Things I Hate About TV: Designers' Challenge on HGTV
I went through a very long period when I was rather addicted to the design and makeover shows on HGTV. I loved shows like Design on a Dime and Divine Design and that show where the woman shows you how to take an old hobby horse and recondition it so it can be used as a wine rack. I don't watch them half as much as I used to, but I still like them. They're shows that actually show us how we can redo our rooms and homes easily and without spending a ton of money. I find shows like that useful. I might not do exactly what the hosts say, but they always give me ideas for something I might want to do in my own place.
I can't say that same about Designers' Challenge though. I think this might be the worst show on HGTV, and here's why.
If you've never seen it, here's how it works. A couple wants to redo a room or maybe even a few rooms in their home and three designers battle to see who will get to do it for them. The designers interview the couple, come up with a design plan, and then each designer does a presentation for the couple. The couple then picks the winner and they start the project.
This show fails on several levels. One is the structure of the show. It's tedious, badly edited, and predictable. A lot of shows have a formula, but this one gets to me more than most. Maybe it's the rather antiseptic way the show looks or and the soulless way the host goes about his duties.
The host is Chris Harrison, who is also on The Bachelor. He's better there, because this show doesn't really give him much to do. He doesn't even interview or interact in any way with the couples or the designers. He just sits in a chair in front of the show's lame spinning logo and reads cue cards. It's probably an easy gig, but when the camera is off he must cry or grit his teeth.
Another thing that irritates me? This isn't really a show that the average person can get into. While many other shows on HGTV have something that we can all learn from, how can I identify with a couple who has $40,000 to spend on a new bathroom? It's an immediate turnoff (even if we weren't in this financial/housing mess right now).

165 Comments