Powered by i.TV
February 9, 2012
 
CONNECT    

Dollhouse: Target

by Brad Trechak, posted Feb 21st 2009 10:02AM
Dollhouse(S01E02) In what was seriously a step up in show quality, Dollhouse gave us its version of the short story "The Most Dangerous Game". In effect, humans hunting humans with lethal weapons. I'm surprised the concept isn't a Fox reality show yet.

Episodes that fill back story always enrich a series (and remain one of Whedon's strengths). A good example of this sort of story is "Out of Gas" from Whedon's previous television show Firefly. I've also seen the concept in Torchwood and The Sarah Connor Chronicles. In this case, we learn about Boyd Langton's introduction to the Dollhouse and the nature of his relationship with Echo.

Now we have a potential Moriarty to Echo's Sherlock Holmes in the form of Alfa (which is spelled that way and not "Alpha" in the NATO phonetic alphabet). It's uncertain as to whether Richard himself was Alfa, but if he was, it would have been likely that Adelle DeWitt would have recognized him in his initial interview (unless plastic surgery was involved). Thus, that seems unlikely. Had he been, it would have added a level of complexity to his name since hunting is such an alpha-male sport (much as how Echo lives up to her name by containing traces of memories).

If Richard wasn't Alfa (which is likely), then he still had an appropriate name since he was such a Dick. However, it also leads to a mess of questions (some of which were expressed by characters in the episodes). Does Alfa remember his experiences with the Dollhouse? How did he know the exact methodology of getting past their screening process like that? It seems like an inside job to me. The only question we got an answer to was the fate of all of Richard's ex-girlfriends.

After establishing their relationship throughout the story, it was somewhat unbelievable that Langton would abandon Echo (or her current personality, Jenny) to fend for herself against Richard. Granted, he was injured, but it still seemed out of character. At least he was in character during the handler/handlee hug.

Favorite line of the episode: as Echo was cocking her gun..."I had four brothers, none of them Democrats."

I have no doubt the audience will be introduced to Alfa at some point, probably this season. If Richard rated as "moderate" danger, I can't wait to see what intense danger looks like.

Agent Ballard had a minor role this week, essentially investigating last week's episode (and dealing with the subtly amorous intentions of a shy neighbor).

Amy Acker still looks adorable even with her scars. Did anybody else catch the use of the phrase "Tabula Rasa" and note that it was the title of a Buffy episode, or am I alone in being that much of a geek?

This week's opening with white-water rafting was very similar in theme to last week's opening on motorcycles. I wonder if that will be a recurring motif of the series.

The episode was definitely a step in the right direction for the series. Many questions remain, but that's why we tune in next week, same Doll time, same Doll channel.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

38 Comments

Filter by:
raith

"Alfa" or "Alpha"? The spelling "Alpha" is used in English versions of the phonetic alphalbet. British Armed forces and other exclusively English speaking organizations employed this spelling. "Alfa" was utilized in international theaters, for consistency.

February 24 2009 at 3:10 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tri

We did see Langdon outside of work in the pilot (martial arts gym), and the only way for him to be Alpha would be with multiple personality disorder, which could be interesting, but unlikely.

I agree that Alpha was clearly trying to induce memories in Echo through drugs and extreme stress. To what end is as yet unclear.

Boyd = Alpha is also somewhat unlikely -- presumably, if the Dollhouse caught him, they'd know what went wrong and would not repurpose him w/o first fixing the problem. Thus, if would be unlikely that Alpha would resurface.

I thought this ep was OK in terms of overall plot and backstory development, but I thought the acting/directing was pretty poor. Jenny was all bad-ass up until she became prey, and then suddenly she runs like a little girl, leaving an obvious trail, in panic, etc. And then, she meets Boyd, and does another 180, and turns hunter. It just didn't flow for me. The thrill of it should have excited her, stimulated her, if she were to keep with the character. She should have turned on Richard much sooner.

Finally, as for Richard - Alpha, they didn't say so directly, but the implication was that nothing out of the ordinary happened with this body -- i.e. he was still dead.

February 24 2009 at 1:43 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
clgbutterfly

Instead of complaining about the show let's talk about some of the stuff no one's seemed to pick up on.
Alpha is smart, really smart. He was watching the whole time Echo was being chased, he sent the FBI agent the information about Echo/Caroline and he already had a connection with Echo when he went crazy leaving her alive and now trying to get her to become Caroline again. He's also still a psychopath because he murdered the people of the house he was sitting NAKED in when sending the info to the FBI.
Secondly I think the original concept for Dollhouse was different probably set in the near future and was probably a powerful Corp. I also don't like that no one at the FBI thinks its real, but its there. It aso gives our storyline a twist when Echo does realize who she is and the FBI agent goes rogue. The show seems very Aliaseque.
Finally, I also find it odd that Langdon is this loyal lapdog, but in my mind I wondered if he is also a doll. We don't seem him outside of work and he pretty badass. Its completely plausible that the handlers are just like the dolls and programmed.
As for the episode concepts. They are still playing around and taking a very difficult concept and making it pliable not only to viewers, but to corporate hollywood.
Finally I was very happy to see Middleman hotty with his big arm muscles. Hubba Hubba. If they have canceled middleman this guy needs more screentime.

February 23 2009 at 2:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bruce

"Why do we build robots to do things that we, humans, are perfectly capable of doing?"

1) To save on long-term labor costs with an initial capital investment; 2) to perform repetitive actions with speed and consistency to exacting standards and high tolerances; and 3) to work 24/7/365 with no need for sleep, sick-leave, vacation, injury, etc.

Your question presupposes that people are perfectly capable of doing things when in reality, we're very bad at doing most things. Those things that do require a human due to very specialized knowledge and experience, such as surgery, have not (and likely never will be) replaced with robots.

But the dolls are no better than any other human. They can still get sick, break a bone, etc, and they can't build mechanical parts to within one ten-thousandth of an inch the way a robot can, no matter what programming the dollhouse puts into their heads.

February 22 2009 at 5:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bruce

Hutch: but they're NOT perfect! They're healthy and attractive, and in good shape (though surely there are people in better shape), but that's it. First of all, it was explained that they get the programming from real people - so the dolls/actives can't be better than the person from whom their programming originally came. Second, it was explained by Topher that they have to program in flaws like nearsightedness, allergies, asthma, etc. for the programming to work right, or something like that (it didn't make any sense to me). So they have their flaws just like regular people.

As far as I can tell, the only advantage of a doll over a regular professional is that they will have their mind wiped afterwards, and thus they are great when confidentiality is needed. Thus, there are only two legitimate uses for such a person - secret government operations, and criminal actions. If the dollhouse is really so secret and underground, only criminals would be able to find it. You're telling me the FBI can't find it, but a parent with a kidnapped kid, a crazy sportsman, and a Brittney Spearsish teenybopper singer can find and contact the Dollhouse whenever they need it?

Besides, there's a huge disconnect between the dollhouse being some secretive, highly illegal underground operation with an unyeilding FBI agent constantly on the search for it, and the dollhouse renting out its people to save little children and protect innocent people. I thought the point of the show was that the dolls were used to conduct illegal operations. I also thought they'd have some special abilities, somewhat like in The Matrix - they could be programmed with lots of special skills, to always be superduper computer hackers, kung-fu masters, helicopter pilots, etc. That's not the case.

You need a bodyguard, you can hire Kevin Costner, or you can hire some normal person programmed with Kevin Costner's bodyguarding memories for 100 times the price while breaking the law. Hiring the dollhouse certainly constitutes conspiring to break whatever federal laws the dollhouse is breaking such that FBI agent Ballard is after them. It's giving financial support to a criminal organization. Why would anyone do that for no obvious benefit? And again, how can anyone but a serious criminal know how to find/contact the Dollhouse?

Macguffins (I missed the g key on my keyboard) or not, the whole premise of the show makes no sense. It's illogical. I love sci-fi, and there are plenty of great, creative ideas that could be based on mind-wiping and programming people with memories and skills. This one just doesn't make any sense at all. I predict it won't even get a full first season.

February 22 2009 at 4:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to bruce's comment
GerryofNorVA

I'm with you on this, Bruce. Not only does "Dollhouse" fail in its execution to be an intriguing drama, its base premise is just plain flawed as you point out. I know Whedon fanboys/girls want to give it time, but did a run of episodes save Dark Angel, Knight Rider (2008), Swingtown, Pushing Daisies, etc. No, when a show is badly done (or just unappealing) it deserves a mercy killing after its initial six ep run.

February 24 2009 at 12:24 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mb

Perhaps it seems that I'm the only one who thinks that last week's episode wasn't bad at all (especially for a premiere), but this week's episode was rather good especially when it comes to character development.

As much as I like to trash poor writing and lazy development, I think this show is really creative and innovative. Is there anything like this right now on television? No, and that's what makes it unique.

If the Sarah Connor Chronicles were as novel as this show, it wouldn't be facing cancellation at the end of this run. The problem is that Dollhouse is a much better show and clearly outclassing it. Too bad for TSCC.

Can't wait to see what's going to happen on this show next week.

February 22 2009 at 12:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Critic

> If Richard wasn't Alfa (which is likely),
> then he still had an appropriate name
> since he was such a Dick.

How old are you -- 13?

February 22 2009 at 12:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bruce

I just don't see the point of this show. I don't get the point of the Dollhouse. Unless they're having the dolls doing illegal things (quite the opposite), or unless the dolls have superhuman abilities (which they don't), what's the point?

For example, next week Echo is hired to protect a singer. Why would anyone pay an extremely high fee to some secret and illegal underground operation to get a mind-wiped human programmed to be a bodyguard when you can just go out and hire a bodyguard?

The only legitimate purpose of something like a dollhouse would be to use the dolls to act as criminals, to smuggle drugs, sex slaves, etc so if they got caught, they'd have no memories of anything... they're basically expendable. Another legitimate use would be as prostitutes, of course.

But to use them to conduct not only legitimate, but noble services, to help people and make people happy in legal ways, defeats the whole purpose of an illegal underground operation. There's just no real point to this show. I can handle macuffins to move a plot along, but I can't tolerate a show whose sole existence makes no logical sense.

February 22 2009 at 2:49 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to bruce's comment
Hutch

First off, it's MacGuffin. Second, I keep hearing this a lot, that people don't get the point of using the dolls for legal operations. Why would a singer want to hire a doll to use as a bodyguard when there are perfectly wonderful bodyguards out there that aren't dolls? Maybe they could hire Kevin Costner.

The point is that the want someone perfect. Normal people, they have flaws. They drink, they do drugs, they lie about their abilities. With a doll, you get the perfect whatever it is you want. Or at least, it's supposed to be. Let's say I want a maid to come in and clean my house. If I paid a maid service I'd have to worry about them rifling through my things, stealing stuff, finding personal stuff and telling all their maid friends about it. But if I hired a doll, I know I'd get a clean house and that if he/she found anything personal, she'd forget about it by the time my check cleared. That's obviously a simplistic example but you get the point.

The fact that Echo is having flashes of imperfection and that she's growing beyond her programming is the point of the show.

Also, if none of the above made sense, think about it like this: Why do we build robots to do things that we, humans, are perfectly capable of doing?

February 22 2009 at 10:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Simon

To close the "Alfa/Alpha" debate: in non-English countries, the NATO phonetic alphabet does use "Alfa" for "A" -- however, in the US, the ANSI standard is "Alpha", as it is likewise in the British armed services.

Plus, as was pointed out, it clearly shows "ALPHA" on the file folder during the pilot, and second episode recap.

February 22 2009 at 12:42 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
La-Di-Dah

Amy (scar-lady) is working with Alfa?

I still rolled my eyes at this episode (still giving it a chance though) until the very end with the "shoulder to the wheel move" by Echo. That raptured my attention. I will be staying tuned to see if Echo goes "composite" the way of Alfa, or to see what other S**t hits the fan.

February 22 2009 at 12:04 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners