great episode! Didn't disappoint me! Bree's facial expressions are priceless!

I have thought from the very beginning that Dylan isn't the real Dylan

i have always thought that the "present dylan" is a kidnap child and the real one is dead (and that she died in her old room, because of her dad), later katherine hit the dad (we don´t know if he is really dead, i'm betting that he is just in hidding), and the corpes buried in the back yard is Dylan I (she wouldn't be criying for the death of her violent ex husbend).

Gaby and carlos... should have died in the tornado... and burn in hell!!! LOL

I didn't see any spoilers before I saw this show and I was bored bored bored. I too thought the Lynette thing was a small part, brought out to be a major part in the show. I thought it was kind of pointless and oh so stupid when they were in church and she started raising her hand asking questions. What?

Also they spent alllll this money on the tornado for one epi? I thought this was a flash forward or flash back when I saw it. Only a couple of dumpsters were there. Everything else was so clean and nice.

I think most of the story lines are blah. They need new people or new stories.

I have one more question for your list. There is a huge gouge in the wooden floor of the upstairs bedroom. The room that "Dylan" (or Dylan II) used to stay in. That should represent something big because many characters touched it and were moved by it being there.

This show has jumped its shark. It used to be quirky, fun, twisted and twisty. Now its just blah, stupid, and silly. I think they have lost me on this.

was this a review of last nights desperate housewives or a commercial for the "spoilers anonymous blog" on this website??

I think your expectations for this episode were a little high. Did you really expect to get lots of answers to the seasons biggest questions in the first episode back? If that were the case they would only need one or two episodes to close the season and not the batch they have, the answers will come, just not all at once, geez, have some patience.

Also, Katherine hit her ex with a candlestick not a chandelier.

I thought this episode was a good one back. I really like Lynette and thought her crisis of faith was something very real, I actually wish they had explored it a bit further.

I'm sure we'll get more answers in the upcoming episodes, just try and be patient and let the creators tell their story, it's been pretty damn good this season.

maybe you shouldnt read spoilers if it is going to affect your viewing the show. this was a good restart in my opinion, and since i wasnt tainted with spoilers, i was able to see the Lynette storyline to be very touching and understandable. keep that in mind, next time you are tempted to read spoilers. and, if you read so much ahead, you should know that Katherine hit and killed her husband with a CANDLESTICK, not a chandelier.

children are very impressionable and will believe just about anything you tell them. i think Dylan is the real Dylan, but she doesnt remember anything because her mother moved her away and probably told her that her memories were dreams, just like Dylan said in the episode about her dreams feeling so real. the same thing happened with Zach Young.

and where was the gay couple?

Edy is leaving the show. It was on my local news last week. I like the theory that DYLAN is not Dylan. Maybe she's adopted, one of those under the radar ones. Maybe Dad accidently killed the child, (buried out back) and then got his with the candle holder. (shades of CLUE!) And kids change a lot, so if you haven't seen a kid in years, of course it will look different. And, as much as I like Carlos, I am rather sick of Gaby.

I used to really like DH, but I just found it hard to enjoy about midway thru season 2. I have kind of kept up on the storyline, but just by reading reviews. Maybe I'll pick it up in syndication someday. Part of my dislike is the Gaby/ Carlos story. They should have just stayed apart. One thing I'm puzzled about, though, is why she was putting furniture in his way so he'd fall? What caused that/ It seems especially cruel, even for her.

Gaby is my favorate character, I don't think she is the one who are moving out. Athough there are some kinds of hints, but considering her former career--as a excellent model, she is more likely to get involved with another mysterious guy, who would probaly take some fresh air to the story.