Powered by i.TV
February 11, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Grey's Anatomy: Dream a Little Dream of Me, Parts 1 & 2 (season premiere)

by Jonathan Toomey, posted Sep 26th 2008 8:13AM

Patrick Dempsey and Ellen Pompeo
(S05E01/S05E02) "The person that invented the phrase 'happily ever after' should have his ass kicked so hard." - Meredith

Another September, another Grey's Anatomy season premiere. Hard to believe that we're already into a fifth season. But you know what isn't hard to believe? That we're still dealing with the same "Meredith and Derek - will they or won't they" mess. Grey's has reached the point that regardless of what happens, I'm going to keep watching it because I've invested too much of my time to walk away now. I really am a fan of the show, which is why I don't feel bad when I say that this was quite possibly the most ridiculous season premiere ever. It was all over the place like some strange metaphor for all the ups and downs Mer and Der have had over the years. A random army doctor, two limousine accidents, ninja attack icicles... and god, the cherry on top - Denny Duquette. Really?

The episode picked up fairly soon after last season's finale - I'm guessing no more than a day or two elapsed. So Meredith's "candle house plan" (I'm sure Smokey The Bear loved that) did the trick, Derek ended things with Rose, and TV's favorite couple that's never a couple is now a couple again. Honestly, it's what we've come to expect from them. I will say that I'm glad that it appears they're going to make bigger steps forward this season. Derek half-seriously asked Meredith to marry him and he's even getting rid of the Airstream and moving in with her.

The one thing that really surprised me about the whole situation was how much Meredith actually weights her decisions on what Cristina thinks. Yang is a train wreck! Why would Meredith care what she thinks, friend or not? However, now that Mer has realized that she has some sort of inner fear of actually getting the happy ending (she keeps dreaming of Derek dying), I suppose it's worth getting a second opinion. It'll be interesting to see them living together though.

OK, back to the overarching plot. Early on we found out that Seattle Grace dropped significantly in the "top teaching hospitals" rankings to number 12 in the country. Webber is pissed, he put the whole hospital on notice, and after chastising his staff for knowing nothing, he challenged them to become better doctors and teachers. I think we may be seeing a more bad-ass side of Richard this season. He's angry about the hospital and he's angry about Adele still. Everything he touches seems to fall apart. I thought it was ridiculous that he blamed (or at least insinuated) that his going soft was correlated to having Ellis' daughter (Meredith) working with him. Very cowardly tactic, especially for him.

The case du jour (and yes, it was the same one for the full two hours) focused on three husbands and three wives, who were in two different limousine crashes. The story itself was fairly uneventful. There were some adultery secrets, one woman got some sort of brain-resetting amnesia, one guy died, one severed his vocal cords, and another got the same surgery (therapeutic hypothermia) that Buffalo Bill Kevin Everett received. That was one of the better threads because Callie spearheaded it when Derek said it was a bad idea. It allowed us to see the tension that had grown between her and Hahn since the big smooch. By the end of the ep, it got awfully awkward though and for a moment felt like scene from Curb Your Enthusiasm with the"you're the only girl I want to kiss" line. We found out that Callie is Hahn's first too - so they're both just bi-curious. OK then.

Back to the freezing surgery though. Let's talk about who suggested it. Major Owen Hunt (Kevin McKidd), a US Army trauma surgeon. He was involved in the husband's limo crash and triaged them at the crash site. So he made it back to the hospital and quickly became a love interest for Cristina. She helped staple his leg and he removed the icicle from her stomach. Oh right... that happened. Fell from the roof and stabbed her in the gut. This is what I meant earlier when I said ridiculous.

As you'd expect, they randomly locked lips at the end and Webber offered Hunt a job. Call me crazy, but maybe Seattle Grace is #12 because Webber offers jobs to nomadic Army surgeons who wander in off the street and operate on "his patients" with no one really stopping him. I know how to build computers, but something tells me if I hopped behind the Geek Squad counter at a Best Buy and started tinkering with someone's hard drive, I'd get noticed.

Bailey had the least to do in this episode. There was no mention of her home life and Tucker, she no longer has the clinic to worry about, and Webber (in his zeal to be "better") took over her one case. The only shining moment was when she had Karev change a clock in the OR so that one of the limo survivors who had expired health insurance would still be covered.

It was a noble thing to do, but it should be noted that she only did it because she was pushed/guilted into it by Karev. As Izzie said, he really is a good guy. I think it's safe to assume they're going to end up together (again), but not until Alex becomes comfortable with shedding his asshole costume. After everything that happened with Ava (nuts!), that might take some time. So it was no surprise that by the end of the episode, he went home with some nondescript brunette. Izzie saw him, and defeated, she began to fantasize about Denny. Ugh. She still isn't past him. That is creepy.

The highlight of the episode for me was definitely listening to Sloan berate George. I'm sorry, but he's funny. Jerk, yes - but funny too. He called him a "special moron!" The whole Lexie wants George plot feels forced to me though. At this point, with Ellis dead and Thatcher swimming in whiskey, the point of Lexie being around is lost. The same sort of goes for George too. His failing the intern exam the first time around threw him into this weird limbo and hooking up with Lexie is all that really makes any sense right now. Well... it make more sense that him hooking up with Izzie at least.

Oh and how could I forget Rose? First off, remember that big promo? The one where she told Derek she's pregnant? Bogus! Turns out she was just being a bitch! See, this I don't really get either. I liked her last season, a lot. Partially because she wasn't Meredith, but regardless - I liked her. You knew it wasn't going to last but it never struck me that she was the "bitchy ex-girlfriend" type. This felt forced too, as if we're meant to hate her now and I sort of do. I mean, she did hand Derek a scalpel blade first. However, no worries because she transferred to pediatrics. Goodbye Rose.

A few more thoughts...

  • I love that Yang killed a guy. That line Hahn hit her with was gold. The one about how she lacks general surgery knowledge because she spends too much time on cardio-thoracic stuff. She's not as good as she thinks.
  • What the hell was with that dream Yang had? Her and Meredith old? My interpretation? She told Mer that it wouldn't work with Derek because she has no one and she selfishly needs someone to grow old with. Then Hunt entered the picture...
  • I hated the whole "Mercy West is getting all the good patients" thing at the beginning because of the new, lower ranking. "Guess we'll just stand here and wait." "Oh look, a limo with no windshield is barreling towards us!" It was just so obnoxiously predictable and worst of all, it's been done before.

Overall, just not that great. The ridiculous moments (the icicle, Denny, Hunt smooching Yang, Yang's grandma dream) coupled with the forced behaviors from Rose, Lexie, and George just really killed any momentum this episode might have had. The scary thought? Did you see the previews for the new episode in two weeks? It looked like a bathtub fell through the ceiling into the OR. Oh no.

Who's your favorite couple from this episode?
Mer and Der273 (20.7%)
Yang and Hunt654 (49.5%)
George and Lexie87 (6.6%)
Old Meredith and Old Yang119 (9.0%)
Izzie and (Dead) Denny149 (11.3%)
Karev and The I Miss Ava Brunette40 (3.0%)

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

28 Comments

Filter by:
mnm

HAHA!!!! @ ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO HAVE SAID THAT THEY HAD WATCHED THE SHOW BEFORE BUT THEN STOPPED BECAUSE OF THE LACK OF MORALS.....

---->IF YOU STOPPED WATCHING THE SHOW, THEN WHY THE HECK ARE YOU EVEN TAKING THE TIME TO BE ON TV SQUAD READING ABOUT GREY'S ANATOMY, READING PEOPLE'S POST, AND RESPONDING.!?!????? !

(it seems as if the only thing more ridiculous than some GA's last episode is you)

If you think that you just might be better off not watching t.v. anymore,.... then maybe you might want to disconnect your internet service too! *Snicker* hehe!

October 01 2008 at 11:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
JC

I was disappointed in last season and wanted to give Grey's another shot. It is not entertaining watching a bunch of neurotic selfish idiots talking a million miles a minute about their so call traumatic existence. And I felt like I was watching a repeat with Meredith's should I or shouldn't I be with Derek. I can barely stand to look at her. What happened to the characters we fell in love with in Season 1. I miss them.

September 28 2008 at 1:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Melonie

OMG, I absolutely loved your review! Not only do I fully agree with everything you said about the plot of the episode, I love the points you made about a few of the characters feeling so forced. But like you, I have been watching it too long to stop now. I guess the best thing we can do is sit back and expect a lot of repetition.

September 28 2008 at 1:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Alvira Khan

Great synopsis of the season premiere! It will be interesting to see what unfolds with Mer and Der and I hope that their dream house will finally get built.

Alvira Khan
Florida Atlantic University
FAU Boca Raton Alumna
http://www.alvirakhan.com

September 27 2008 at 7:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Sean

Did anyone else notice 2 bits were borrowed from MASH? The pen as a trach was done by Fr. Mulcahy I believe and the clock turned back was done by Hawkeye so the deceased's kids wouldn't equate Christmas with the day their father died.

September 27 2008 at 1:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
nattyff

Is just me or mer look like crap in these espisode???
And the episode itsel was really crappy....

September 27 2008 at 5:16 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bruce

White atheist. Who gives a crap? I hate Mel Gibson, but respect him as an artist and still like and watch his movies (he can burn jews in his home oven, it won't make Braveheart a bad movie). Ironically, "Christians" are presumably supposed to hate torture and murder, yet they absolutely loved Mel's Passion of the Christ, which I saw and which was nothing more than a sick torture/snuff film. I have never heard a self-professed Christian say "I do not approve of torture and murder so I will not watch Passion of the Christ." They should, but they don't. Hell, these are people who wear a mini torture/murder device around their necks. Who the hell are any of them to decide something is sinful and not worth watching anymore?

I promise you, you won't catch Gayness from watching Grey's Anatomy. If you're watching it, you very well may already be gay, but I like it and I'm not. Nor have I become gay at any time during the past 5 seasons, including after last night's premiere. At least, I did not wake up this morning dreaming of cock nor do I see it happening.

September 26 2008 at 4:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
adela.t4

Upon the insistence of my friend Claire, I decided to watch the season premiere of Grey's last night in the hopes that the crappiness of last season could be attributed only to the writer's strike and not to the fact that the show has completely and irreversibly jumped the shark.

After last night's episode, I'm still not sure what I think.

The first half of the episode was entirely lame, but I think the latter half somewhat made up for it. (Only somewhat, though.) The episode definitely did not need to be two hours long; they probably could have pulled a Fringe and premiered it in 1.5 hours instead.

The episode opens up with this entirely lame dream sequence where Derek gets into a car accident and dies with Meredith screaming and crying and pounding on the window as though that's going to help somehow. The audience is supposed to believe that this is actually occurring, and the dramatic swelling of music accompanied by Meredith's screeching really didn't make me sympathetic for her at all -- it actually just made me want to push the mute button.

Thankfully, this sequence didn't last too long, and the rest of Meredith's story for the episode is the usual emo should-I-or-should-I-not-be-with-Derek. Meredith thinks that perhaps her dreams are just her fears of not getting a happy ending, and she of course talks Cristina's ear off about the whole thing. When the episode started, I couldn't really think much beyond, "omg, are Meredith and Cristina still complaining about their personal lives in front of strangers when they're supposed to be acting like professional surgeons?" And the answer is yes. Towards the middle of the episode, however, I was shocked and pleased when Cristina finally turned around and told Meredith to shut the hell up! Oh yes, and then she followed this exclamation by repeating it: "Consider the possibility of shutting the hell up!" It's ABOUT TIME that Cristina finally gets fed up with Meredith's constant blabbering. But then, tragedy of tragedies, Cristina gets IMPALED WITH AN ICICLE as some kind of existential punishment for finally putting Meredith in her place. What kind of weird justice is that?! If you ask me, Meredith should have been the one to get impaled.

At the end of the episode, Meredith tells Cristina that she needs her to be the friend that tells her that she can make it with Derek, because if she doesn't have Cristina's support she's going to fail no matter what. Well, way to go Meredith -- there's nothing better than asking your best friend to lie to you, thus ensuring that she's never comfortable expressing her true opinions again.

Also, the show sadly decided to bring up that whole "you're my person" thing again -- that was cute once, but we really didn't need to go there again. Meredith tells Cristina "you're my person," and I was willing to let it go -- I remember the moment distinctly: I started giggling a little bit in my chair, and I said "No, it's okay just once, maybe it's a little cheesy but I can deal." A little bit of dialogue takes place, and then when Meredith asks Cristina if she's only saying what she thinks Meredith will want to hear, Cristina says, "I am your person!" And I pretty much started laughing so much at the idiocy of it that I didn't hear the rest of that conversation.

Oh, well, I'm sure I didn't miss much.

So basically Meredith's character hasn't evolved much at all since season one -- she's still afraid of "getting her happy ending" and still does nothing but complain and whine about how crappy her life is and contemplating why it is that she's so "dark and twisty."

I'm torn about Cristina in this episode. I like that she finally told Meredith off, but I'm sad that she backed down so quickly at the end of the episode. What she should have told Meredith is, "No, bitch, I'm not going to lie to you and compromise my integrity just to make you feel better." And instead she said, "I am your person, la la!" Okay, maybe she didn't sing, but considering how cheesy that moment was I probably wouldn't have been surprised if she had.

One of the highlights of this episode was an army trauma surgeon that comes in with some trauma victims -- after Cristina finds out that he trach'd a guy with a ballpoint pen, her response is "Hot!" After she gets impaled with the icicle, he's the one who finds her and eventually gives her medical care. He tells her that she's too good for this hospital and should do what he does, trauma surgery in the military, where things are more spontaneous and exciting. Cristina of course tells him that things can be spontaneous and exciting at Seattle Grace and she doesn't want to leave, but all I could think was, "Yes, Cristina, please go off with

September 26 2008 at 3:57 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to adela.t4's comment
Sandy

As a reader, it's actually annoying to see your entire lengthy blog post pasted here on *someone else's* blog. It interrupts the flow of conversation, almost as if someone has barged into a crowded room and started lecturing loudly about your own opinion and handing out copies of her latest book.

At the most, all I'd be interested in seeing is an excerpt of your post and link to your blog.

September 26 2008 at 9:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
khia213

This is the first time I've watched this show and I only watched for Kevin McKidd. I don't think I can do it again even though I think he's sex on a stick. The show is too whiney, neurotic and utterly unrealistic. Back to my Rome dvds.

September 26 2008 at 1:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to khia213's comment
BC McKinney

Rent "Bedrooms and Hallways." Lucius Vorenus and Marc Antony get it on. But don't tell Renee.

September 26 2008 at 3:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
BC McKinney

"That line Hahn hit her with was gold. The one about how she lacks general surgery knowledge because she spends too much time on cardio-thoracic stuff. She's not as good as she thinks."

And yet, the story line last season was Hahn's refusal to teach Christina, until she finally had to beg. But now Hahn's resentful when Richard tells her she needs to improve her teaching skills (why doesn't he talk to Sloan as well, btw). Although her attempts understand the other doctors' teaching styles were some of the funnier bits of the episode.

September 26 2008 at 1:48 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners