Earth 2100 was terrible and it really shouldn't have been
On Tuesday night, ABC News aired a special: Earth 2100. It was to give us a speculative look at the next 90 years based on scientific analysis and scenarios. The idea was to "scare us straight" with the worst possible scenario, and it was certainly bleak. According to these experts the worst possible scenario has life as we know it eradicated, cities destroyed and the global population dwindling below 3.5 billion. The message is about the importance of taking care of our natural resources and doing something about our negative impact on the planet. Important stuff, yeah?It took me a couple days to figure out how to write about it, because I really hated it and I wasn't even sure why. Maybe it was Lucy's fictional narrative, shown in static drawings instead of computer imagery or special effects. Telling us about the ocean levels rising and changing the map may have had more impact if you'd shown us that map? Hell, their image for the flooding of the subways was a photo of a subway tunnel with poorly layered running water where the tracks are. You're not going to scare people into changing with 1960s era effects.
Maybe I'm spoiled by The History Channel's Life After People and some of their stunning visuals, but I really thought a major broadcast network could have put some money into this program. While I was watching it, I was wondering if Bob Woodruff found this old newsreel story about Lucy and spliced it into Earth 2100.
Hell, the message might have come across better if they'd just dramatized Lucy's story completely. Hire some actor and use real special effects to showcase the world she's living in. Short snippets would have still been effective, but giving viewers a more realistic look at her world would have had more impact than the moving cardboard cutouts animation style they used.
I was glad to see that in the final fifteen minutes, they showed how things didn't have to be this way. I do think it's an important message to get out there, it just looks like ABC kind of dropped the ball on doing so. Luckily, according to the ratings reports, nobody was watching Earth 2100, so maybe someone else can give it another go. Maybe this time with sock puppets?

19 Comments