I love this show!!!!!!!!! I use torrents of it from Canada in my teaching. I have every episode on my iPod. Piven and Marshall were genius (better than Willis and Sheppard in Blue Moon). Cavanaugh has the comedic timing that could pull it off. I'm cautiously waiting the return of this show.

> 16. How about Tom Cavanaugh from "Ed"?

I think the character had a desperate quality to his condition that I haven't seen Cavanaugh possess. I hope they can find someone right for the role(s).

How about Tom Cavanaugh from "Ed"?

How about Will Arnett? Hell, I thought that was his photo anyway when I clicked on this link.

I LOVED that show. But it was the Piven who made me love it. I don't know who else could carry off that manic energy without coming off as Piven Lite--like the annoying Jack Black Lite in "Reaper."

Bring back Firefly instead. :o)

Keep in mind, the whole point of the original show was, is this guy really Cupid, or is he a mental patient. If that's still your premise, you need someone who can play a good mental patient. I don't think Bateman can do that.

I loved that show. I'm glad to hear it's coming back, but I'm not sure it will be the same without Ari.

Please get FOX to revive Wonderfalls and slot it on other than Friday or Saturday night.

Adore that show. FOX's previous management made a huge mistake to cancel it.

One of my first and only comments on this site for the longest time was in a Cupid thread(different handle). I probably wasn't part of the demography they were looking for, but I loved the show. I'm a little concerned about remaking and starting the show over though. Of course, setting the show in LA already takes away some of the charm that the show had.... It will be interesting to see who is cast. I thought the casting was pretty much perfect back then. Now if they would only bring the original Cupid to DVD...