Powered by i.TV
February 10, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Scrubs: My No Good Reason

by Joel Keller, posted Mar 22nd 2007 11:21PM
Scrubs cast
(S06E14)
Here's the scenario: We all knew that the Scrubs crew was going to kill off one of its long-running cast members. They tried to fake us out by making Jordan bed-ridden after pre-natal surgery, but we weren't fooled (I mean, even Bill Lawrence doesn't have the balls to kill of his own wife).

Then we get a plot line where Cox keeps trying to convince Jesus-loving Nurse Roberts that some things happen for no good reason. All of a sudden we see Aloma Wright, who plays Nurse Roberts, recite a meaty speech at the end of the episode, something she's never done in six years. Right then and there, we all knew who the killee was going to be.

Yep, Laverne's a goner.

Well, technically we don't know that yet. She just ended the episode in a coma. I'm guessing we'll find out her fate in part 2 of the episode in a couple of weeks. But it's not looking good for Laverne.

That whole storyline was kind of awkward, wasn't it? I mean, why was Cox so hellbent (pun intended) on dissuading Laverne of her belief that everything happens for a reason? Out of all the docs at Sacred Heart, Cox is the most aware that everyone has a coping mechanism to deal with all the sickness and death around them. And, although he's been critical of Laverne's devotion in the past, it still seemed ultra-cruel of him to try to break the poor woman. It just seemed like a long way to go to set up the auto accident that put her in the coma. I was kind of surprised they resorted to a car accident, though; I figured they'd give her cancer or some fast-acting disease. Heck, even having Nurse Roberts contract something from a patient would have been a better idea.

Of course, whenever Cox is around, funny things happen. He asks Laverne how to explain New Orleans, sugar-free ice cream and Hugh Jackman (boy, what did Hugh do for Cox to hate him so much?). Then he asks her what reason there was for him to dump coffee behind his back, which J.D. answered by slipping, falling, and refusing to get up unless Cox helped him. He was down there for so long, another nurse stepped right on him...

The funnier moments in this episode, though, happened away from the Cox/Laverne storyline. The best was about Heather, the lovely nanny that the Turks hired to take care of little Izzie. Both of the funniest parts were J.D. fantasies: The Todd's call of "Boooobiiiiieeesss!" to get all the men in to watch the nanny cam tape (don't care if the "Ricola" joke is overdone; it worked here), and the fantasy where J.D. not only makes out with the nanny, but the football players who beat him up show up and announce they're gay and his high school crush wanted a threesome. The reason Turk knew it was a fantasy? "How did Kristin know Heather's name?" Also, the visual demonstration of how ugly Turk finds all of J.D.'s girlfriends was equally disturbing and funny. Whoever played "ugly Elliot" earned his SAG card with the dress and wig.

The last storyline, about Kelso finally speaking to Elliot after she thanks him for making her the doctor she is now, was OK, mainly because of Ken Jenkins' performance. I like the face he told the Janitor to make when he relayed the news that Dr. Reed was suspended for bringing a patient's dog into the hospital. I also liked the line "I'm going to say the same thing I told my new gardener when he asked for Easter off: No way, Jose. His name is actually Jose. That's why I hired him." Janitor didn't have much to do, but I liked how he made like J.D. and looked into the distance, only to find out that's where he drunkenly threw all his cleaning supplies.

See? There's always something funny in a Scrubs episode (I forgot about J.D. wanting to give Heather a goodbye hug, and Turk going "yeah, she's a smoking hot racist thief."), and this episode had more funny moments than we've seen through most of this season. But, the laugh-out-loud moments have turned into chuckle-softly moments, which is not a good sign. Either way, the show is still entertaining to watch, and they still have the power to hook a viewer with the serious side of the story, as the show's fans are going to be curious to see how they treat Laverne's decline. As the fans know, even at 75%, Scrubs is still better than most comedies on TV.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

34 Comments

Filter by:
Jennifer

Really liked this episode - to me it felt like it was firing on all cylanders like in previous seasons (as opposed to how many eps this season have felt "off").

Weird choice for Laverne to have a car accident - she's a middle-aged overweight black woman - she should've had a stroke or heart attack.

No one commented yet on the shout-out to the weirdness that's been McGinley's hair this season - Jordan sarcastically said, "I loovvee your hair." and Cox said, "Everybody does!" That was great!

A comment on the season in general - I think one thing that's been missing is interaction between Cox and JD. That relationship is key to the series, and even though JD is no longer Cox's resident, I wish they'd find more reasons for them to collaborate.

March 25 2007 at 12:51 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dan

I missed the episode. Does anyone know where I can see it online? NBC only has the 2 minute replay.
Thanks!

March 24 2007 at 4:27 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Gwin

Sorry, I am a fan of Scrubs - that signature (which I can't seem to get rid of on this computer) was regarding something else!

March 24 2007 at 2:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
laurie

Nick, this is a bit late but the song is called, "Ain't No Reason" by Brett Dennen.

March 23 2007 at 4:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
judi

I actually recall people talking about this storyline at least a month ago--on TVSq, so when that scene with Laverne in the angel wings came on, I yelled to my roommate "OH MY GAWD, IT IS HER!! IT'S GOING TO HAPPEN!" to which it did not...until now.
::deep sigh of gratification::
mmmm~Foreshadowing. Just like Shakespeare.

March 23 2007 at 3:58 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Wu Kong

My favourite part was the collaborative lie told by the guys. Great stuff!

March 23 2007 at 3:53 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Gwin

A couple of thoughts:

1. I noticed throughout the episode that Laverne was filmed with a sorta soft glowy light around her. Did anyone else notice that?

2. The episode was directed by Zach Braff.

3. The "ugly Elliot" wasn't an actual person -- it was a digital creation (mixing Elliot's features with some dude's).

March 23 2007 at 3:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
LaughingBull

Hey Joel,

I found an interview that explains Dr Cox's hate for Hugh Jackman (sort of): http://www.tvsquad.com/2006/05/16/john-c-mcginley-the-tv-squad-interview/

Keep up the good work!

March 23 2007 at 1:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
agentmichaelscarn

To OnlyRumors, yes I saw the foreshadowing.

At the same time, the cast and crew revealed that a character from the show will die way back in May. Given the order in which they presented it to us(and some help from this site and Wikipedia.com) led me to the following conclusions.
1) Person will die
2) Has been a regular since season 1
3) Person is female

After that I figured that it would not be a major star and Jordan wasn't really a cast member the first season or two, just a recurring character. I guessed that it would be good old Laverne. Plus, the actress who plays her rarely ever got to show her dramatic skills and this episode let her character open up more -- granted it doesn't really help her situation.

If you excuse me, I feel as if I'm beginning to ramble. Not a bad episode.

March 23 2007 at 1:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
OnlyRumors

re: Laverne

2 weeks ago, there was an odd scene with laverene wearing angelic wings while hovering in the background. Did anyone else catch this foreshadowing?

March 23 2007 at 11:45 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners