Powered by i.TV
September 1, 2014

MythBusters fans want to bust the E-reader

by Keith McDuffee, posted Apr 18th 2008 1:20PM
e-meterSomething tells me this isn't going to happen, but you can be sure plenty of us would tune in if it did.

Over on Discovery's MythBusters forums -- where fans regularly congregate to discuss previous episodes, disagree with Adam and Jamie's conclusions and offer suggestions for future myth-busting -- someone has made the suggestion that the MB's take on the task of not only obtaining but also fully testing the capabilities of one of Scientology's most exclusive devices: the E-meter.

If you go by what Wikipedia tells you, the E-meter measures the "'mental mass and energy' of the subject's mind." What the Church of Scientology does with the information from the reading, you can either go by what's released already in the wilds of the interweb or, if you're a Scientologist yourself, you probably already know.

While a bunch of folks on the forum and over on Digg think this is a great idea for MythBusters, I can't quite figure out what the heck they'd do to disprove anything it supposedly does, no matter how ludicrous it seems to some. Is there really some way to concretely disprove or even prove something like this?

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

21 Comments

Filter by:
Anonymous

L Ron and his mindless clones vs Adam and Jaimie

A recipe for pure hilarity!

The truth is a scientologys achilles heel.

April 19 2008 at 6:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bill

Scientology is a religion just like Christianity or any other religion, except you have to pay as you go; there are RTF slave labor camps; Critics are harassed and occasionally "vanished"; members are told their lives are meaningless because they will be reborn; there is absolutely no room given to interpretation; Interfaith association is frowned upon or forbidden; families are broken up; abortions are mandatory to stay in in some cases; "excommunication" for no real reason is common; familial murder; rampant extortion; faulty medical advice is mandatory; the unalterable source text is being altered; government infiltration; attempted coups; extortion and attempts to exert influence on governments; and hundreds of other things.

Other than that, it's virtually identical to any other religion.

April 19 2008 at 7:04 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
DG

All this talk about religious persecution is utter nonsense. If science wants to look at the e-meter, it can do so. We are allowed to take a critical eye at ANY claim. This isn't persecution, it's freedom of thought and belief. Persecution is when we tell other people they're not allowed to believe something, which is worlds apart from critical examination. Trying to claim "persecution" as a defence to criticism is, in fact, persecution itself: since you're trying to tell people they're not allowed to form opinions.

Religion often critiques the fundamental tenets of science. They don't seem to feel any shame in doing so. Why should science feel shame when they invoke turnabout as fair play?

April 18 2008 at 11:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
MERVE-THE-PERVE

I don't know diddly shit about Scientology, but it sounds like they could make it into a pretty good sci-fi show if done right. Nothing inaccurate or mocking or anything, just based on regular happenings of your average Scientologist. It could be interesting.

April 18 2008 at 7:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Joel

Wouldn't it be brilliant if they could once and for all prove the utter lack of existence of a "god"?

I don't begrudge people for their religious beliefs and i'm an athiest. To each his own. But wouldn't it be great to see their faces if they were to Mythbust "god". lol. sorry, i'm not trying to offend, i just had this thought and had to type it out.

April 18 2008 at 5:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tim

I think they should prove/disprove the existence of God. Religious mythbusting is not only difficult, but dangerous - even if the 'religion' is Scientology.

April 18 2008 at 3:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jables

Wouldn't they just dis-assemble the parts and analyze the inner workings to determine what the E-Meter does, if anything?

April 18 2008 at 3:22 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Jables's comment
jonathan

yea thats what i thought too jables. yo peeps, no need to get angry, seriously.

April 18 2008 at 3:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Franklin

Oh you self-righteous religious nuts! Can't you see how your ability to forgive others and believe that there is a higher power than we human beings doesn't even begin to compare with the smug superiority and total intolerance of these mentally superior atheists? Haven't
you learned a thing from their ridicule of your beliefs?

Anyone with half a brain can easily see why being an athiest and a socialist is the way to go. I mean, they never look down on the beliefs of others, they're quick to forgive and they understand that diversity is a part of life!

At least that's what they want you to believe, but it only takes a few words from their narrow minds to belie their true nature.

Rick's a notoriously narrow-minded California Commie who cannot stand to be in the presence of anyone different from himself. And when he finds himself in that situation, like right now, he attacks without much intelligence. Bash is from one of the many countries whose ass we've saved, so it's understandable why he'd have animosity towards anything different. He may not be a member of the Nazi party, but he's just as
intolerant.

They are, in a word, "Hypocrites". They talk about how silly religion is and how intolerant they think religious people are while being worse in those very regards than anyone their ignorant fears have them believe exist. They believe one way and hate anyone who believes differently, but of course *ALL* religious people are like that, not them!

They are ignorant and fear the unknown, exactly like ancient man. I wonder if they, too, live in caves?

April 18 2008 at 3:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
BillS

I'm not a scientologist. I think e-meters are bunk. However, what's the point? There are three categories of people when it comes to e-meters: people who believe in them, people who don't believe in them, and people who have never heard of them.

Scientology has gadgets and part of the word "science" in its name, but their beliefs include the supernatural. Some alien soul in volcano thing, if that South Park is to be believed. The scientific method ignores the supernatural. If you believe in an all-powerful God, it might be God's will that makes the apple fall from the tree, and gravity is bunk. Since you can never disprove the supernatural, science just ignores it.

So what scientific value is there in looking at a device that measures... whatever it is that it's supposed to measure? None. You'll be preaching to the choir for people who already don't believe in e-meters, you'll be ignored by those who do believe in them, and otherwise you'll be saying "hey, this thing you've never heard of? it doesn't work." Exciting television.

April 18 2008 at 2:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
FLUNK

cokely, if only it were that simple.

you equate the humanity of 5000 years ago to todays, vastly interconnected and increasingly vocal global community. we are not a crowd of club-weilding heathens, nor a stadium full of screaming blood-thirsty romans. we have evolved, some of us, at least, and when we see injustices being perpetrated upon our fellow man, we want to speak up. when a large (tax-exempt, at that) corporation is abusing its employees and harrassing its critics, cowing even youtube and amazon into censorship...something has to be done.

sure, there are "worse" things going on in the world...but if we do our best to stop scientology from gaining the power it so deeply craves, we might be able to avert political/economical/(and even) spiritual disaster.

April 18 2008 at 2:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners