Powered by i.TV
May 26, 2012

ER: Family Business

by Richard Keller, posted Apr 19th 2007 11:50PM

Doctors Kovac and Barnett from ER(S13E19) Even after 13 seasons and 285 (!) episodes ER can still get to me once in awhile. There will be that one storyline, that one character, that will just hit a raw spot with me and generate a overwhelming feeling of sadness of sympathy. This week's episode had one of those story lines.

It involved a son, who never took care of himself and was dying of heart failure, and his father, who was well into his bout with Alzheimer's Disease. As the episode progressed the son died with the father there to watch. His reaction to his son's death was a bit heart-wrenching to watch. Maybe it's because I have a young son of my own and I would never want to be in a situation where I watch him die before my very eyes.

Later in the episode, when Doctors Kovac and Gates are trying to get the father into a nursing home, we realize that he doesn't remember that his son died, and it begins all over again. By the end of the episode the father again forgets that he watched his son die. This time, instead of repeating what he had said to the man previously, Kovac tells the older gentleman that his son will come and see him in his new place when he can. As he leaves the hospital we see the father smiling to himself with thoughts of how good his son was.

Call it schmaltz, call it sappy, call it over-acting. If it got to you, then it worked. And, that's one of the reasons why ER is still on the air.

As the title of the episode implies, this week's ER definitely dealt with family on both a patient and staff level. I already mentioned the story line that featured a father watching his son die. There was also a story that featured a little boy and his older brother. The older boy had an asthma attack and was rushed to the emergency room by an Armenian-speaking florist, who proceeded to crash his van into a hospital wall. The florist had a brother as well, and that man berated him for crashing the florist's van into the hospital. However, when he found out that his brother was speeding in order to save a young man's life, the brother forgave him.

From the staff of County General we had the further adventures of Tony Gates and Sarah, with a special appearance by Tony's dad. We learned a bit more about Mike, Tony's father, in this episode. Mike was a former firefighter, which may be the reason why Tony became a lifesaver himself. Now, he can't find another job that suits him. Broke and homeless, Mike is now staying with Tony, which is putting the strain on his and Sarah's relationship. Well, there's that, and the fact that Sarah knows that Tony is not her father. This is why she is doing her damnedest to keep a good house for Tony. She probably feels that if she helps take care of Tony that she can continue to stay with him rather than moving to her grandparents' farm. By the way, while we are speaking about Gates, when did he and Pratt get so chummy? Tony was practically kissing Greg's butt this week when he found out that Pratt's brother wanted to become an EMT.

And while we're on the subject of Greg Pratt, he makes amends this week for the idiotic way he treated his brother earlier in the season. Once again, this is another sign of how Pratt is finally growing up after years of channeling Peter Benton. We've seen that with the way he has treated Gates and the other interns and residents over the last few episodes. I'm glad to see Greg get back together with his brother, but it looks like his brother is going to be in trouble pretty fast, according to next week's previews.

The final family connection this week was Abby and her son Joe. This was the only part of ER that I found extremely predictable. Abby brings in a sample of Joe's urine because he's been sick for a week. When Luka finds out Abby throws the specimen into the trash. Then, when Kovac isn't looking, she grabs it out of the trash and has it analyzed anyway. Let me be sarcastic for one moment . . . ahem . . . . Gosh, I didn't see that coming! Thank you. Then, she brings her son into the ER to get checked out. All right, I can accept this because everyone from Dr. Greene to Peter Benton brought their kids in over the years for one reason or another. But, why do you examine him in a room where other sick people reside? Isn't there a potential of getting sicker?

rating 6

That's it for this week. I don't know what's going on next Thursday, but the previews actually intrigued me. So, take care and I'll see you then. Oh, wait! I almost forgot, on a scale from one to seven, with one being the worst, I give this episode of ER a . . .

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

10 Comments

Filter by:
indigal

great review! and really interesting comments.
I was glad to see Robert Prosky recognized, as his performance was one of the most moving I have ever seen. I cried through almost every moment, and really forgot completely that this was fiction. I think Prosky is an unbelievable actor, and this storyline was so well-written. By far the most memorable part of this episode for me.
I also loved the Armenian florist/good samaritan. He really lit up the creen with that face and that smile, and the embrace between the two brothers at the end was one of those 'awwww' moments. I have yet to see Borat, so this image was not tainted for me. He was very entertaining.
I find that ER is so good at casting guest stars, and of course their writing is solid.
I love how they developed the family connections in this episode. I am really interested in the Pratt/Chaz storyline with issues about insecurity, masculinities, and homosexuality. Pratt is one of my favourite characters because of his complexity and slo because Mekhi does an excellent job in capturing this character and bringing him to life. He has a wonderful range of emotions, with a vulnerability and sensitivity that always leaves me wanting more. I also think the actor playing Chaz did a great job, and these two have a very natural on-screen connection.
As much as I love Gates, I really want Neela with Ray. I think Neela is drop-dead gorgeous, so it doesn't surprise me that so many men adore her, but what really intrigues me about her is that vulnerability. Similar to Pratt, she is very closed-off on the surface, but reveals so much emotion through her sympathetic eyes and minor facial gestures. You can tell that she desperately wants to connect with people but doesn't know how or cannot let herself. It is really interesting to see her open up. I actually started watching ER because of Parminder; I was so captivated by her performance. I can't believe I have missed so much quality drama for so many years! I am catching up with the dvds, though:)
I really hope that Luca and Abby can have a relatively happy marriage, because I love this couple. As always, Visnjic turned in a stellar performance, and those father/son moments were so appropriate. Goran has such a quiet presence...I don't know how to describe it, but there is such a softness and sweetness to him. He really pays attention to the subtleties, nuances.
Was it just me, or was Sam hilarious tonight? I thought Liza's facial expressions were so perfect when she was shocking that patient. I like how she has been a lot more relaxed since she got that phone call from her son on her birthday. I really hope something great happens to this character, because she has such a tough life. Will we see a return of self-defense teacher? I hope so!

May 01 2007 at 3:13 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Cat

The father/son storyline was heartbreaking. So sad.

I actually didn't hate Gates this episode, tho him and Pratt being all buddy-buddy was weird. I'm getting the feeling that Gates is definitely not ready to handle 'fatherhood'.

Man... all the guys like Neela, huh?

I thought Sam's storyline was cute, tho.

April 26 2007 at 7:40 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
drew

what is next week's episode about?
can somebody post a link to a site, with a preview?

thanks

April 20 2007 at 1:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tim

I liked this episode, and the scenes with the old man definately tugged on the heart strings.

Why would people here read a review of a show if they hadn't watched it (and were planning on it)? That seems pretty silly - especially when they complain about it in the comments.

April 20 2007 at 11:14 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jimmy

For me this episode was all about Robert Prosky, who played the dad with Alzheimer's Disease. The man deserves an Emmy for the performance he gave when Kovac and Gates had to once again tell him his son had died.

April 20 2007 at 10:48 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Erika

It was sad to see Luca and his son at the end, knowing that he was thinking about his other children...
I don't want Luca to leave!!
Sam's storyline was amusing, but totally out of place in that episode. oh well.

April 20 2007 at 9:38 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
KateG

The fact that the Armenian florist was Azamat from Borat was a little distracting at first but after I got the image of that wrestling match out of my head I was fine.

April 20 2007 at 9:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mikey

I don't mind the spoilers because that is what this site offers, a recap for those of us who miss out. I did see this episode and I do agree with all the recap.

April 20 2007 at 3:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Nez

And again, when anyone does a review, could you please either not tell the entire storyline, or put in a spolier warning? Thank you

April 20 2007 at 12:47 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tammy

Yes the story line was hard to watch. My grandmother had Alzheimer's and now my mom is in early stages of it too. So it's tough anytime there is a story line involving that disease.

I thought for sure they would make Gates the dad. That was a surprise.

April 20 2007 at 12:00 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners