I also enjoyed the show. I mean it wasn't The Office's best episode but it was still good. It was a bummer that Michael and Holly broke up, although it was more angst than funny it showed more depth to Michael and I wanted to cheer when he admitted at the end that he hated Jan. I thought it was brilliant on Dwight's part to try to goad Andy into another office explosion! Too funny. I'm not sure where they're going with Jim and Pam and it makes me nervous, of which I'm sure the writers intend. Shouldn't Pam be back at the office by now? Especially if it is Halloween? I thought it was three months. Hmmm.

And I thought the Joker thing was a really good satire of how obsessed everyone seems to be with the Joker and how pretty much everyone tries to imitate his voice, often badly.

You know, I've found that the less criticism of the show I read the more I enjoy it.

This episode was great. I don't get you people, they did the same stuff they always do and to me it seems you can't get over the fact that they brought couples together to take them apart again now.

It more and more looks as if Jim and Pam will break up in the finale of this season. I thought they would do it earlier but I guess they expect the show to go on for another two years after that which need to be filled.

Someone commented that this did not seem like something Dwight would do......

On contrary, its CLASSIC Dwight....it's exactly the sort of childish thing that he used to when Jim would egg him on.

I dont know what everyone is complaining about, I thought this was a good episode focusing more on emotion than laughter, which i think is ok every now and than. I defenintly think that dwight was trying to get to andy so he would snap and get fired so he could have angela to himself. I liked the Michael and Holly stuff because i thougt it was a fitting ending to their relationship and showed us that michael did indeed not like Jan. I thought that the Jim/Pam stuff was the weakest storyline of the episode. Although I thought it would be interesting if at the end of the episode Pam said "Yeah your brothers thought it would be funny to make fun of me like they did your old girlfriend that was an artist", then Jim saying, "I never dated another artist before".

The double shrug was something I caught on the second viewing (I may not have TiVo at school, but my VCR performs the same duty albeit the old-fashioned method).

I think this episode felt off mainly because of the extra plot building on the part of Michael & Holly, and the lack of humor that could be injected into it. After all, haven't a fair portion of us been enthralled by Amy Ryan's character? Her transfer couldn't be summed up by one scene.

Also:

"Stop saying WE!!!"...followed later by Andy dumping his coffee after Dwight did a cup clink with a clear smirk

Kelly as Carrie Bradshaw-HILARIOUS!

Just rewatched the intro and realized that they split two days between the open and the rest of the show. But when did Pam start working for Dunder Mifflin in New York?

I liked the episode it was alright not the greatest but still fun. I think the part with Andy and Dwight was good fun. I really thought the ending was great Andy trying to be Dwight and sucked at it.

Holly will be missed I liked that Mike had some one finally that got him.

Darryl was pretty cool I so think Darryl should get his own spin-off the Warehouse. We already now about him and it would be pretty neat. Also I wonder if you could get Pam's ex back on the show.

I do think the show should have been all about Halloween.

Because to me I think that story line would have been more fun.

Three people as the Joker. Two good one bad. Creed really out did himself. Dwight did not have the feel of the Joker as Creed did but Dwight went all out on his costume.

I would have loved to have seen who would have won for best dressed for Halloween.

I also think you could have done some good parts with Pam at corporate. I really would have like to have seen what they would have called her.

Again I think the Halloween show would have been better.

But I guess the people making the Office thought people would have liked the show they gave us instead.