Powered by i.TV
May 20, 2013

Family Guy: McStroke

by Brad Trechak, posted Jan 14th 2008 9:42AM
Family Guy(S06E08) In a mild parody of the movie Super Size Me, Peter suffers a stroke after eating too many fast-food hamburgers. Meanwhile, Stewie becomes the most popular student at James Woods High School, despite being a baby.

Family Guy has such potential to be an original and funny series and so much of it is wasted. I saw hints of really good ideas in the episode but those were superseded by some hack writing and poorly executed material. Another reason to loathe the WGA Strike.

Spoilers after the jump.

To begin, this episode copied The Simpsons plot device of leading into the main story with an unrelated one. That wouldn't be so bad if the plot were good, but it wasn't.

It is interesting how none of the ancillary characters appeared in this episode. There was no Cleveland (although there was a reference to him), no Joe and no Quagmire. There was, however, a talking cow voiced by Ricardo Montalban.

The main plot of Peter suing McBurgerWorld was jumbled. It started with him growing a mustache then did a non sequitur, going to Peter having a stroke from eating thirty hamburgers (he saved the McBurgerWorld manager from a fire. The fire department let him do it because he had a mustache and apparently all firemen have mustaches. Make of that what you will). The plot then turned and Peter sued the McBurgerWorld company after his stroke was magically healed by a stem cell research lab he walks into. Then he had to save a cow from the McBurgerWorld slaughterhouse called Da-cow (very lame Holocaust joke). The whole "A" plot felt like three or four unrelated stories.

(I could make a South Park-inspired manatee joke here, but I'll leave that to you.)

The "B" plot, on the other hand, was decent. They even foreshadowed it with their One Tree Hill parody ("There's nothing that can't be fixed by staring at a lake"). I enjoy a good parody of teen-angst high school television shows. The lines were funny, such as going to Anal Point and the teen girl saying "O.M.G." Even the revenge bit at the end where Stewie has the girl arrested for kissing a baby was funny.

Funny stuff included the Monopoly Man in The Shawshank Redemption, the Wimpy joke, the Will Smith rap, and when Stewie was offered the breasts of the teenage girl with the response "No thanks. I'm stuffed." The lame stuff included the entire mustache storyline, the sudden use of the stem cell lab, the Italian joke, the Robin Williams joke, the horse leg joke and the buff hamster joke. The Monkees-themed chase scene felt weird and out of place.

Overall, other than a few high points, I'd have to say this episode was a downer. The writer's strike could be blamed. Perhaps with Seth McFarlane behind the episode, some stuff could have been made better. I just wish Family Guy more lived up to the quality it had before its cancellation.

Did Family Guy lose quality when it returned from cancellation?
Yes, perhaps Seth McFarlane is working to much with American Dad.282 (35.8%)
No, it's as good as it ever was.506 (64.2%)

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

26 Comments

Filter by:
KDB

Funny episode.

February 09 2008 at 3:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Zombo

Boppity boopity?

C'mon...that stuff KILLS!!!

Get off you high horses everyone...it's not like there's anything else even remotely creative on the air these days (with the possible exception of some late night Cartoon Network stuff).

Seth is a friggin' genius and all you do is critique and complain. Jackasses.

Keep it comin', Family Guy!

Z

January 29 2008 at 1:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
blzbug242

Wow, how come noone ever complains about Ghost Whisperer?

That show's never funny.

...and she's ALWAYS over dressed.

January 20 2008 at 1:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Guy

Gotta disagree about the Monkees bit. I thought it was awesome! And how can anything in a show like this seem "out of place"? I'm thinking that maybe you have to remember watching the Monkees to really appreciate it? You're right about the Will Smith bit though... VERY funny!

January 16 2008 at 11:48 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
victor

Hi. I'm from Brazil and a big fan of this show. To prove I have a blog: familyguydownloads.blogspot.com where I translate to portuguese-BR, making possible to the brazilian people watch this amazing show.
But my english its not so good. Always have about 10 sentences that I dont understant. For example: in the monopoly guy sentences - "And the Sisters ...."
If anyone can contribute for the brazilians fans helping me with a few sentences, I'll be glad!

victorglomer@msn.com

January 15 2008 at 8:49 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
beanspants1

i thought the episode was actually pretty funny. the moustache club was great, and the high school bit just shows that they can attack high school cheesyness from many different angles (peter as grease, stewey as 7th heaven) and still be funny. The boob and "no, thanks, i'm full" -- so all the people who hated this episode didn't laugh at that at all? wow!

also, brian as a moustache and the horrible failure of a court case were clever.

January 14 2008 at 10:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Karen

I'm confused by all these comments about the WGA strike affecting the writing on Family Guy. I thought it had been fairly widely reported--including on this site--that (for reasons I don't fully understand, granted) animated shows' writers do not have to be members of the WGA.

That being said, I laughed a lot at last night's episode, and as someone who watched and loved "The Monkees" as a 9-year-old I found the Monkees parody hilarious.

January 14 2008 at 8:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Michael Cicconi

The poll is a little misleading ... FG is definitely as good as it's ever been (Blue Harvest is a perfect example) but these non-WGA episodes are quite a let-down.

January 14 2008 at 8:03 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Matt

"Family Guy is like that inside joke that gets repeated until it's no longer funny. First two seasons were great at the time. Can't watch them anymore. For every bit of wit the show throws out there it lumps in a dozen bits of random. The randomness gets tedious and tiring."

Exactly. I haven't actually laughed at Family Guy since season three, and didn't crack even a half smirk at last night's episode. The show has become pathetically unfunny, and they should kill it off for good before it completely craps on the good it used to be (see: Season 1 and 2).

January 14 2008 at 4:08 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Teddy

I agree that the idea of a ridiculously age-inappropriate person disguising himself as a high-school student and becoming the coolest kid in class is funny. Almost as funny as when it was done years ago on, um, "Family Guy."

January 14 2008 at 3:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners