Powered by i.TV
May 24, 2013

My visit to Costas NOW

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Apr 30th 2008 4:40PM

CostasNOW

Anyone catch the live broadcast of Costas NOW last night? I was lucky enough to get a few tickets and went to the live taping in Manhattan with my girlfriend. And I really do mean lucky. Not only did we get seated in the front row, but we were seated right in front of all the panelists. Everyone. Joe Buck, Cris Carter, Mitch Albom, Mike Tirico, Michael Wilbon, John McEnroe... the list goes on. And of course, Bob Costas was only a few feet in front of us on stage. For a sports and TV fanatic, it was very impressive. So why am I writing about it? The town hall format of the show covered a lot of hot topics in sports, but there were a couple segments that really stood out because they directly relate to what we're doing here at TV Squad -- blogging and athletes' (or in our case TV celebs, writers, and producers) reactions to the media.

The general consensus? Blogging is ruining the journalistic landscape. Mitch Albom said it was evening out the playing field because anyone, especially those that are not even remotely qualified to comment, can do it. He's right though. Look at me. Ten years ago I would have never been afforded the opportunity to rant about TV the way I do. Sure, I've worked for a few TV shows and consider myself fairly knowledgeable about television, but I'm in no way an authority. I can't walk into Variety or The New York Times and expect to be offered a critic's position - I've got no legit journalistic credentials like a Masters or newspaper experience. To me, that's the beauty of it though.

Albom, Buzz Bissinger, and most of the other panelists felt differently, that blogging erodes the quality and alienates those individuals that are being written about because, more often than not, negativity reigns. So as I was watching and processing all of this, I couldn't help but to think about TV Squad ... and how I was going to blog about it. It's a satisfying feeling, to know that I could do that and quickly voice my opinion. It seemed to me that many of the journalists (whom I obviously respect greatly) felt miffed that it's so easy to get yourself "published" now; like bloggers such as myself have taken a giant short-cut. It was just really interesting to me because it's the first time I've been in a situation where I was being told that blogging is wrong; that blogging is dumbing down the population. But to hear it from writers and sportscasters that as I said, I respect, is what made it powerful. Then I realized that I could say things like Bob Costas looks way older in person or Cris Carter was wearing a ton of cologne and feel confident that none of them were going to read it anyway!

The great thing about what we're doing, and was missed in the show, was that even though blogging is quick and immediate, so is the response. On our site, Joel has frequently engaged with TV writer Ken Levine and I can recall another instance where we got some great praise from one of the producers from NCIS. People in the industry read us. To make the ultimate sports connection here, a few days ago we were linked to by Bill Simmons in one of his ESPN Page 2 posts!

Alright, enough with that. I've spoken my part. Back to the show itself. Actually, let's talk about the set. I really wish I could have taken a few photos, but they were pretty strict with the no-pictures policy. I saw a few people get slaps on the wrist for trying to sneak out their camera phones so I wasn't going to risk pulling out my girlfriend's digital camera and possibly get ejected. There were huge monitors everywhere with the Costas NOW logo and lots of big, transparent posters with all the big names in sports - Kobe, A-Rod, Peyton Manning, etc. It was really cool looking in-person.

The one thing they were supposed to do was take questions from the audience, but that never happened. But I can understand why - with five separate panels, 90 minutes just wasn't enough time. Costas did mention that one of the panels - sports and race - would be brought back later in the year as its own Costas NOW installment.

Some random observations ... I haven't watched it off my DVR yet, so most of this is from memory:

  • McEnroe had on a ridiculous tie that I'm sure the director hated. It was all black with what looked to be a bedazzled rose in the middle of it. It kept sparkling under the stage lights and I'm sure it was disorienting to look at.
  • Did anyone else notice that Buzz Bissinger kept stroking, I mean really rubbing, his thigh?
  • Dan Patrick is a giant in person. Very tall man.

So for anyone that watched this from home, what did everyone think? I'm curious to hear what everyone has to say about the comments about blogging. You're reading this, so that's a good start.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

6 Comments

Filter by:
Jeremy

Was this a one-time-deal, or will they be taping this series up there regularly?!

Have always been a fan of Michael Wilbon's, hailing from DC and all...and the Tirico show on espn radio is a daily-fix for me.

That sounds like a great panel you got to witness.


May 11 2008 at 6:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jonny Rice

Jonathan, did they show the pre-taped segment before the live panel with Bissinger and Leitch? If so, how could you not mention the (quickie) appearance by Mike Schur, aka Mose Schrute, aka Ken Tremendous?

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1321658/
http://deadspin.com/385770/bissinger-vs-leitch
http://www.firejoemorgan.com/2008/04/few-words-on-internet.html

Guy's a blogger AND a TV writer. Where's the TV Squad love? The third link is his review of the Bissinger/Leitch brouhaha. Good stuff on blogging.

April 30 2008 at 10:58 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

I really enjoyed last night's episode. I disagree that Buzz came off badly. I think he came off as an honestly disgruntled lifelong newspaperman.

I guffawed when Joe Buck called himself "BallsDeep"

You could tell Tirico *really* wanted to take advantage of being on HBO so he could get all Al Swearangen on us, even though in the end he didn't swear once.

Costas's line about "stay tuned for G-String Divas and Cathouse" was hilarious, more so by the fact that HBO scheduled "Cathouse" for immediately afterwards.

The show was, all-in-all, quite good. The last segment was too rushed, but c'est la vie.

April 30 2008 at 6:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to David's comment
johnperson

David, I completely disagree about Buzz. I had never heard of the guy until yesterday (I saw the Friday Night Lights movie, but didn't know it was based on his book) and I thought he completely embarrassed himself. You can be honestly disgruntled about anything, but that doesn't mean you can completely and rudely cut off a person and say, for absolutely no reason, that they, their body of work and everything they stand for has no merit, and that they are full of s hit. Also, it doesn't help that he bashed blogs and their commenters for being profane when Bissinger was way more foul-mouthed than almost any other post I would see any day on Deadspin or Fire Joe Morgan. So what does that mean? That blogs are too profane? Is the printed word so sacred that only the classically trained wordsmith can talk about how the Tigers should have put in Bobby Seay to face Grady Sizemore? Or that a certain part of The Office really advanced the storyline? Sportswrting, episode reviews, gossip magazines...all of these are by and large subjective and opinion-based topics. And what Buzz said last night was what artists were saying during the German literary Enlightenment from the late 1600's to the middle 1700's: that there should be rules for aesthetics and that certain steps and schooling are needed in order to create writing that they deemed 'beautiful'. Buzz, we're not talking about philosophy or poetry. We're talking about sports. I was hoping that this would be an open exchange of ideas, but damn. Poor Will Leitch. He might as well have been standing blindfolded in front of a brick wall with a cigarette in his mouth.

April 30 2008 at 11:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Justin

How did you put up with listening to Joe Buck for so long? If his father wasn't a legend in the business and his last name didn't carry such weight, I can't imagine he'd have much of a job in sports. His insight is horrific and his announcing is terrible.

That out of the way, the rest of that panel sounds great as does the show. I have it set to tape later this week when it re-airs.

April 30 2008 at 5:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Frank

Buzz Bissinger came off like an enormous jerk. He has some interesting points, in that blogs do produce a lot more garbage writing (misstated facts, inaccuracies, hopelessly biased opinion), but I think he went WAAAAY overboard in his thing with the Deadspin guy.

Basically, I think you have to treat blogs as a different medium than "real" journalism. It's much more raw and you have to work around that fact to find the gems that it creates. You have to accept that a lot of things will be somewhat ignorant or ill-informed and that ALOT of it will not cater to your interests.

You just filter out those things and find the few bits of new, innovative and interesting writing that's out there.

April 30 2008 at 5:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners