Powered by i.TV
October 7, 2015

Five deaths that rocked television, or at least their shows

by Jason Hughes, posted Nov 26th 2007 2:01PM

John RitterI'm feeling a little melancholy today. This past Friday, a friend of mine lost two daughters in a senseless automobile accident. They were thirteen and eighteen; one having just started college and the other just entering the magical teen years. It was so sudden and insane that I can't really wrap my brain around it. As a parent, I can only begin to understand what he and the girls' mother are going through, but even then I'm sure it pales in comparison to the reality.

As I thought about this blog and things to post on television, I was struck by how death can have a dramatic and instant impact on a fictional show as well. Sometimes when an actor dies, the show is able to move on with relative smoothness, but other times there is an irreplaceable hole that just never seems to be filled.

1) Eight Simple Rules (for Dating My Teenage Daughter) - John Ritter
When star John Ritter passed suddenly mid-season, Eight Simple Rules didn't end immediately, and even managed to retain much of its quality, thanks in large part to impressive work by Katey Sagal as new widow Cate Hennessy. The creators opted to work in Ritter's sudden death from an aortic dissension by having his character Paul Hennessy also die suddenly. The show bravely continued two more years, having the family deal directly with the loss of its primary breadwinner and patriarch in a realistic fashion, something few shows had done to such an intimate degree. Ratings declined, however, and even the additions of James Garner as Cate's father, and David Spade as her nephew weren't enough to revive them. Considering the show mustered another two seasons, it's hard to say if the loss of Ritter doomed the show, or shifts to less and less ratings-friendly time slots did it in.

2) NewsRadio - Phil Hartman
While NewsRadio was an ensemble cast, and Phil Hartman was by no means considered the main star, his character was significant enough that his sudden death between seasons four and five stunned both the audience and the cast. An argument could be made that the show could have continued without Hartman, had they not so quickly replaced him with Jon Lovitz. Nothing against Lovitz, as I think he's a tremendous comedian and by itself his character was funny, but one couldn't help but be reminded of Hartman every time he was on screen, and of how different they were. Maybe if some time had lapsed before Lovitz' character had been introduced, things could have changed, but who knows. Hartman was a beloved actor/comedian dating back to his time on Saturday Night Live, with Lovitz (the two of them had known each other and worked together dating back to time spent together with improv group The Groundlings), and his sudden murder by his wife rocked the tabloids the summer between those two seasons. It was such a high profile murder, that nothing perhaps could have saved the show from a gaping Hartman sized hole in every episode.

3) The Royal Family - Redd Foxx
While hardly a success for CBS in the 1991-1992 season, The Royal Family didn't really get a chance to see what it could have been. The comeback vehicle for comic legend Foxx proved too late as the actor died of a heart attack after shooting only seven episodes. Producers originally opted to end the series, but changed their minds and decided to use the series to show a family coping with the sudden loss of ... sound familiar? Jackee Harry joined the cast as widow Victoria's (Della Reese) sister. Of course, then the show went on hiatus from November to April and when it came back it was a whole different monster; Harry was now Reese's eldest daughter and it was as if the show had never featured Redd Foxx at all. This brings it into the realm of sudden, pointless and unexplained cast changes which is another list altogether. Luckily after 15 episodes, the plug was pulled and Foxx can remain remembered for Sanford & Son and other works.

4) Chico and the Man - Freddie Prinze
A groundbreaking show, Freddie Prinze played Chico, a street-smart Hispanic kid who finds a job at a run down garage, in Chico and the Man. The chemistry between Jack Albertson as "The Man" and Prinze catapulted the show into a top ten hit in its first two seasons. By the third season, Prinze's real-life drug abuse began to impact his physical appearance on the show, as he became emaciated and haggard looking, and ultimately led to his suicide during the airing of the third season. Fans struggled with acceptance as the season played out with Prinze still on the air. Rather than let the show end, producers continued, explaining away Prinze's absence by saying he was visiting his father in Mexico. They brought in a 12-year old kid as the new "Chico," shortly followed thereafter by Charo as his aunt. Ratings continued to slide as fans were less than enthused, and the fourth season proved to be its last. There's another list, bringing in a kid to try and bolster ratings; note to producers: this almost never works.

5) Sesame Street - Will Lee
When Will Lee died suddenly of a heart attack in December of 1982, producers of Sesame Street were left with a major decision. Lee played Mr. Hooper, beloved proprietor of Mr. Hooper's Store and a central human figure in the series. But how should a children's show populated by puppets handle such a serious matter? Should they address the death, or just work around the character, something that could have easily been done considering the frantic and haphazard pace of the show. In a landmark decision for children's programming, producers ultimately decided to write in Mr. Hooper's death and have the cast deal with his passing directly, showing children about death and the natural grieving process. It proved a moving and powerful bit of television that garnered Sesame Street tremendous critical accolades, and though I was a young lad at the time, I still remember Big Bird struggling to understand what had happened to his friend.

I realize there are many prominent deaths I did not cover, Jerry Orbach of Law & Order, John Spencer of The West Wing, and on and on. I focused on the ones that seemed to dramatically impact the flow, direction and popularity of their programs. I also was trying to go more for the deaths that were surprising, straying away from older characters whose deaths, while no less significant, may have been less unexpected. I'm sure its likely that I've still missed some that had a deep impact on you, but that's what the comments are for.

In remembering these actors and their performances, think of this as a tribute to their greatness and importance in television, rather than a depressing examination of their absence.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

The way they handled David Strickland's death on "Suddenly Susan" was classy and respectful.

November 28 2007 at 9:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Scott Brody

I am new to this posting and feel very sad for the writers loss and hope that he can feel some love from all of us that sympathize.

As for actors dying while a series is on the air or suddenly, I was terribly upset when Freddie Prinze shot himself, Redd Foxx had a heart attack, especially when most thought he was joking around originally, and was totally floored by John Ritter's death. I recently was at an autograph signing that Katey Sagal was doing and asked her to tell me one wonderful memory of John Ritter. She thanked me for asking, said all memories were wonderful, that she loved him and was about to tear up just thinking about him. She then turned to her kids and said, "We loved John, didn't we kids?" Her answer almost made me cry, but she was so happy that I brought him up.

Lastly, though some people did post and catch a few I was going to mention, Jon Erik Hexum, Selma from Night Court, and Coach from Cheers, one that nobody seemed to include and although didn't hurt the show drastically, but definitely changed it's ensemble a bit was Jack Soo from Barney Miller.

To Photoscribe: They did two days worth of Tributes when Bob Hope died, but one of the reasons you remember John Ritter so much is because he died on Sept. 11th and that day so much coverage was done for 9/11 that his story got extended for a few days. Also he was much younger than both Hope and Hepburn who were more expected to pass. I was very sad as well when George Burns and Johnny Carson died. These are people of legendary status like Jack Benny, Steve Allen, Milton Berle, Elvis, James Dean, Marilyn Monroe, Bruce Lee, Richard Pryor and the list just keeps going.

November 28 2007 at 4:21 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I still miss Phil....

November 28 2007 at 12:18 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Casting no aspersions on John Ritter, but I should point out that both Bob Hope and Katherine Hepburn died at about the same time that Ritter did, and shock of shocks, RITTER was the one who got the lion's share of the press!! Now, Ritter may have been a likeable guy...."Three's Company" may have been a major 70s hit, and he had very good luck with his other series actually having decent ratngs, but the man was NO Bob Hope, and he wasn't of the legendary status of either Hope OR Hepburn. There were NO Hope retrospectives...nothing on Hepburn....but TONS of blurbs and convos about Ritter....What was UP with that??

November 27 2007 at 11:57 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I think this is a great list but John Spencer as Leo McGarry on "The West Wing" should absolutly be on it. He was a central character in the show. He was 58 years old (would be 59 in four days) when he died and no one except his family and close friends (such as he "TWW" co-stars) even knew he was fairly sick.

His death absolutly affected the outcome of the show. He was the Democratic candidate for Vice President and it has been revealed that the Republican candidate, Arnold Vinick, was supposed to win the election but after John Spencer passed away and they wrote Leo McGarry's death into the show, the writers and producers thought it would be too crule to not have Santos, the democrat, win the election. The show would have ended completly differently if he had not passed away.

Also, Martin Sheen said in an interview that the cast was CONSIDERING not returning to the show for an 8th season but the death of John Spencer really made up their minds. Who knows, "The West Wing" might have gone on for several more seasons if he had not passed away.

November 27 2007 at 10:23 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

The loss of your friends' daughters is very hard to take, as I know. Their sudden and tragic deaths in this car accidents had hit us all very much so in this area. What is even more unsettling is the car that caused this horrendous tragedy has not been located. My thoughts and prayers to the family and friends. The girls were very much loved and will be missed.

November 27 2007 at 10:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

The Children's Defense Fund’s Leave No Child Behind® mission is to ensure every child a Healthy Start, a Head Start, a Fair Start, a Safe Start, and a Moral Start in life and successful passage to adulthood with the help of caring families and communities.

CDF provides a strong, effective voice for all the children of America who cannot vote, lobby, or speak for themselves.

Particular attention to the needs of poor and minority children and those with disabilities.

CDF encourages preventive investment before children get sick or into trouble, drop out of school, or suffer family breakdown.

CDF began in 1973 and is a private, nonprofit organization supported by foundation and corporate grants and individual donations.CDF has never taken government funds

November 27 2007 at 9:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

NewsRadio was and still is my favorite TV show of all-time. Phil Hartman's death was absolutely devastating on so many levels. He was considered a great and caring person, immensely-talented and a wonderful father to his two young children at the time. To this day I can't watch that first episode back that directly dealt with his character's death. The emotions of that close-knit cast were so raw and real that it's impossible not to cry along with them during that final group scene where they read the letters. Props to NewsRadio's writers for being able to make you laugh through the tears though. RIP Phil Hartman, you are missed.

November 27 2007 at 8:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

My condolences for the loss of your friends young daughters. Vic Morrow comes to mind. Also, Peter Jennings death was another one that broke my heart.

November 27 2007 at 8:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

wow what a sad sesame street episode. pretty morbid i think

November 27 2007 at 7:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners