On The Lot: Contestant Films (Action)
(S01E11) I'm really surprised On The Lot has made it this long without getting yanked.
My suspicion is Fox doesn't quite have the guts to cancel a show produced by the venerable Steven Spielberg, but they're covertly doing everything in their power to get this stinker off the air. Hence, the double eliminations for the last two weeks.
By my calculations, if we continue cutting two people a week, we'll only be subjected to four or five more episodes tops.
I think this may be the first time I've ever consistently watched a show on a weekly basis while simultaneously wanting it to die.
Yup, this show is definitely an anomaly, but in the worst kind of way. Let's hope the world is never subjected to a show about the movie-making process ever again. It just doesn't seem to work.
Tonight's guest judge is Antoine Fuqua, director of hits like Training Day and Shooter.
#1 - Sam - Key Witness
Synopsis: A bounty hunter tracks down a key witness in a trial.
Carrie - I thought it was a lot of action and that that was very good. However, the action overwhelmed the movie for me.
Antoine - Well covered and a lot of style. Almost too much style over substance. You were caught up in the action a little too much, but you did a great job.
Garry - Some of the motivation was a little medium, but I thought it was a good job overall though.
Considering he had 1 1/2 minutes to work with, I thought Sam did a pretty extraordinary job. It was a little busy at times, and I didn't quite know why so much time elapsed before the second assailant above the dumpster started shooting at the bounty hunter and witness, but I'm just being nit picky. Good action, a nice bit of humor at the end, and serviceable acting. I liked it.
#2 - Jason - Sweet
Synopsis: Guy forgets his anniversary at the last minute.
Carrie - This is my favorite thing that you've done so far. Great visual style. Your wife should be very, very proud.
Antoine - You proved action doesn't have to be violent. You made me care, and you did it with style.
Garry - No blood, no one died, it was comical yet totally accessible. You did a terrific job.
Jason said if no one else gets this movie than his wife will. That's a great strategy, jackass, considering you're wife will be casting the solitary vote that keeps you in the competition. Brilliant. As it turns out after watching his film, I was pleasantly surprised with what he did. It was funny, well shot (aside from the weird black and white still reaction shots), and completely accessible because I have a similar panic attack every time a special occasion rolls around. Best film Jason's done.
#3 - Andrew - Zero 2 Sixty
Synopsis: Car salesman is forced to sell cars in an extraordinary situation.
Carrie - I thought you did a really, really good job. This was a really inventive idea, and I thought you did a good job with the action. Solid.
Antoine - You really did a good job, but I got a little lost in the action comedy drama. The character was interesting, but I couldn't quite understand his high pitch voice.
Garry - Very ambitious and well paced. I love a car chase.
The judges are idiots. This was a bad Ford commercial disguised as a car chase. Nothing more. The FBI agent was wholly uncertain with his confidence and unbelievable, the salesman was annoyingly annoying, and I can't figure out why he decided to join the FBI agent on a high speed chase. As far as the pursuit went, it wasn't completely horrible. However, the fact that the plot was so poor completely tarnished the action. Andrew will be heading home.
#4 - Kenny - The Losers
Synopsis: Dad takes on his son's bully in a downhill skateboard race.
Carrie - Kenny, you've got an awesome eye. You make some incredible looking films, but it's a little unbalanced. The stories aren't as developed as the films look. Work as hard on the story as you do the film.
Antoine - I felt the geography was a little all over the place, and the ending teetered away. You're good, but you need to trust your crew a little more.
Garry - I love that you're wild and abstract, but I was a little bewildered. The lizard confused me.
My vote was for Kenny to do the stunt himself in the hopes he would get hit by the car. Didn't happen. However, as the judges said, he ended up making a visually meaty film that was a little anorexic in the story department.
#5 - Mateen - Catch
Synopsis: A good samaritan attempts to catch a thief.
Carrie - I thought you did a good job with that. This was your best film so far. Good job.
Antoine - I though you put too much in two minutes at first, but watching it again I thought you did a good job.
Garry - I don't know that someone stealing money from a hat was a big enough deal to make a movie out of. I still think you did a good job.
So Garry - a guy stealing a hat full of money isn't a great reason to make a movie, but skateboarding downhill is? That just seemed like a strange thing to say because he's said a lot of nice things about plots that I found a bit on the unworthy side.
All in all, I thought Mateen had a decent film. He started out well, had a nice chase sequence in the middle, and tied everything up together at the end with a believable "catch" which I thought did a good job of explaining why an older gentleman was physically fit enough to take down a much younger thief. I think it was one of Mateen's better films.
Favorite movies of the night:
Carrie - Zero 2 Sixty
Antoine - Sweet
Garry - Sweet
JJ - Sweet
|#1 - Sam - Key Witness||9 (11.3%)|
|#2 - Jason - Sweet||59 (73.8%)|
|#3 - Andrew - Zero 2 Sixty||4 (5.0%)|
|#4 - Kenny - The Losers||2 (2.5%)|
|#5 - Mateen - Catch||6 (7.5%)|