Powered by i.TV
May 18, 2013

Project Runway: The Art of Fashion

by Annie Wu, posted Feb 14th 2008 12:24PM
Winning Outfit(S04E11) For the first time since the history of the show, I'm actually quite satisfied with the final group of designers going to Fashion Week. Now, that is not to say that I've changed my mind about how well this season's designers have been doing, because I still feel like it has been one of the worst seasons. However, this time it seems like the final group of designers all truly deserve to be there.

All right, before I get ahead of myself, let's go over just how well everyone did in this challenge. Please excuse me if I fail to fully suppress my pretentious artiness.

This challenge was super-exciting for me as an artist. The designers were sent to explore a few wings of New York's Metropolitan Museum of Art and find inspiration for an outfit from a specific piece of art. I remember the first time I was at the Met, I spent ages in there, in complete awe and just feeling terrible about my own work. Even though none of the designers broke down into tears in a weird Stendhal syndrome moment, it was still nice to see them appreciate these old masterpieces. None of them chose anything particularly bizarre, even though Rami made a bad move and immediately gravitated towards the section with all the Greek statues, aka The Land of Draping Galore.

The special guest judge was -- wait for it -- Roberto Cavalli. No pressure.

Christian: [WINNER] At first I thought Christian was trying to redesign Seinfeld's puffy shirt, but he actually made this old-school military style work very well. As much as I despise Christian's overwhelming ego, I must admit that the kid knows his stuff.

Chris: [ALMOST AUF'D] How dare sleepy cat Chris take a nap in the middle of the final challenge. I mean, seriously, it was like he didn't understand how crucial it was. I did like watching Tim Gunn wake him up, though, because it looked like something out of a bizarre Odd Couple. There's Tim, the neat one with a well-tailored suit, and then Chris, the lazy one with a loud shirt. That would be both the greatest and gayest show ever. Anyway, Chris chose an oil painting of a French noblewoman as his inspiration and he was totally spot-on with the texture. However, the outfit looked so much like his avant-garde collaboration with Christian. If he had exaggerated the bow more, he wouldn't have needed that weird side-collar. Or maybe if he hadn't taken a nap, he wouldn't have been almost Auf'd.

Rami: [ALMOST AUF'D] Okay, okay, so Rami knows how to drape. We all know that. The judges almost sent him home because he didn't deliver anything new. However, in another weird twist, they decided to keep both Chris and Rami. But before they get to start on their collections, they have to make one more piece to see who will get to move on. I'm almost 100% sure that Chris will get to move on, but perhaps Rami will surprise me. He certainly caught me off-guard when he started back-sassing Cavalli. No one back-talks Cavalli! EDIT: According to some comments, I may have gotten the details here wrong. Chris and Rami have to make full collections and then present their best three to the judges? Is that right? I honestly wouldn't be surprised if I got the details wrong because my mother called me up just as this happened to share her glee over the fact that Sweet P is finally out. She wasn't a fan.

Sweet P: [AUF'D] Sweet P can be cute, but, I'm sorry, she's overstayed her welcome by many, many episodes. He dress was too simple and I didn't see how it related to her piece of artwork. I saw absolutely no "peacock"-esque qualities, as It looked more like a half-assed tribute to Klimt than anything else. Sorry, Sweet P, but it looks like we're not going to get any more of your social awkwardness.

Jillian: Fierce! I absolutely love Jillian's coats. I suppose gold-lovers would have loved the inside dress, but I'm a coat-girl myself. Jillian obviously knows her silhouettes very well and I hope that we get to see more of this kind of stuff in her Fashion Week collection. Yes, I know pictures are online, but I've decided not to spoil myself this year.

Who should present at Fashion Week?
Chris226 (78.5%)
Rami62 (21.5%)

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

7 Comments

Filter by:
BOOMERCHIK

I agree that Christian has quite an attitude, but I have to love his style. A grown man who is willing to fling himself to the floor and into a fetal position when it gets to be too much for him is pretty funny to watch. Being his friend would be an interesting experience most likely filled with brutal honesty.

Jillian makes BEAUTIFUL jackets and I truly hope that this is where her main emphasis will be when we see her collection.

I actually hope that it is Chris that makes it since Rami is just boring. However, I could probably be happy just seeing Christian and Jillian at the end.

February 14 2008 at 7:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Europa

"Before it was three designers with the 4th as a decoy since the runway show takes place before the airing of the season."

That's what I meant too. I know only three will actually be competing but four show anyway to throw off the audience. That's why the little competition between Rami and Chris seems a bit mute to me especially since they basically tied anyway according to Heidi. I guess I just want to get on with it. LOL. Just show the freak'n clothes already and the drama each designer goes through making their collection. (And no, I don't want to scrounge around on the Internet looking at the results. I want to see it on my television. Old school style.) :-D

And I can't believe I was the first person to post - and on the day after! *That* never happens. This show really must be loosing some of it's fans.

February 14 2008 at 5:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Liz

Rami should have been out...he is a one trick pony and his dress was boring. Sweet P's dress was ugly and didn't look like a peacock at all. She should have made a long shimmery dark blue gown (with maybe some green) with a long feathery train... now that would wow the judges!

February 14 2008 at 5:18 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sarah

yes, the comments are right. they have to make an entire collection and show their three best pieces to vie for the third Bryant Park spot.

i rather liked Sweet P's dress, but in terms of the challenge, she missed the mark completely. poor thing, she was so out of her league.

February 14 2008 at 3:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Akbar Fazil

Only last season did they send 4 designers to the final show, as competitors. Before it was three designers with the 4th as a decoy since the runway show takes place before the airing of the season.

Since Annie wants to be surprised I wont say who goes to the show. But it will be interesting to see who the decoy is.

February 14 2008 at 1:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
B

I thought they both have to make their collections and then show their best 3 pieces. Then the judges would decide which one would actually get to show. Or did I just hear it wrong? This is a new thing they're doing.

February 14 2008 at 1:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Europa

"But before they get to start on their collections, they have to make one more piece to see who will get to move on. "

Did I misunderstand or did Heidi say that Chris and Rami would have to create their *full collections,* (just like Christian and Jillian) and show the judges their *best three* outfits to see who gets to move on? And since they usually have the top four show their collections anyway, it's sort of a semi mute point. Both Chris and Rami will get to show.

February 14 2008 at 1:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners