Powered by i.TV
October 30, 2014

Dancing With The Stars: Week 8

by Brett Love, posted May 8th 2007 3:28AM
Billy Ray Cyrus, Karina Smirnoff
(S04E14)
Which one of these doesn't belong? As is par for the course on Dancing With The Stars, somebody always gets through on the power of the fan vote, surpassing contestants that are superior dancers. This year, that somebody is Billy Ray Cyrus. We could argue all day about whether or not Billy Ray should still be on the show, but one thing is for sure, while he is here, he makes things interesting. Read on to hear about the latest dustup.

Ian Ziering, Cheryl BurkeIan Ziering and Cheryl Burke (Foxtrot) - It's been a long time coming, but Ian is finally coming out of his shell. It's a little late in the competition to be getting to that, but better late than never. The new relaxed attitude was evident right from the beginning. They lacked some of the wow factor we have seen with other couples, but it was a very nice performance. Len thought Ian took a bit of a dip, calling the dance a bit skippy. Bruno agreed with him. He compared Ian to a "jumpy goat." Carrie Ann praised him for his exuberance and charm. Score: 22 (8, 7, 7). I thought that was a bit low.

Joey Fatone and Kym Johnson (Waltz) - I have to say, Joey's behind the scenes package summed up what is so great about him. He's such a likable guy, with a great personality. I understand what he was trying to do by going to the more traditional performance, I'm just not sure if that is playing to his strengths. The waltz lacked the show stopper 'razzle dazzle' that has become Joey's trademark in the competition, but it was a beautiful dance, performed well. And Princess Kym was stunning. Bruno thought it looked like a rehearsal and wanted more razzle-dazzle. Carrie Ann agreed, saying it was solid technically but lacked Joey's personality. Len thought it was elegant and beautiful. Score: 26 (9, 9, 8) Not bad.

Billy Ray Cyrus and Karina Smirnoff (Foxtrot) - At this point it's almost like someone called ahead and told you the time and place for a train wreck. You just have to see what is going to happen. The performance started out looking more like the foxwalk, but Billy did manage a nice set of steps in the middle. I think the fact that Karina has toned down some of the more vulgar aspects of the character was a nice plus as well. Carrie Ann praised Billy's improvement. Len said it had the most content of any dance Billy Ray has done, but the steps were all wrong. Bruno thought it was the deliciously awful foxtrot on the temple of doom. That's the typical crazy Bruno talk we've become accustomed to, but then he went on to say it was crap. Yikes. Now, I've thought Billy Ray should have been sent home every week, but even I balk at calling it crap. That's not judging, not criticizing, it's just being mean. Score: 18 (7, 6, 5). That's a reasonable score, and it was followed up by Billy Ray making a point that he didn't appreciate Bruno's rudeness. More on that later.

Laila Ali and Maksim Chmerkovskiy (Waltz) - Laila's dad was in attendance this week and she dedicated her waltz to him. It was another beautiful performance. The waltz lends itself so well to graceful and elegant dancing. Her blowing the kiss to her father was very touching. The only thing I could take away from it was the finish. They just kind of stopped and walked away instead of dancing to a finish. Len called it elegant and classy, but criticized Laila's posture. Bruno thought it was excellent. Carrie Ann praised the emotion that Laila brought to the dance, calling it profound. Score: 27 (9, 9, 9). That's a good score.

Apolo Ohno, Julianne HoughApolo Anton Ohno and Julianne Hough (Tango) - At this stage of the competition, I really believe that Apolo is the hardest working of the dancers. His hard work has paid off as he and Julianne continue to put up one great performance after another. This was a very slick tango, with a lot of credit going to Julianne for the choreography. It had the basic elements of the tango, but with a fresh look that we haven't seen this season. The one problem with it was the music. Rick Springfield's "Jessie's Girl" for the tango? Seriously? There was some fantastic dancing here, but that song couldn't have been more distracting if they had tried. Bruno called it electric, dynamic, and contemporary. He also praised Julianne's choreography. Carrie Ann said everything was perfect. Len thought it lacked passion and drama, saying it was a cacophony of noise, to which Bruno said he was losing his marbles. I have to agree with Bruno in that regard. Score: 28(10, 8, 10) That's a good score, but what the heck was with the scoring snafu?

Ian Ziering and Cheryl Burke (Rumba) - Some of the free spirit Ian disappeared with this performance. There were moments where the uber-focused Ian had returned. Possibly more time was spent practicing the other dance, so he wasn't as comfortable coming into this one. Not that it was bad by any stretch. They had some great moments, but those moments were broken up by Ian thinking his way from move to move. Carrie Ann didn't think Ian's passion was authentic. Len liked Ian's poses, but didn't think he was natural. Bruno said it was a great improvement. Score: 25 (8,8,9) A nice score for that performance.

Joey Fatone, Kym JohnsonJoey Fatone and Kym Johnson (Mambo) - The razzle dazzle was back with this performance, and it worked to full effect. I especially liked the section where they mirrored each other. Their synchronization is very impressive. They had very intricate work with their arms as well. That was a fantastic performance. I'm happy for Kym that she got Joey for a partner this season. She had a tough go of it last season with Jerry, so it's nice to see her get an opportunity to shine. Len liked the underarm turns and the fact that they broke it on the second beat. Bruno thought they pimped the mambo. Carrie Ann appreciates that Joey has stepped it up and is working hard. Score: 29 (10, 9, 10). One of the best of the night.

Billy Ray Cyrus and Karina Smirnoff (Mambo) - They were unfortunate to be following Joey and Kym while doing the same dance. It really exaggerated just how far apart these two are when it comes to dancing. For the first half of the dance Billy Ray had something going on. He was actually doing the dance. It all kind of fell apart in the middle when he knelt on the floor and just watched Karina dance. Bruno called Billy Ray a wild beast that can't be tamed. Carrie Ann offered the backhanded compliment that Billy Ray makes people think they can do this as well. Len thought it was entertaining, but not nearly as good as the first performance. Before the scores could be revealed, Billy nearly gave Samantha a heart attack as he tried to wrestle away the microphone to speak his peace about Bruno's rudeness. He might have gone too far with it, but he has a point. Bruno was in the wrong. Score: 20 (6, 7, 7)

Laila Ali and Maksim Chmerkovskiy (Jive) - They took a little long to get into their dance, but once they did it was really good. The moves they did in sequence were really together and they had a cute finish. With the scores so close for the top four couples, it is going to come down to a fan vote. It will be interesting to see if Laila has been able to win over enough of the fans. As far as the dancing is concerned, she has certainly done enough to put herself in the running. Carrie Ann called it clever and spunky. Len praised Laila, but didn't like the opening. Bruno agreed with Len. Score: 26 (9, 8, 9)

Apolo Anton Ohno and Julianne Hough (Paso Doble) - Holy smokes. The dance of the night. Julianne made a small bobble on her big slide in their opening sequence, but other than that this was a perfect performance. It was theatrical, well choreographed, danced wonderfully, and had the fire and passion required for the paso. At this point I'm ready to give Julianne the MVP (Most Valuable Professional). I think she is getting more out of her partner than anyone else. Len thought it had everything he wanted to see. Bruno said that was a champion looking at the finish line. Carrie Ann had chills. Score 30 (10, 10. 10) A perfect score to cap off a great night.

6 out of 7So, that leaves us with one big question. Does Billy Ray have enough of a fan base to put him through for another week? I think it's probably his time to go, but I don't think Ian is safe by any stretch. We've seen it before with Jerry Rice edging out Stacy Kiebler. It should make the results show very interesting. It was a great night of dancing, worthy of a 6, out of 7.

Don't forget to vote in AOL's Dancing With The Stars poll!

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

41 Comments

Filter by:
Jan

I have watched Laila Ali from the start of the show and I think they are scoring her way to high. Just because she is the daughter of Mohhamed Ali she should not constantly get 10's. I think Apollo and Joey are much better dancers and much more entertaining. I feel Laila is way over rated.

May 17 2007 at 7:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Carolyn Covel

I have to agree that Billy Ray Cyrus probably is a wonderful person and a gentleman. But he should not be out there dancing if you want to call it that. He is not only an embarassment to himself but to his partner. If I were dancing with him I would walk off of the floor. And also if he is a gentleman he would not have pulled a temper tantrum. I have to agree Grow up Billy and do the best in your field.

May 16 2007 at 9:06 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
patricia

I just wish ABC would invite people with a modicum of skills. Last season it was Jerry, this season Billy Ray. They stay on far longer then they should because of strong fan bases not an ability to dance. It is so unfair to the contestants with talent.

May 14 2007 at 10:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
edie

Apolo is my favorite, and I hope he wins. I felt sorry for Billiy Ray, though.I give him an "8" for effort. He just wasn't good enough, but didn't deserve all the negative comments. His fans were responsible for his coming back
each week, and he was entertaining. I looked forward o seeing what he was going to do next, so I'll miss him.

May 12 2007 at 6:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
rajini

I cannot believe Joey was in the bottom two last night. Are those voters out there crazy? How can they vote for Ian to be safe??? He has never gotten a 10 since the show started. Not that I don't like any of the stars , I love them all , but hey, give credit to those who have done so well. Joey deserves to win. He has been the most consistent of the lot. So you Joey fans out there, KEEP THOSE VOTES COMING!

May 09 2007 at 6:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Linda Sawyers

My comment is this: Be it Billy Ray or Ian or Joey, they need not be so harsh as to think any of these people are pro's. Not one of them is a professional it would be a nute point if they were. they are all pro somethings. so why so much disrepect for them all.?? They are trying so hard .ie the practices and weight loss. saying any thing is crap after all these weeks? Bruno was not sorry when he grabbed hismouth he knew he went to far. why attack anyone so personally. as karina said it is to be constructive criticism but how do you fix crap. say you are sweet but your arms are still or you don't bend your knees enough. the judges have become carried away with their own fame. (let;s see them dance) even better let's see them act or sing.....

May 09 2007 at 8:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ina

I feel Bruno should have been the one sent home not Billy Ray. He is a gentleman, because if he wasn't, Bruno
would not have been able to be there. Being judged and told you are a bad dancer because you don't dance like you are on MTV instead of a ballroom is bad enough, but when some one says what Bruno did because you don't "turn" him on with filty dancing is more than any descent person could take. He did not throw a temper tantrum, he just tried to say something, but he wasn't alowed because he wasn't using gutter language. I only watched the show this time because Billy Ray was on it, I don't ever watch it any other time, and I certainly want watch it any more. I'm glad there is some Gentlemen left. We have a country full of Bruno's and that is why this world is so rotten. GO BILLY RAY!

May 09 2007 at 7:52 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Heather

I wasn't surprised that Billy Ray was the one to get kicked off, but it was still a tense moment, because his fans really could've turned it around for him. Every time the judges badmouth someone, they're gonna get voted in, the next week.

It was really unnecessary for the judges to attack Billy Ray. Yeah, granted, he's not that good, but still... why was Ratzenburger "cute" for his efforts, and Billy Ray was a "bumbling bear"? Totally uncalled for, and Bruno and Len should've said they were too harsh on him. In the end, DWTS is a personality contest, but B.R. did get out there and rock it the best he could.

I was very surprised when Ian was the first to move on to the semis. I was sure it was gonna be him and Billy Ray in the red light. I think the final 2 will be Apolo and Joey, tho an Apolo/Laila match up would be great... just to see them really bring it, with their sports backgrounds.

Julianne is unbelievable. She is SO great and fun and professional... and 18!! She and Apolo are definitely a great match. They were great together from the start, but now they're just fantastic. All of that intricate choreography just kills me :) Their routines are amazing, and that nonsense when Len gave them an 8 for their - what was it? The fox trot? That score was total crap. However, they can't all be terrific, so I think the judges are trying to separate the pack, too.

May 09 2007 at 6:17 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tori

I absolutely agree that Julianne is the best professional dancer on the show. Her choreography is always interesting, hit or miss. I hope to see her and Apolo in the final. They really did the best overall with both their dances and they are consistently hardworking and solid. I think that both dances were a bit busy last night but they were entertaining.

Laila's ballroom dance had more sophistication and seemed smoother than Joey's so I understand the difference in scores. But I actually really prefer Laila to both Joey and Ian (and of course Billy Ray who has personality but no skills). It's difficult being judged at the only female especially one with such limitations because of her size and strength compared to her partner. Still, she'll need to step it up. Ian is still looking quite unpolished and although Joey's got the personality (borderlining on annoying at times), he's really over the top to me.

May 09 2007 at 2:12 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Glenda Wood

Billy Ray is not a dancer, the stars are asked to be on that show, and should be shown a little respect, that goes for all of them, if they were professional dancers, they would not be on the show, some learn some don't, but to say hurtful things is uncalled for. I have watched this show, because the judges show class in their comments, not like simon and don't put down the ones who can't dance, so what happened, they will lose some of the fans of the show with that kind of action last night, as they don't have be that way to have a great show

May 08 2007 at 6:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners