I was just thinking--an eye for an eye. What that means in relation to the different characters is something I have to ponder further, though!

Maybe Bill is the last cylon? I still think it's Roslin, for no other reason than that I want her to live. Or resurrect. Either one is fine with me.

Speaking of the right eye - anyone remember the scene in the very first episode (miniseries): In the midst of the initial Cylon attack and at the very moment the Galactica is getting word of it, Col. Tigh (a Cylon) is in his cabin looking at a photo of his wife - and he burns a hole in her picture right where her right eye is. The burn first creates a bubble, and then her right eye is replaced by a glowing red ring of ember, not unlike the Eye of Jupiter mandala Starbuck painted. Here's a screen-capture of the photo just before the hole burned through:

http://media.battlestarwiki.org/images/8/8f/Miniseries_Ellen.jpg

Hmm. What color are Anders's eyes? And Tigh's (err... "eye")? "And the caravan of the heavens was watched over by a great lion with a mighty blinking eye, red and blue" The scriptures are supposed to be polyvalent, right? Perhaps the "different" cylons are to protect the fleet after all?

Well, Saul went from persecuting the jews to being the Apostle Paul.

So Saul Tigh goes from persecuting the Cylons to being one of the four "fundementally different" Cylons...

who will he "serve"?
I'm kind of digging the theory that the Galactica herself is the final Cylon.

you're absolutely correct. I meant to say Damascus. ( I just didn't know we could cuss on this board...hee)

Drat. He says all we have to do is watch it over in slow motion, and it's all laid out.

Now I'm counting red lights on dash boards, and bald pates. I will probably have full blown OCD by the time Friday rolls around. Thanks Mr. Weddle. :)

Maybe I'm reaching, but in Adama's glasses I see the reflection of the board behind Tigh. With the hole that bullet left, I think his eye looks like the Eye of Jupiter.

Here are some screen shots:
http://redlightnaps.wordpress.com/2008/04/08/bsg-4-he-who-believeth-in-me/

They also like leading fans in the wrong direction.

And Tigh was made a Cylon after he lost his eye. When Tigh was tortured they didn't know he would be one of the four.

There's a good chance David Weddle was joking, but if he is it reeks of fan mockery. As in, I don't think it's obvious enough that he's joking. So, instead, he's trying to throw fans into a tailspin by telling us to look at something that's not there.

Look, I know I like to over-analyze this show much like many do for 'Lost', but it's fun. If he's frakking with us, then it's just plain mean.