Powered by i.TV
April 19, 2014

The Best and Worst of 2007: Joel's list

by Joel Keller, posted Jan 5th 2008 12:02PM
Viva LaughlinTo call 2007 a stellar year of TV would be a mistake, because it was a very bleh year in many respects. Shows that had previously riveted us to our seats made missteps and mistakes. New shows were either mediocre or just unmemorable. A writers' strike made people anxious and depressed all at once. And the aspects of the TV world that have generated low expectations continued on their merry lowbrow way (I mean, who expected Tila Tequila's search for love to be anything but a skankfest)?

But in a year of abject mediocrity, some highlights and lowlights poked through. Like last year, I'm going to make up categories instead of doing traditional "Bests" and "Worsts." It hurts my brain less...

GOODNESS

Best "I told you so!" show: 30 Rock. Like most people who saw last year's pilot, I thought the show wasn't all that good. But something about it made me continue to watch. Was it Alec Baldwin's performance? Probably. But there was something else there, a quality that told me -- and a few other patient folks -- that if the show was allowed to hit its stride, it could be something special. Now that it's being hailed as the show with the "most laughs per minute," and winning awards left and right, I'm happy that I stuck with the show from the beginning. It's one of the smartest shows on the air, cleverly making fun of everything from product placement to politically-correct network initiatives (I'd love to see David Schwimmer come back as Greenzo) to the war in Iraq. It's one of the shows I'll miss the most if the strike continues.

Best "You told me so!" show: Life. I really hated the pilot for this show. Damian Lewis' sprung-from-prison detective Charlie Crews had too many quirks and tics, and the procedural plots were too standard-grade, to make me think the show could work in the long term. But after reading all the comments of praise that accompanied Rich's reviews (along with my brother's glowing reviews themselves), I decided to give the show another chance. And I'm glad I did; Crews' tics have been toned down, and the mysteries -- especially in the episode "Farthingale" -- were twisty and interesting to watch. NBC picked it up for a full season; let's hope that it comes back even if the writers don't come back until next year.

Best finale that I could hope for, given the circumstances: Gilmore Girls. Amy Sherman-Palladino left the show after the sixth season and blew up the works on her way out. New show-runner David Rosenthal took almost two-thirds of the season cleaning up the mess, giving nothing of the old Gilmore for longtime fans to hold onto. But, the season finale -- which was obviously written to double as a series finale, because the chances Lauren Graham and Alexis Bledel were coming back were slim at best -- tied up loose ends and settled relationships well enough to satisfy even the most ardent fan. Did Luke and Lorelai get married? No. But there was enough of a "things are going to work out" vibe as the series concluded that it left me more satisfied than I could have imagined at the beginning of the season.

Best job of living up to expectations: Pushing Daisies. Unlike 2006's most-anticipated shows -- Studio 60, The Nine -- PD followed up its spectacular pilot with episodes that deftly balanced the sweet and sticky (a duet of "Birdhouse In Your Soul," anyone?) with the dark and twisted (bodies buried in snowmen, cheating spouses, dirty medical examiners). There were a few missteps, including the revelation at the end of the last pre-strike episode, but those offenses were minor. Let's hope Bryan Fuller finally has a hit on his hands.

Best recovery from an awful season: Scrubs. Season six of the veteran comedy was awkward and -- for the first fifteen or so episodes -- not particularly funny. But, starting with the musical episode, Bill Lawrence and company ended on... well, I can't call it a strong note, since they almost threw viewers back into a J.D. / Elliot coupling, but at least the episodes were entertaining. Season seven has started off well, mainly because the zaniness factor has been ratcheted back and we're getting reacquainted with the characters again. Opinions on the season have been decidely mixed, but after last year's stumbles, I welcome what Lawrence has done this year. Hopefully we'll get a final episode.

Honorable mentions: Stephen Colbert's entire year, but especially the "WristStrong" initiative; the improvement of the new correspondents on The Daily Show; The Simpsons Movie (it's so strongly connected to TV, I decided to include it); The Office (mostly... see below); Scott Baio is 45... and Single (it's the best of a bad cable reality bunch); It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia (especially Charlie's "Day Man / Night Man" songs); The Riches; Chuck; Reaper (though it fell off a lot after the pilot); the "Showdown" episode of How I Met Your Mother; Drew Carey's transformation into a damn good game show host.

BADNESS

Best reason why half-hour shows are only a half-hour:
The Office's hour-long episodes. It just seemed like most of the episodes were half-hilarious, half-filler, didn't it? And the structure seemed to be the same: first half was like a typically-funny Office episode, but in the second half, the writers run out of comedic gas and go for the broad and silly. The fun run, the kidnapping of the pizza delivery kid, Michael driving his car into a lake: all of those plotlines could have been sliced out without anyone missing them. I was very happy when the show went back to a half-hour; I wonder how those episodes will play out in syndication?

Best reason to agree with Dr. Perry Cox: Scrubs' cantankerous doctor hates Hugh Jackman, and after watching Viva Laughlin, I can start to understand why. What a disaster: bad acting, bad characterizations, bad writing, and a musical gimmick (stars singing along with the soundtrack) that was awkward at best. In a season where networks didn't pull the trigger as quickly as in the past due to the strike, Laughlin got canned after two episodes (aired over two days). That tells you how bad the rest of the episodes were going to be.

Best job of forcing people to get some sleep: The WGA and the AMPTP. The first casualties of the writers' strike were the late-night shows, who had to immediately shut down. Without a steady diet of Stewart and Colbert, Letterman and Conan, Leno and Kimmel, etc., the pickings on TV were pretty slim. Seinfeld reruns? Two and a Half Men? Family Guy? Why bother when all of that is on DVD? Local news? Too much fluff and shocked weathermen. Even without writers, the recent return of the late-night slate is a welcome sight, even though I'm not sure what it'll do to help or hurt the writers' cause.

Best way to make the public hate a show before it ever airs: Play promos for it repeatedly during a sporting event. FOX has been a culprit in the past -- who can forget Ron Silver bellowing "Her father is the district attorney!" all through the baseball playoffs a few years back? -- but TBS' constant promotion of Frank TV during this year's Division Series and NLCS bordered on viewer abuse. Poor Frank Caliendo... I think those three promos of him doing his Al Pacino, George W. Bush, and John Madden impressions are what his vision of hell looks like. It sure wasn't pleasant for the rest of us.

Best way to piss off loyal viewers: Kill off your main character, make her go through limbo and profess that it's the most unique plot ever written, then bring her back to life without any residual damages. Hook up two characters that previously said that they never saw each other "that way." Take your strongest and most likable character and spin her off into a show that makes her look like an indecisive wimp. All of that happened this year with Grey's Anatomy and it's spin-off, Private Practice. Shonda Rhimes was just too in love with her characters this year to realize she was going down a bunch of bad plot roads. From what I've heard, she's fixed some of what she wrought in the 2006-07 season (Izzie and George are broken up, for instance), but I wouldn't know, since I gave up on the show -- one I watched since day one -- last May.

Dishonorable mentions: ESPN's continuing destruction of Monday Night Football; Big Shots; Cavemen's original, racial-joke-laden pilot; the news channels' blanket coverage of Anna Nicole Smith's death; the entry of Sanjaya into my consciousness even though I don't watch American Idol; Larry King asking Jerry Seinfeld if his series was cancelled; Seinfeld's torturous Bee Movie promotion; Michelle Ryan's wooden acting on Bionic Woman; Viva Laughlin (it was so bad I had to mention it again).

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

15 Comments

Filter by:
Caitlin

I'm in Australia, and have been watching Season 4 of The Office over the internet (I promise I will buy the DVDs when they are released, writers). Anyway, I have actually really been enjoying the hour-long episodes. Maybe it's the fact that without ads, the episodes are actually closer to half an hour than an hour, or that they flow better and seem less drawn out. In any case, I think the hour-long episodes have been really funny and entertaining, and I would say Season 4 is my favourite so far. Just my two cents.

On everything else, I agree with you. I bought the complete series of Gilmore Girls from America the other day, and I actually can't bring myself to watch Season 7, because I know it's going to be bad. Should I just skip to the last episode?

January 06 2008 at 8:34 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rebekkah Dirnberger

I also like Life and Pushing Daisies as well as Journeyman. Am so tired of the same story on SVU (used to watch every episode). Am glad to have Medium back but certainly there is room for Life and Journeyman also? Looking forward to new shows this week instead of the dreck that has been on for a few weeks.

January 05 2008 at 8:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ben

Funny - I had the exact opposite reaction to the reduction of The Office from 1 hour to a half hour. I felt like I was missing out. I'd really come to enjoy spending an hour a week with the characters - I guess I don't really need an engaging story to keep my interest. It probably comes down to filler on The Office being better than the best of what many other shows have to offer.

January 05 2008 at 6:08 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Galley

The "Frank TV" promos were relentless!

January 05 2008 at 5:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Nancy

I couldn't agree more about Grey's Anatomy. I have watched that show since day one, but I think season 4 has been a huge disappointment. Frankly, not much as progressed since season 3 and they've added idiotic new characters like Ava and Rose. And, now there is another derek, meredith triangle in the works. The show was so much fun in season 1 & 2, but I'm not sure I can stick with it anymore, esp since the shows creators seem to willfully ignore how fans feel and continue to write storylines that are nonsensical. I truly hope someone can rescue that show.

January 05 2008 at 4:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Scott

I think many people's impressions of the hour-long "Office" episodes is based on their feelings after seeing a half hour of the show. It's simply not a show that can really work well for an hour. It's a delicate mix of humor, most of it understated (the parts that work, anyway). So after 30 minutes, people are inclined to think the rest is less funny. I think those second-half-hour episodes will look much better on their own in syndication, where the viewer is tuning in for a half-hour only.

Hasn't anyone ever sat down with a DVD of their favorite 30-minute sitcom, and watched a number in a row? There's simply no way you're laughing as much on the 2nd or 3rd show as the first one. Some things are better in small quantities. Has anyone ever read a Dave Barry book straight through? There's an example of humor that worked better in small doses once a week than in book form.

January 05 2008 at 3:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
BillS

"Her father is the district attorney!" was a bad one, but House also had "You're risking a patient's life!" I just assumed House would be terrible from that, but I'm glad I recorded them just in case.

January 05 2008 at 1:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Elmouth

The WGA strike sucks, here's why

Just watch this Video :

http://blip.tv/file/489668

And add to this, that this strike costs 33,000 non-WGA jobs and 80 millions per day to the community.

January 05 2008 at 1:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Elmouth's comment
Ed Huang

Blah. that's a terribly ignorant video. It ignores the fact that writers own the copyright to what they write. And that writers, knowing they are usually unemployed are entitled to even higher salaries that the studios were unwilling to pay for up front on projects that could fail. Residuals are NOT bonus pay. Residuals are DEFERRED SALARY because studios don't want pay for something they don't make money on.

Writers are saying, "You came to me hat in hand because you said you couldn't afford the risk of paying me upfront for my work for something that might not work out. But if it does work out, you'll give me a share of the pie. I can't help but notice that you're driving around in a big car, have a big house, and swimming pool, dripping in diamonds because this risk paid off. Where's my piece of pie?"

January 05 2008 at 2:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Borat

Completely agree with Grey's Anatomy. I started watching the show when the strike started and have blown through all episodes of the show really quickly...it's amazing how bad it got worse. I don't think I'll even tune in when the show comes back.

Can't believe what they did to Addison...really loved her. And that "death" episode had me rolling my eyes over and over again.

January 05 2008 at 1:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lucyfan62

Good call on the "Birdhouse in Your Soul" moment from PUSHING DAISIES! I almost fell off the couch when they started singing! Actually, when Kristin Chenowith's character spoke the line "build a little birdhouse in your soul" I got a huge grin on my face. The song was just icing on the already sweet cake! DAISIES is my favorite new show of the year! Can't wait for it to return!!

January 05 2008 at 1:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners