out.
  • Was there an actual point to introducing Hector Elizondo as Calleigh's father? Or was he simply brought in as the catalyst for George to remember the Night of the Living Gizzie? I like Elizondo which is why I ask, but he was just sort of... there.

And of course, the quote of the episode. One I assume everyone laughed at:

Addison (after Izzie asks her about sex with the wrong person): "What am I? The go-to person for adultery?"

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

35 Comments

Filter by:
th7284

I hope this was a dream. It doesn't click. I think they are too good as friends to be lovers.

April 03 2007 at 10:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
th7284

I hope this was a dream. It doesn't click. I think they are too good as friends to be lovers.

April 03 2007 at 10:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Big_Red


Grey turned into a soap. And not even a good soap.
bad soap. I feel like cleaning.
I wish they would have a personality. It's not hard to make a hospital show compelling- there is drama everywhere. And if you must do a soap- Alex+ Izzie.
George + some beautiful nerdy chick. And christina+ No one.
There.

March 25 2007 at 8:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Liza Apper

Poor Izzie! She loses in love every time! ALex, the cheater, Denny the Dead guy and now George the married best friend. Talk about rotten luck. Izzie, by the way,is NOT a slut and she is not sanctmonius. Izzie is a deeply compassionate person who makes mistakes (like relationships with guys that don't work out).
If people would listen to what is going on they would see the consistency and loving care with which Rhimes and the writing staff treat the GA characters.
I do, though, sense impending disaster with the Izzie/George "secret."

Liza

March 25 2007 at 2:09 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Deborah

My husband thought the construction worker who had his foot amputated looked familiar. Can anyone tell us who he is, and what other shows he may have been on? I thought he was on 3rd Watch, but didn't find him in their website.

March 24 2007 at 9:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
dave nelson

Did you see the story about ABC announcing "Dancing With Disabiliities" --after the success of Heather Mills?

A chick with no arms is goona lead off doing a Tango?

Digibandit.com

March 24 2007 at 2:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jaymez

Callie is quickly becomming the only likeable character on the show. Of all the main characters, she's the only one that's likeable. She's the only one that comes off as genuine and doesn't have some kind of secret motive.

My prediction for Alex. He and Jane Doe will hook up. He'll fall for her. The baby's father will return and take her away from him. He'll be devistated.

March 23 2007 at 11:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
anna

How can anyone love cheaters? Izzie and George. I think Izzie should be fired from the hospital and leave the show. And George should fess up because we all know how selfish Izzie is and jealous of Callie. She'll tell, its just a matter of when. Callie doesn't deserve any of this. And why wasn't Dr. Bailey up for the chief's job? She's the best and only qualified candidate.

March 23 2007 at 9:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
babe8720

I can't stand IZZY. I don't think they should have given her a raise. They should of replaced her. Or just dumped her. The show is so boring dramatic I had to turn it off. After Izzy's little drunk night.

March 23 2007 at 7:33 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Liz

I love Izzie and George together. I think they are so cute and really understand each other. I also think they have chemistry. I was happy for the hook-up and really sad for them at the end of this episode because both looked so miserable.

March 23 2007 at 3:48 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners