Powered by i.TV
July 28, 2014

My reactions to the Emmy nominations, part two

by Allison Waldman, posted Jul 18th 2008 9:03AM
Emmy goldEarlier today I did a first take on the Primetime Emmy nominations, sharing with you my first impressions and noting a few surprises. Now, I'm going to finish what I started. Please, share your comments and your opinions about the nominations.


Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series - This would seem to be Mad Men's to lose. The pilot was very strong, but they're competing with themselves in this category, with "The Wheel" also nominated. The Wire winning would be a shock, but not as much as Battlestar Galactica which -- hallelujah -- finally got some well-deserved attention. Damages pilot was a stunner, too. Anyway you cut it, this is a damn good set of scripts.

Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series - Two 30 Rocks, including "Cooter" which I thought sucked! Pushing Daisies and Flight of the Conchords are wonderful new blood for this category. I'm going out on a limb and declaring that The Office will win for "Dinner Party." That episode was like Edward Albee's Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, a Tony and Oscar winner.

Outstanding Variety, Music or Comedy Special - Can Kathy Griffin in concert, Straight to Hell, beat Bill Maher, George Carlin, or Don Rickles specials? The Kennedy Centers Honors and/or James Taylor (Great Performances) are a surer bet, but because of his untimely death, I think George Carlin should win a post-humous award.

Outstanding Reality Program - Okay, here Kathy Griffin, My Life on the D List, has a shot. Her toughest competition, though, may be Dirty Jobs, more than Extreme Makeover Home Edition, Intervention or Antiques Roadshow (seriously??). Of course, seeing how much Kathy shows off her Emmy now, NATAS may want to give her another. She's great publicity for the award show! But what could she say if she wins might frighten the voters.

Outstanding Nonfiction Special (this is different from reality and competition, apparently) - AFI 100 Years, Alive Day Memories: Home from Iraq, Autism: The Musical, Pioneers of Television: Late Night, The Pixar Story. I'm tempted to say Pixar because they seem to have the Midas touch (hello, WALL-E!), but of all these shows, I liked Pioneers of Television best; it was superb.

Outstanding Nonfiction Series (again, different from the one above) - American Masters, Biography, Inside the Actors Studio...all somewhat similar. Deadliest Catch is not. This American Life has major buzz, but I'm thinking Deadliest Catch, even if they doctored some footage.

Outstanding Lead Actress in a Miniseries - Laura Linney should have this in hand for John Adams, but Dame Judi Dench in Cranford is an award-hawk (deservedly so). The others are fine actresses in great roles, but it's a two person race in my estimation.

Outstanding Lead Actor in a Miniseries - By all rights, Paul Giamatti -- like Laura Linney -- should have this sewn up for John Adams. However, the actor competition is formidible, Kevin Spacey and Tom Wilkinson for Recount, Ralph Fiennes for Bernard and Doris, and Ricky Gervais for Extras: The Series Finale movie. Ricky was really brilliant as Andy Millman, especially in this film.

Outstanding Guest Actor in a Drama Series - How is Stanley Tucci nominated for ER? Wasn't he a regular? Robin Williams got mucho media for Law & Order: SVU, but the winner here will be Robert Morse from Mad Men. All those scenes in stocking feet were great!

Need more Emmys scoop? Get reactions to the biggest Emmys snubs and surprises and see which celebrities sparkled on the Emmys red carpet last year.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

3 Comments

Filter by:
lilly

I feel it noteworthy that one of the most riveting ,most thought provoking movies was (raisin in the sun) and not even a mention???

July 21 2008 at 2:01 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
C C

30 Rock is going to win the comedy writing Emmy for "Rosemary's Baby"-put money on it.

July 18 2008 at 11:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
SirCrumpet

I would LOVE for The Conchords to win Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series.

July 18 2008 at 9:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners